10 FEBRUARY 1956

Page 3

SPECTATOR

The Spectator

ESTABLISHED 1828 No. 6659 FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 10, 1956 PRICE 7d.

POOR MAN'S ATLANTIC CHARTER

The Spectator

A s was expected, the communique issued after the Washington talks between Sir Anthony Eden and President Eisenhower did not contain any very concrete policy decisions, and the...

DANGEROUS GAME

The Spectator

T HE voters of Malta go to the polls this weekend to decide for or against 'integration' with the United Kingdom. Mr. Mintoff, Prime Minister of Malta, and his Maltese Labour...

Page 4

NO NEW LIGHT

The Spectator

By RICHARD H. ROVERE I T can surely be said that, from the American viewpoint , no harm was done by the Washington conference of the Prime Minister and the President. In this...

FROM THE PIGEON HOLE

The Spectator

NA-a. MACMILLAN made a very bad start in his first pro- nouncement as Chancellor last week. This turned out to be the kind of impeccable, though superficial, diagnosis of the...

BURKE OR GALLUP?

The Spectator

I T can fairly be claimed,' stated the Daily Telegraph this week, 'that public opinion is by no means ready for the abolition of the death penalty.' That many people still...

Page 5

DEFEAT IN ALGERIA

The Spectator

By DARSIE G1LUE Paris oNS1EUR MOLLET'S defeat by the French of Algiers marks the limitation of the theory on which his Governtnent is built. Boldness is not a certain cure for...

Portrait of the Week

The Spectator

FTER the frost the thaw. Householders who have been wrestling with burst pipes and the water boards who have been trying to stop the loss of supplies have been having a bad time...

IN NEXT WEEK'S SPECTATOR

The Spectator

Charles Curran - The Politics of the New Estate D. W. Brogan on H. L. Mencken Christopher Hollis - The Scholar Tipsy

Page 6

Political Commentary

The Spectator

BY HENRY FAIRLIE I N the week of its silver jubilee, the Parliamentary Labour Party has given an impressive demonstration of its new- found confidence. Mr. Bevan ran amok at...

Page 7

Toujours la politesse. A comedian riding down , the King's Road

The Spectator

on a camel the other day took off his hat to an acquain- tance and fell off his camel. This reminds me of a friend of mine, a famous QC, who, riding his bicycle to the Temple...

A Spectator's Notebook

The Spectator

WILLY-NILLY I must return to Section 16 of the Criminal Appeal Act, 1907. This, it may be remembered, is what Mr. Lloyd George said 'prohibited him' from placing , a copy of the...

A FORTNIGHT AGO 1 quoted with some opprobium a remark

The Spectator

Lord Douro was reported by the Evening Standard to have made about a party he gave at Apsley House. I have before commented upon the astonishing inaccuracy of that news- paper's...

During the printing dispute some readers may find that copies

The Spectator

of the Spectator arrive late. We regret any incon- venience that may be caused by circumstances beyond our control.

Page 8

Deus ex Machina

The Spectator

BY CHARLES WILSON* I T is difficult to know what influence the recent publication of material about scientific education in Russia had on the British Government; there can be...

Page 9

The Maltese : a Theophrastian Character

The Spectator

BY CHRISTOPHER HOLLIS H E was born some sixty years ago, the son of a small farmer. At the age of eighteen he ran away from home, seeing that, if he remained in Malta, there...

Page 10

The Steam Whistles Act, 1872

The Spectator

BY JOSEPH DEAN F were a Member of Parliament, endowed with the consti- tutional right to have my questions answered, I would ask the Minister how many prosecutions have been...

The iSvettator

The Spectator

NOTICE has been given by Sir FRANCIS Buaperr, that he will, on the introduction of the Mutiny .Bill, move a clause abolishing the punishment of flogging. Every attempt to...

Page 11

City and Suburban

The Spectator

BY JOHNBETJEMAN T HE extremely clever and rather on-the-defensive introduction by John Summerson to the exhibition of the last ten years of British architecture held at the Arts...

Page 12

The Empire of the Eggheads

The Spectator

/ SHALL be sorry if the Government decide to jam the Greek broadcasts to Cyprus. It is wrong of the Greek Government to use Athens Radio for the purposes for which they are...

Page 14

SIR,—Housing estates have many things to suffer, some of which

The Spectator

are the outcome of their planners and designers. Their hardest lot to bear is those who write about them. Mr. Curran's article is typical of conclusions drawn from looking at...

OXFORD ROADS

The Spectator

SIR,—Mr. John Sparrow, the Warden of All Souls, courteously takes me to task for depict- ing the Oxford road controversy in an unduly lurid light. Indeed, in a somewhat...

SIR,—The Warden of All Souls has a fine vein of

The Spectator

gentle raillery. He has only to extract deftly a few phrases from the context of Mr. Blake's article to make it seem absurd. We all know too the skill of his advocacy,...

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

The New Estate Charles Curran, John O'Leary The John Gordon Society Graham Greene, John Sutra Oxford Roads Robert Blake, P. A. Brunt, Osbert Lancaster Free Elections Peregrine...

THE JOHN GORDON SOCIETY

The Spectator

SIR,—In recognition of the struggle he has maintained for so many years against the insidious menace of pornography, in defence of our hearths and homes and the purity of public...

The Spectator

Page 15

THE NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICE SIR, — Since you appear at last to

The Spectator

have grasped the significance of the NHS, the title of your leading article should have surely been 'The Cost of the Medicine-Bottle.' That expensive bone of political...

SIR, --May I contribute a word or two of com- ment

The Spectator

on Mr. Sparrow's magisterial rebuke to Mr. Blake? Whether or not the latter's account of the Manner in which this totally unnecessary con- troversy has been conducted is wholly...

SIR, — May I congratulate you on the realism of your article

The Spectator

of February 3. While there is much that is excellent in the present Health Service, it is sad to find the Government still wasting much time and money in applying remedies which...

FREE ELECTIONS

The Spectator

SIR, — Nowadays all entertainment is on ice, including your political commentary. Mr. Fairlie seldom just takes one step in an argu- ment at a time but, like an enthusiastic...

Page 16

THE ALTAR

The Spectator

SIR,—The recently reprinted The Altar Steps is the story of the life and spiritual growth of an Anglo:Catholic clergyman up to his ordina- tion and first curacy. But the first...

Contemporary Arts

The Spectator

Poetic or Poetical ? DARKLING CHILD. By W. S. Merwin. (Arts.) THE writing of a modern verse drama is notoriously among the most difficult exercises that a poet can undertake....

SIR,—While we hesitate to prolong a discussion which may have

The Spectator

the appearance of a parochial matter, the issue between the London Transport Executive and ourselves over the Leith Hill bus service reflects in miniature a national contro-...

CHURCH PRESERVATION SIR,—Since Mr. John Betjeman's observations in your issue

The Spectator

of January 13 in effect impute to the Church, or at any rate to its officers, the employment of somewhat shady tactics in achieving the demolition of a church, I am reluctantly...

WILLIAM ARCHER am writing the biography of William Archer, the

The Spectator

dramatic critic, translator of Ibsen, and playwright, and should be grateful for any information your readers can provide. Any letters, press-cuttings, articles, reviews and...

Page 18

Fat and Thin

The Spectator

SUPPORTERS of the movement have sometimes suggested that the large size of many 'New Realist' pictures proves the painters' ambition to make public decorations for public...

Measure for Measure •

The Spectator

I WANT to make it clear that when I was writing recently about the relationship between the Independent Television Authority and one of the contracting companies, Associated...

King Kaye

The Spectator

The COURT JESTER. (Plaza.) The Court Jester finds Danny Kaye in a mediaeval England amusingly if not brilliantly parodied by authors-cum-directors Norman Panama and Melvin...

Page 20

BOOKS

The Spectator

Noble Savage BY PETER QUENNELL C ARLYLE was a professed stoic, totally unacquainted with the virtues of silence. So his loyal but sharp- tongued wife considered; and subsequent...

Page 21

Gurkha Soldier

The Spectator

BUGLES AND A TIGER. By John Masters. (Michael Joseph, 16s.) 'IN England I had tried to ape the fashionable ignorance of India, but now already I found myself resisting England's...

Page 22

Hungarian Threnody

The Spectator

THE MEMOIRS OF MICHAEL KAROLYI. (Jonathan Cape, 35s.) MEMOIRS. By Admiral Nicholas Horthy. (Hutchinson, 21s.) BUT for the war most of us would look on Admiral Horthy as the head...

Proust at the Ball

The Spectator

'I WAS happily sitting with my partner on the gilded chairs tied together with his handkerchief as was the fashion, when I saw a strange sight. Here was Marcel Proust crossing...

Page 24

THE LONG BODY. By Helen McCloy. (Gollancz, 10s. 6d.) Manufactured

The Spectator

suspense thriller, from a writer who can usually be relied on to cajole the reader into accepting an impossible plot before stunning him with a rational solution. Here, however,...

AN ARTIST DIES. By John Rhode. (Geoffrey Bles, 10s. 6d.)

The Spectator

Dogged detection by Inspector Jimmy Waghorn, after a com - mercially successful painter, much envied by colleagues at the local Art Club, is found dead in a farmer's...

Eyes and Legs

The Spectator

EYE WITNESS. By Noel Monks. (Frederick Muller, 16s.) AMONG the illusions that die hard is the one about war correspon- dents being the romantic, adventurous figures they were...

THE FRAZER ACQUITTAL. By Stephen Ransome. (Gollancz, 10s. 6d.) Another

The Spectator

novel which leans heavily on contrivance. A New England lawyer, engaged simultaneously in defending a client charged with murder and shielding the woman he believes to be...

It's a Crime

The Spectator

THE BLUNDERER. By Patricia Highsmith. (Cresset Press, 15s.) Relentlessly single-minded novel of suspense, as tactically ingenious as Miss Highsmith's earlier Strangers on a...

A Stitirr OF GUILT. By John Bude. (Macdonald, 10s. 6d.)

The Spectator

Murder of an art student in an English country town, setting a satisfactorily tricky problem for a cautious police inspector. Reliably constructed, in spite of a solution which...

DARLING CLEMENTINE. By Dorothy Eden. (Macdonald, 9s. 6d.) Cosy Kensington

The Spectator

melodrama, with a tearful and bedridden heroine who worries about her 'tainted blood' inherited from a pirate ancestor, hears ghostly voices in the middle of the night, and...

THE HOUSE THAT DIED. By Josephine Gill. (Crime Club, 10s.

The Spectator

6d.) Murderous happenings in an old house in Boston's Back Bay, where first the aged Miss Bellamy's companion and then Miss Bellamy herself are found mysteriously dead....

THE CASE OF THE NEGLIGENT NYMPH. By Erle Stanley Gardner.

The Spectator

(Heinemann, 10s. 6d.) 'Boy, the way you managed to keep Gloster all tied up in knots, even when he had you on the run as far as the facts were concerned, is one of the greatest...

Page 25

Dear Eddie

The Spectator

LORD EDWARD FITZGERALD. By Patrick Byrne. (Staples, 12s. 6d.) The Wildes of Merrion Square revealed talent enough in Patrick Byrne to suggest he would make a worthy biographer...

Stale and Flat

The Spectator

SWEET AND SOUR. By John O'Hara. (Cresset Press, 12s. 6d.) THIS is a collection of short pieces written for the book page of a New Jersey Sunday paper. There is very little...

THE SMILING SPIDER. By Leonard Halliday. (Hammond and Hammond, 9s.

The Spectator

6d.) Eventful. thriller, with an Austrian mountain setting, in which an English fencing instructor, once a Labour MP, finds himself entangled in an inordinately complicated spy...

Mirrors of the Sea

The Spectator

THE first two of these books are both to do with the sailing of small craft for pleasure, yet they could hardly be more different in con- tent. In The Crest of the Wave, Uffa...

Page 26

New Novels

The Spectator

THOUGH not necessarily, as some people might claim; artistically immoral, propagandist fiction tends to be tedious, and it is a measure of Edith Pargeter's skill. and of her...

Page 28

COMPANY NOTES

The Spectator

By CUSTOS THE Chancellor's first speech 'pulled the plug out' of the recovery in the stock markets which had developed towards the end of last week. Although it had been denied...

THE WRITING ON THE TREASURY WALL

The Spectator

By NICHOLAS DAVENPORT IT is certainly 'a matter of the most desperate urgency,' as Mr. Macmillan told the National Production Advisory Council last week, 'that the whole...

Page 29

FROZEN POND

The Spectator

When I visited it, the pond was frozen, and the ice was covered with a confectioner's dust- ing of snow. I stood and looked around for a while, admiring the glitter of sunlight...

Country Life

The Spectator

BY IAN NIALL FOR me, at least, trees arc as much part of a place as the habitations of man. At the ap- proach to a village on a hill near us two trees were to be seen until a...

Chess

The Spectator

BY PHILIDOR No. 36. G. HUME (2nd Prize, 'Good Companions,' 1921) WHITE: (II men) BLACK (14 , men) WHrfE to play and mate in two moves: solution next week. Solution to last...

OWL TALK Curiosity may have killed the cat, but the

The Spectator

poor cat is not the only creature afflicted With curiosity. I came along the side of the wood just before dusk and heard the first owl call up in the pine trees. Something...

EARLY SOWING

The Spectator

Boxes of healthy leek and onion seedlings are to be prized when it comes to laying out the vegetable garden. In wet or hard weather, when little can be done outside, it pays to...

Page 30

Your Baby's Story books have such entries as : 'first

The Spectator

recognised daddy,"birth - day—how celebrated, those present, gifts, etc.,' first brushes own teeth' and so on. A prize of £5 is offered for a similar record of stages in the...

SPECTATOR CROSSWORD No. 874

The Spectator

ACROSS 1 Shades of the RAF! (6, 7) 9 Headgear for a Ctinadian hero (9). 10 How old is the moon? (5) 11 The artist is here to stay (5). 12 Hid spiral (anag.) (9). 13 Backward...

The winners of Crossword No. 872 arc : MRS. AYMEI

The Spectator

V. PATTERSON , 65 The Rise, Glasnevin, Dublin, and MRS. B. TOCHER, 23 Woodside Road. Worthing, Sussex. 1

Bunkered Browning

The Spectator

There has recently been published a History of Golf by Robert Browning. Competitors were asked to imagine that this was the work of the poet, and for the usual prize, to provide...