6 OCTOBER 1906

Page 3

BOOKS.

The Spectator

ARISTOTLE'S THEORY OF CONDUCT.* THERE is a mot told of the late Duke of Marlborough which may or may not be true, but which certainly conveys a truth. He is reported to have...

Ettrrarp Oupptrintnt.

The Spectator

LONDON: OCTOBER 6th, 1906.

Page 4

THE PEASANT REVOLT.*

The Spectator

THE late Mr. J. R. Green in one of his least inspired moments declared that the ablest of the Plantagenets was King John. If wasted opportunities and the alternation of courage...

Page 5

THE NIECES OF CARDINAL MAZARIN.*

The Spectator

IT was about four years after his rise to power, quite as much by personal influence with the Queen-Regent as by political talent, that the Italian Cardinal, so well hated in...

Page 6

SKETCHES IN ECCLESIASTICAL HISTORY.* "A stcrpEwr's journey through the world

The Spectator

of books," says Dr. Bigg in his preface, "is not a mere ramble in search of amusement." The "Wayside Sketches," accordingly, constitute together a serious contribution to the...

Page 7

• CURRENT LITERATURE.

The Spectator

HAECKEL AND HIS CRITICS. Last Words on Evolution. By Ernst Haeckel. Translated by Joseph McCabe. (A. Owen. 6s. net.)—Haeckel : his Life and Work. By Wilhelm Mischa. With...

Page 8

ENGLISH LITERATURE IN THE SEVENTEENTH CENTURY.

The Spectator

The Temper of the Seventeenth Century in English Literature: Clark Lectures given at Trinity College, Cambridge, in the Year 1902 - 3. By Barrett Wendell, Professor of English...

THE ORIGIN AND GROWTH OF CORPORATIONS.

The Spectator

Corporations : a Study of the Origin and Development of Great Business Combinations and of their Relation to the Authority of the State. By John P. Davis, Ph.D. 2 vols. (G. P....

Page 9

THE SANITATION OF ARMIES IN THE FIELD.

The Spectator

The Sanitation of Armies in the Field. (Published privately.)— We have received from Dr. Thomas Dewar, Medical Officer of Health for Forfarshire, a valuable pamphlet dealing...

THE MIDDLE EAST.

The Spectator

Western Culture in Eastern Lands : a Comparison of the Methods Adopted by England and Russia in the Middle East. By Arminius Vambery, C.V.O. (John Murray. 12s. net.)—This...

Page 10

TRAVELS AND STUDIES IN RUSSIA.

The Spectator

Russia : Travels and Studies. By Annette M. B. Meakiii. (Hurst and Blackett. 16s. net.)—There is nothing very extra- ordinary, in the sense of original, about this lively,...

THE SCOTS CHURCHES IN ENGLAND.

The Spectator

The Scots Churches in England. By Kenneth Macleod Black. (W. Blackwood and Sons. 5s.)—This well-written and carefully compiled volume will receive a hearty welcome from members...

THE PHILIPPINES.

The Spectator

The Philippine Islands. By Frederick W. Atkinson. (Ginn and Co. 10s. 6d.)—This is one of the most interesting of the many books which have been published on the new possession...

Page 11

FIRE AND SWORD IN THE CAUCASUS.

The Spectator

Fire and Sword in. the Caucasus. By Luigi Yuan. (T. Fisher Unwin. 10s. 6d. net.)—Every portion of the Russian Empire is, of course, of the profoundest interest at the present...

MOTOR-CARS AND USE.

The Spectator

Motor Vehicles and Motors. By W. Worby Beaumont. Vol. IT, (A. Constable and Co. 42s. net.)—The second volume of Mr. .Worby I3eaumont's monumental work on Motor Vehicles and...

TWO ART BOOKS.

The Spectator

Preece. Painted by John Falleylove. Described by the Rev. J. A. McClyinont, D.D. (A. and C. Black. 20s. net.)—The "Description," to speak first of the literary portion of this...

Page 12

DR. MARTINEAU'S PHILOSOPHY.

The Spectator

Dr. Martineau's Philosophy. By Charles B. Upton. (James Nisbet and Co. 7s. 6d.)—Professor Upton has taken advantage of the demand for a second edition of his well-known...

THE SCOTTISH PARLIAMENT.

The Spectator

The Scottish Parliament : its Constitution and Procedure, 1603- 1707. With an Appendix of Documents. By Charles Sanford Terry. (James MacLehose and Sons, Glasgow. 10s.)—" So far...

RICHARD ACLAND ARMSTRONG.

The Spectator

G. Armstrong has drawn for us an attractive picture in describing his father's personality. He was a man who enjoyed life vividly, and had a gift of "getting on" with all sorts...

THE TREE OF LIFE.

The Spectator

The Tree of Life : a Study of Religion. By Ernest Crawley. (Hutchinson and Co. 12s. net.)—The lettering of this volume does not suggest the nature of its contents, and the...

Page 13

FRANCE IN THE NINETEENTH CENTURY.

The Spectator

France in the Nineteenth Century : 1830 - 1890. By Elizabeth Wormeley Latimer. With 22 Portraits. (Hutchinson and Co. 128. 6d. net.)—This is an agreeable and entertaining book,...

IN SEARCH OF EL DORADO.

The Spectator

In Search of El _Dorado. By Alexander Macdonald. (T. Fishes Unwin. 10s. (3c1.)—" These are true romances," testifies Admiral Moresby in his introduction to this volume, "no...

THE ROMANCE OF EMPIRE.

The Spectator

The Romance of Empire. By Philip Gibbs. (Edward Arnold. 6s.)—Although Mr. Gibbs does not wield quite such a fascinating pen as that of Dr. W. H. Fitchett, the prose-Laureate of...

PERSONAL FORCES IN LITERATURE.

The Spectator

"are not intended as contributions to critical literature they are concerned rather with the 'personal equation' of the writers discussed than with the purely literary aspects...

THE WORLD'S DESIRES.

The Spectator

The World's Desires. By Edgar A. Ashcroft. (Kagan Paul, Trench and Co. 10s. 6d.)—" The great majority (almost the entire race) of mankind are to-day mentally in the position of...

t GREATNESS IN LITERATURE.

The Spectator

Greatness in Literature, and other Papers. By W. P. Trent. (George G. Harrap and Co. 5s.)—Professor Trent, of Columbia University, the author of a useful history of American...

ENGLISH PROSODY.

The Spectator

A History of English Prosody from the Twelfth Century to the Present Day. By George Saintsbury. Vol. I., From the Origins to Spenser. (Macmillan and Co. 10s. net.)—The first...

Page 14

History for Ready Reference and Topical Reading. By J N.

The Spectator

Lamed. 6 vols. (W. Heinemann. 126s.)—This is a "new and revised edition" of what may be described as a cyclopaedic dictionary of history. It is arranged in alphabetical order....

Trinity College, Cambridge. By W. W. Rouse Ball. (J. M.

The Spectator

Dent and Co. Is. 6d. net.)—This is one of a proposed series of "College Monographs," and seems exactly suited to its purpose. It is a little book which can be conveniently...

Page 16

Lorimar e Printed by Lovs & Mstcomsox (Limited) at Nos.

The Spectator

4 and 5 Dean Street, Holborn, W.C. ; and Published by Jogs BAKER for the "SPECTATOR" (Limited) at their Office, No. 1 Wellington Street, in the Precinct of the Savoy, Strand, in...

Page 17

Last Saturday at Athens the official investiture took place of

The Spectator

M. Zaimis as High Commissioner of Crete. Delegates of the protecting Powers appeared before the Crown Prince, and upon the consent of the latter being notified, M Zaimis was...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

O N Monday the Viceroy of India received at Simla a deputa- tion, who presented an address from the Mohammedan community of India. The occasion was of the first import- ance,...

M. Lanessan's article on French religious indifference in the Siècle

The Spectator

of September 28th, summarised in the Times of Monday, is worth attentive study. The failure of the repeated attempts of clerical extremists in association with political...

The Times of Tuesday published the Note containing the conditions

The Spectator

on which the Powers are prepared to agree to the increase of three per cent. in the Turkish Customs for a period of seven years. In the first place, certain reforms are de-...

The chief event in Russia during the past week has

The Spectator

been the publication of the Government's agrarian programme. For the moment there is a reaction against revolution among many classes formerly affected by it, a feeling that...

The United States, as we argued last week, have been

The Spectator

com- pelled to intervene in Cuba. Last Saturday Mr. Taft, acting under authority from Mr. Roosevelt, proclaimed himself Pro- visional Governor, and took charge of the...

Noricz. — With this week's " SracreTos " is issued, gratis, a

The Spectator

LITERARY SUPPLEMENT.

.*priciator

The Spectator

, 17 1906 4084.] FOR THD WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, OCTOBER 6, 190G. [ Poszzus ABROAD R REGISTERED Al • PRICE So. NEWSPAPE. I IIT POST...61D. 2o.

* e a The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript, in any

The Spectator

case.

Page 18

Thei inaugural address at the Church Congress, which opened at

The Spectator

Barrow-in-Furness on Tuesday, was delivered by the Bishop of Carlisle, and had for its chief subject the present opportunity of the Church of England. Drawing an instructive...

The Conference of the Amalgamated Society of Railway Servants—the Railwaymen's

The Spectator

Parliament—has held a stormy session at Cardiff. After deciding on amalgamation with the Labour Party—i.e., the group of twenty-nine Members chosen by the Labour Representation...

The Transvaal is preparing for the coming elections, which will

The Spectator

take place at the close of the present year or the beginning of the next. On Tuesday the allotment of new electoral dis- tricts was published. Four country districts, including...

The proceedings at the Church Congress on Wednesday were of

The Spectator

great interest, the mincipal subjects discussed being the new Education Act and the relation of Church and State. On the latter subject Mr. St. Lee Strachey read a paper, in...

During the past week the Secretary of State for War

The Spectator

has made several important speeches on national defence. Speaking at Haddington on Friday week, he urged that economy and efficiency, so far from being antagonistic, went...

To the pressing question of the day, What is really

The Spectator

meant by the Church ? the answer given by the Oxford Movement could no longer be considered either final or decisive, since whether the Church moved or not, the world moved. To...

Page 19

The Gordon-Bennett Cup for the International Balloon Race has been

The Spectator

won by Lieutenant Frank P. Lahm (U.S.A.) The object of the competitors was to stay in the air a minimum period of forty-eight hours, the balloon covering the greatest distance...

At the afternoon meeting, after a paper by Mr. Cripps

The Spectator

on the Church's educational policy containing a statement of the extreme view, Mr. W. Temple, a son of the late Archbishop of Canterbury, read a very courageous defence of the...

Of the other papers read we have only apace to

The Spectator

note that of Sir Edward Russell in vindication of the right of the Church within certain limits to exercise political functions. While holding that active participation in...

Captain Mahan has contributed to the Proceedings of the United

The Spectator

States Naval Institute for June, 1906, a striking paper on the battle of Tsushima, with special reference to the speed and size of battleships. After showing that, as...

We would call the attention of our readers to a

The Spectator

very able and luminous article by Professor Dicey in the current number of the National .Review on the Trade Disputes Bill. Under the title of "A Protest against Privilege," he...

Lord Rosebery made an interesting speech at Bangour (Linlithgowshire) on

The Spectator

Wednesday on the occasion of the opening of a new asylum erected on the villa, or segregate, system by the Lunacy Board of Edinburgh. Lord Rosebery said that in the case of...

Bank Rate, 4 per cent., changed from 84 per cent.

The Spectator

Sept. 13th. Consols (24) were on Friday 864—on Friday week 86t.

Page 20

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

THE UNREST IN INDIA. MINTO deserves much ' credit for his first important utterance,—the answer to the Memorial prepared by the representative Mussulmans of all India. While he...

Page 21

THE OUTLOOK FOR LABOUR.

The Spectator

T HE omens seem to point to serious difficulties in the near future between the Labour Party and othe , sections of the people, as well as within the ranks of the party itself....

Page 22

LORD ROSEBERY ON STATESMANSHIP.

The Spectator

T ORD ROSEBERY may have his defects as a political J leader, but he is admirable as a political moralist. No man is a greater adept at interpreting the careers of his...

Page 23

POLITICAL PARTIES AND THE GROUP SYSTEM.

The Spectator

W HEN Mr. Ian Malcolm, in the current Fortnightly Review, asks the question, "Is the Party System Honest ?" he demands an answer to a problem which belongs peculiarly to British...

Page 24

THE RUSSIAN PEASANT AND POLITICS.

The Spectator

A MONGST the latest reports from Russia there are many stories of agrarian outbreaks. Only two months ago the revolutionary bodies issued a detailed programme, of which a...

Page 25

THE SPOILT CHILD OF THE LAW. by the mere parade

The Spectator

of affluence, only to discover too late that they have mistaken the shadow for the reality. Amongst the many who play at this game of bluff, none is better qualified to succeed...

Page 26

THE SIGNIFICANCE OF LIGHTS.

The Spectator

T HE twilights of autumn offer compensation for shortened length in their cheerful patches of earlier lamplight, and the opportunity of watching from the hill the gradual...

Page 27

A CENTURY OLD.

The Spectator

T HE South-East Wind brought up the snow, and wrapped the common in a dazzling shroud, and then the mild sea-damp that is never long absent from sea-bound Somerset rolled up too...

Page 28

Lin"rE Its TO THE El) um It

The Spectator

PAN-GERMANISM, HOLLAND, AND BELGIUM. [To TUE EDITOR OP THE "SPECTATOR."] Most CHER CosTentee,—Je vous adresse quelques reflexions. que m'a suggerees la reponse de M. Dingeldey...

Page 29

[To TUZ EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR,"]

The Spectator

SIE, — I shall be glad if you can find space in your valuable journal for a few lines on a subject of some importance both to the present and future well-being of this country....

CONTINUATION SCHOOLS,

The Spectator

Cro THU EDITOR OF TRW " SPECTATOR." J SIE;Will you kindly give me space to say a few words in support of Mr. Medd's very able letter in your last issue ? Although a pecuniary...

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR."' SIE,—As one of the

The Spectator

earliest professional supporters; of your experimental scheme of military training at Hounslow, may I be allowed to offer my congratulations to you and Colonel Pollock on its...

SIR, -- In your issue of last week there appears a letter

The Spectator

signed "Volunteer Field Officer." I would not trouble you with further remarks were it not that the position occupied by your correspondent is one through which many of us have...

Page 30

"PRIBBLES AND PR.A13BLES."

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR:] Sin,—The quotation, in your review of Major-General Maxwell's book in the Spectator of September 22nd, of a specimen of Baboo English—" May...

LADY CUMNOR IN "WIVES AND DAUGHTERS."

The Spectator

Ur0 THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR."] Stu,—Your interesting and friendly review of Mrs. Gaskell's " Wives and Daughters" (Spectator, September 29th) has reminded me that...

SENSE OF "LOCALITY" IN ANIMALS.

The Spectator

LTO THE EDITOR OF THE"SPECTATOR."] SIR,—The wiiter of the article on the "Sense of 'Locality' in Animals" in the Spectator of September 29th seems some- what inaredulous...

MRS. GASKELL'S NOVELS.

The Spectator

(To TUE gorroa Or Tali "SrserAToa."] SIR,—The reviewer of "The Works of Mrs. Gaskell" u tho Spectator of September 29th seems to be in error when be says • " It is curious to...

JOHN WESLEY AND ETERNAL PUNISHMENT.

The Spectator

170 THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR."] SIR,—A tradition on this subject may be worth recording, which I received from the late Mr. Teuton, of the Stationers' Company, whose memory...

THE IRISH QUESTION.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or THE .‘ SPECTATOR."' SIR,—Professor Goldwin Smith in last week's issue, for some extraordinary reason, founds his objection to the Govern- ment's Irish measure...

Page 31

BOOKS.

The Spectator

THE SALVATION ARMY AND THE PUBLIC.* THE Salvation Army is a public institution, and as such is not above criticism. The work before us is a severe indictment of the Army and its...

POETRY.

The Spectator

A DREAM GLIMPSE. I CROSSED the ocean in a dream one autumn night, Nor knew at first my landing-place—the Isle of Wight. Beyond a gate a knoll rose steep with fir-trees crowned...

Page 32

DR. LEYDS ON SOUTH AFRICA.*

The Spectator

DR. LEYDS, it appears, has been spending his leisure in preparing an indictment against Britain's policy in South Africa during the past century, and the fintfruits of his toil...

Page 33

INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY.*

The Spectator

ONE of the leading problems of our time is to discover what makes industrial communities prosperous, and what keeps them so. Such real value as can be found in the "fiscal...

Page 34

THE MAGAZINES.

The Spectator

PROFESSOR VATERKRY'S article on " Pan-Islamism " in the Nineteenth Century will be read with special interest at the present juncture in view of the writer's intimate knowledge...

Page 36

NOVELS.

The Spectator

IN THE DAYS OF THE COMET.* Mn. WELLS'S later excursions into fiction—excepting perhaps Hipps—are not designed to satisfy the requirements of novel. readers who merely seek...

Page 37

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

[Under this heading we native such Books of the week as have not Dem ITSCTred for TOVillW in other forme.] The Health of the Nation. Edited by L. Eliot Creasy. (Hugh Rees....

The Belles of Vanden. By G. B. Burgin. (Hutchinson and

The Spectator

Co. 6s.)—This is a Canadian story of the wilds of Vancouver, and in the prologue tells of a marriage between an English settler and a Canadian lady, both of whom take themselves...

Motor Maniacs. By Lloyd Osbourne. (Chatto and Windus 3s. 6d.)—These

The Spectator

little stories are frank extravaganzas founded on the mania for motor-cars, which burns, apparently, even more fiercely in America than in England. The stories will be...

Page 38

Canadian Nationality, and other Essays. By W. Frank Hatheway. (W.

The Spectator

Briggs, Toronto.)—Mr. Hatheway addresses to his Canadian countrymen some vigorous allocutions,— possibly we should not altogether please either him or them by quoting his most...

American Literary Masters. By Leon H. Vincent. (A. Constable and

The Spectator

Co. 88. 6d. net.)—Mr. Vincent gives us here appreciations, together with brief biographical notices, of a number of American writers. Washington Irving, born in 1783, comes...

Humorous Side - Lights on a Scotch Tour. By S. Kathleen Warden.

The Spectator

(Henry J. Drane. 6s.)—The critic who pronounces definitely that a book is or is not humorous is somewhat rash. Mood and circumstances make a difference. A book that does not...

Saydn's Dictionary of Dates. Twenty-fourth Edition. (Ward, Lock, and Co.

The Spectator

21s. net.)—This indispensable book of reference has considerably overpassed its Diamond Jubilee. It was first published in 1841. The projector, whose name it still bears, gave...

Christian Missions and Social Progress. By the Rev. James S.

The Spectator

Dennis, D.D. Vol. III. (Oliphant, Anderson, and Ferrier. 10s. net.)—Dr. Dennis has now brought to a conclusion this vast work, developed, we may remind our readers, from a...

Handbook to the Controversy with Rome. By Karl von Hese.

The Spectator

Translated and Edited, with Notes, by A. W. Streane, D.D. 2 vols. (R.T.S. 21s.)—Karl von Hese was for more than fifty years Professor of Theology at Jena. This work was first...

Syllabus of British History. By C. H. K. Marten, M.A.

The Spectator

(Spottiswoode and Co. 6s.)—This volume includes four parts out of the ten in which it is proposed to complete the work. These four, VI.-IX., include the years 1485-1815. The...

A Book of the Rhine from Cleves to Mains. By

The Spectator

S. Baring'. Gould. (Methuen and Co. 6s.)—Mr. Baring-Gould's book is, as all the admirers of his genius would wish it to be, eminently characteristic. He has a keen eye for...