6 NOVEMBER 1942

Page 1

THE VICTORY IN EGYPT

The Spectator

HERE can be no question about the brilliance or the decisiveness of the victory at El Alamein. It has been both a generals' and a soldiers' battle, and all three arms of the...

Page 3

RELIGION AND THE SCHOOLS UST forty years after the outbreak

The Spectator

of controversy precipitated 11 by the Education Act of 1902 the President of the Board of Education appears to have the opportunity of achieving something like a complete and...

Page 4

A SPECTATOR 'S NOTEBOOK

The Spectator

across the seas. It has no buildings, nor is it clear where the buildings will be, but it is to begin its career with university extension lectures (extension from what?) to...

Page 5

EGYPT AND RUSSIA

The Spectator

By STRATEGICUS rf HE battle of Egypt now appears to be nearing a climax. Although German reports are being so lavishly issued that one can gather whatever picture suits his...

Page 6

REVOLUTION MEMORIES

The Spectator

By M. PHILIPS PRICE, M.P. N OVEMBER 7th, 1917, in Petrograd—twenty-five years ago—will always be fixed in my memory. I had lived for two and a half years under the Tsar, and...

Page 7

THE TWO FRANCES

The Spectator

By CHARLES d'YDEWALLE So some time in October, little stoves made their appearance in the Hotel des Thermes and Hotel des Bains, with toy chimneys, each of them seeming to...

Page 8

THE CHILD AND HIS SCHOOL

The Spectator

By R. L. ARKELL T HE other day I showed a prospective teacher round our village school. She was young, alert and progressive. Most refreshing. After working several years in a...

Page 10

MARGINAL COMMENT

The Spectator

By HAROLD NICOLSON N all ages and at all places, whether at Nishapur or Babylon, I men and women of sensibility have gathered together into little groups, protecting themselves...

Page 11

THE CINEMA

The Spectator

IF Went the Day Well had been made before the fall of France, no one would have worried overmuch about the military probabilities of the story : Graham Greene's narrative would...

MUNITION WORKERS

The Spectator

THEY sat upon a hill, They could forget The dark oppressive roof-tops of the town. They drank their fill ; The buttercups were wet ; The evening sunlight, webbed and mystical,...

THE THEATRE

The Spectator

MR. RONALD MILLAR, the young author who wrote at sea the new thriller now at the Ambassadors, has very nearly succeeded in planning a complicated and spooky murder play ; but...

Page 12

Sta,—Mr. Horrabin's and Mr. Sanders' letters commenting on Mr. Petei

The Spectator

Wiener's article in The Spectator interest me very much. I have recently met a schoolmistress with whom I tried to discuss Germany the Aggressor (Prof. Hearnshaw). I thought as...

SIR, —Mr. Peter Wiener is surely right in stressing the value

The Spectator

of instruction in the foundations of civic responsibility, and of education in clear thinking, as important factors in post-war rehabilitation. It is strange that so many...

POLITICS AND SCHOOLS

The Spectator

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR Stit,—I read Mr. Wiener's article "Politics and Schools" with particular interest, since I have been preaching the need of definite " political "...

PETAIN-LAVAL

The Spectator

Sta,—May I make two brief notes in the margin of Mr. Harold Nicolson's most interesting "Marginal Comment" on the booklet Petain-Laval? Mr. .Nicolson implies that the really...

FURTHER SPANISH COMMENTARY

The Spectator

SIR, —Mr. Walton comments on my commentary of Professor Allison Peers' Spanish Commentary. I do not know what his defeatist Spanish friends have to do with my remark on the...

LORD BALFOUR AND THE JEWS

The Spectator

SIR, —Permit me to draw attention to two serious omissions in Mrs. Dugdale's most interesting article on Lord Balfour and the Jews in your issue of October 30th. Most...

Page 13

Sta,—Mrs. Dugdale's article on "Lord Balfour and the Jews" is

The Spectator

full ol controversial statements. It ends with one which is the most con- troversial of all, but which is made again and again by Zionists. It is (in Mrs. Dugdale's own words)...

Snt,—The real point about the profit-motive (and it was the

The Spectator

Archbishop's point) was put so perfectly eighty years ago by that inspired (but now neglected) teacher, John Ruskin, that it would, I feel sure, clarify the discussion if you...

HYMNS TODAY

The Spectator

Sut,—While agreeing in a very minor degree only with Canon Fox's criti- cisms of the English Hymnal and Songs of Praise, both excellent books in their special sphere, I feel it...

THE PROFIT-MOTIVE

The Spectator

Sm,---The correspondence in your columns concerning the profit-motive deals with the fact of profit, but not sufficiently with the people who take those profits ; if an...

Page 14

NAVAL CHAPLAINS

The Spectator

S1R,—Mr. Davidson, in The Spectator of October 9th, which has just reached me, asks whether the spiritual welfare of the.numerous Scotsmen strving in the Navy is adequately...

COUNTRY LIFE

The Spectator

IT is a notable fact that gifts of land to the National Trust have never been so big as during the second year of the war. The Trust (which, of course, ought to be national in...

A DIPLOMAT'S DRESS

The Spectator

SIR,—The reminiscences of usually well-informed " Janus " in "A Spectator's Notebook" contain in the allusion to the Genoa Conference of September 30th a slight error which...

BRITTEN'S MICHELANGELO SONGS

The Spectator

sm,—may I, wall all due respect to my friend Mr. Dyneley Hussey, protest against his treatment of Benjamin Britten in your issue of October 30th? After reading his article one...

MAP SCALES

The Spectator

STR,—You write in "Notes of the Week ": "A glance at a large-scale map will show . . ." Surely you mean a small-scale map? In other wars we have all demanded large-scale maps....

Page 16

BOOKS OF THE DAY

The Spectator

Progress of Poesy The Weald of Youth. By Siegfried Sassoon. (Faber and Faber. 8s. 6d.) HAD he lived in the eighteenth century, when some of his favourite nooks and prospects...

Russian Socialism in Practice

The Spectator

The Russian Peasant and Other Studies. Ey Sir John Maynard. (Gollancz. 15s.) SIR JOHN MAYNARD'S acquaintance with Russia goes back to the beginning of the reign of Nicholas II;...

Page 18

A Territorial Settlement

The Spectator

The New Europe. By Bernard Newman. (Robert Hale. As.) MR. NEWMAN is a well-known writer of thrillers and of travel books; he is less well known as a writer on international...

Dr ma and the People

The Spectator

British Dramatists. By Graham Greene. (Coffins 45. 6d.) THERE seem to me only two ways in which you can properly write a very small book about a big subject. You may either...

Page 20

Compete or Co-operate?

The Spectator

British Export and Economic Reconstruction. (The Institute ot Export. 6d.) IMAGINE the following incident. You go up to the newsvendor at the corner of the street and ask him...

Fiction

The Spectator

1 Remember Christine. By Oscar Lewis. (Hamish Hamilton. 8s.1 Crisis in Zanat. By George Malcolm Thomson. (Faber. 7s. 6d.) She Goes to War. By Edith Pargeter. (Heinemann. 95....

Page 21

THE SPECTATOR" CROSSWORD No. 191

The Spectator

IA Book Token for one guinea will i.e awarded to the sender of the first correct solution of this week's crossword to be opened after noon on Tuesday week. Envelopes should be...

SOLUTION TO CROSSWORD No. 189

The Spectator

SOLUTION ON NOVEMBER 20th The winner of Crossword No. 189 is A. E. RIGG, ESQ., Charnwood, Crowborough, Sussex.

Page 22

FINANCE AND INVESTMENT

The Spectator

By CUSTOS THERE is no disputing the strength of the stock markets. Each week the turnover increases and many brokers and jobbers are finding some difficulty in coping with an...