14 JANUARY 1922

Page 1

When the Supreme Council of the Allies met at Cannes

The Spectator

on Friday, January 6th, Mr. Lloyd George proposed that all the European Powers, including Germany and Russia, should be summoned to an economic and financial conference, in...

We are delighted that Mr. Lloyd George should have offered

The Spectator

to put in writing the promise to do what everybody knows we should have to do in any case—that is to say, help France if Germany again attacks her wantonly. We are very glad...

The memorandum which contains this draft agreement is very considerate

The Spectator

towards France. It affirms that Great Britain fully recognizes France's ground for anxiety and expresso the desire to do " all in her power to allay it." It remarks that Germany...

Mr. Lloyd George admitted that there was a very natural

The Spectator

prejudice against the Bolsheviks. " But there is much greater danger from Bolshevism if we fail in the task of reconstruction than there is from propaganda which the Bolsheviks...

The papers of Thursday contained the draft proposal for guaranteeing

The Spectator

French security. It provides that we should help France with our whole naval and military forces in the event of direct and unprovoked aggression by Germany against France. It...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

T HE promising forward movement of Mr. Lloyd George's ideas for composing international relations and for reviving the trade of the world has suffered a check, though we hope...

TO OUR READERS.

The Spectator

Readers experiencing difficulty in obtaining the " Spectator " regularly and promptly through the abolition of the Sunday post or other causes should become yearly subscribers,...

Page 2

The Finance Committee of the French Chamber, on Tuesday, expressed

The Spectator

" profound uneasiness " at the ".fresh infringement of French lights " which.appeared to be threatened by the Cannes Conference, and reminded the Government of " its undertaking...

The situation in Ireland is that the Treaty has at

The Spectator

last been accepted by the Dail Eireann, said that Mr. Griffith has been elected in the place of Mr. De Valera as President. Prepar- ations, are now going on-to form the...

The Conference on Saturday last adopted a similar resolution -binding

The Spectator

the five Powers not to use " asphyxiating, poisonous, and other -gases and all analogous liquids, materials and-devices " in war among themselves and inviting other nations-to...

On Tuesday, the election of Mr. Griffith in place of

The Spectator

Mr. De Valera was carried. Mr. De Valera then walked out of the Chamber followed by all his supporters. On Thtusday, the with- drawal of the British forces in Ireland began and...

We are glad to learn from the Palestinian. Arab. Delegation

The Spectator

that they have not left England, as we were misled into saying last week. They have, it seems, growing hopes that the case whioh they have presented so ably and temperately in...

The General Election rumours set -afloat a fortnight ago by

The Spectator

the Coalition Libemkrraised a sharp - controversy between the two patties supporting the Government. Sir George Younger, the chairman of the National Unionist Association, who...

The Washington Conference on Thursday, January 5th, adopted the resolutions

The Spectator

concerning -submarines, which were moved by Mr. Root and enlarged by 'Mr. Balfour. The five naval' - Powers reaffirmed the international law requiring sub- marine commanders to...

The Allied representatives then adopted the resolution proposed by Mr.

The Spectator

Lloyd George. It declared that the develop- ment of the resources of all countries was necessary to increase employment and relieve the widespread suffering of Europe. All...

In reply to Lord Curzon, M. Montille, of the French:

The Spectator

Embassy, said that France could not continue hostilities with the Turks and had therefore to conclude " an arrangement of local signifi- cance," by which she evacuated Cilicia....

The Foreign Office published last Saturday the correspondence with the

The Spectator

French Government about the Angora agreement concluded by M. .Franklin-Bouillon with --Mustaphs, Kemal. Lord Curzon, on November 5th last, expressed his .surprise and dismay at...

We must summarize the events-which led up to this situation

The Spectator

very briefly indeed. Last Saturday the wearisome debate in the Dail, full of cross purposes and bitterness, came-to a head, and the motion for approving the Treaty was carried...

On Saturday last the Supreme Council, at the instance of

The Spectator

Mr. Lloyd George, invited Germany to send representatives to Cannes. It is stated that the Allied experts agreed to reduce the payment to be made by Germany this year, fixing it...

Page 3

The official report on the conduct of Sir Edgar Speyer

The Spectator

during the War was issued on Friday; January 6th. The Committee said that they were satisfied that Sir Edgar Speyer " had ceased to entertain any feeling of loyalty to His...

Sir Edgar Speyer himself also issued in New York a

The Spectator

reply to the report. The sense of his defence was that the charges were trivial and grotesque ; that his accusers evidently did not understand the elements of international...

The great danger with all organizations is, of course, that

The Spectator

a list of desirable families, however valuable it might be at first, would tend to become conventional or professional. The Pecksniffs and the " good Christian homes " might...

Coke's Institutes describes the oath of office as it was

The Spectator

anciently administered to every Privy Councillor. Among the obligations which the Privy Councillor accepted were the following : "To forward and help the execution of whatsoever...

Our readers may remember that in our issue of December

The Spectator

31st we published a letter from " An -Anglo-Indian Mother," who asked whether it would be possible to get into touch with "kind, jolly, well-bred people " in England, who would...

What we want to tell our readers now is that

The Spectator

the effect of this very touching letter has been astonishing. We have already received some ninety answers and they still come. We have forwarded many of them to the writer of...

We are glad to record that the Ministry of Health

The Spectator

has appointed a small committee to inquire into the charges against our pauper asylums - brought by Dr. Lomax in his book The Experiences of an Asylum Doctor. They are to have...

The rainfall in 1921 was so exceptionally light that it

The Spectator

is not surprising to find the Ministry of Health. expressing concern about the water supply. The wonder is that the supply for the great towns has been maintained for so' long'...

Bank Rate, 5 per cent., changed from 5i • per

The Spectator

cent. Nov. 3, 1921 ; 5 per cent. War Loan was on Thursday, 92i; Thursday week, 91i ; a year ago, 831.

Page 4

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

MR. LLOYD GEORGE'S ACHIEVEMENTS AND THE OPPORTUNITY THEY AFFORD HIM. W E have often had to express in plain terms strong disapproval of Mr. Lloyd George's actions—actions which...

Page 5

IS THE " SPECTATOR " " BITTERLY HOSTILE " TO

The Spectator

AMERICA ? W E recently noted that the editor of a distinguished American newspaper, the Baltimore Sun, had received protests in regard to the London Spectator. The writers...

Page 6

THE PROSPECT IN IRELAND. T HE Moderates in Dail Eireann have

The Spectator

passed through the ordeal of coming under fire for the first time and have emerged from the test with their ranks unbroken and with steady nerves. This fact gives us real hope...

Page 7

MR. KEYNES'S BOOK.

The Spectator

W HEN Mr. Maynard Keynes- published his first book about the Peace settlement, entitled The Economic Consequences of the Peace, he startled the world and made a great name. He...

Page 8

MOLIERE. T HERE is in the Louvre a portrait by an

The Spectator

unknown artist " which lights the small room in which it hangs like a flame," says Michelet. The dark face, kindly and thoughtful, with the full lips, the rather thick nose, the...

Page 9

BY-LAWLESSNESS.

The Spectator

N O one not a criminal is lawless in any large sense, but a great many excellent folk are lawless in a small way. They give in on principle to the moral precepts and...

Page 10

FINANCE—PUBLIC AND PRIVATE.

The Spectator

■ •■■41111.■ NEW LOAN SUCCESSES. INVESTMENT STOCKS STRONG — REAPPEARANCE Olr THE " STAG "—TRADE IN 1921—INCOME-TAX CONSIDERATIONS—MAKING HISTORY AT CANNES. [To rur ERITOR or...

Page 12

CORRESPONDENCE. .

The Spectator

THE DISILLUSIONMENT OF FRANCE. [TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] STA.—Loyal to its high traditions of courageous impartiality, the Spectator has repeatedly set before its...

Page 13

THE FALSEST 01 1/4 FALSE ECONOMY.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] Sra,—The prime need of the country at present is to cut down expenses. If every reduction suggested by the Geddes Com- mittee is to be...

IRELAND AND THE RIGHT OF INSURRECTION. [To THE EDITOR or

The Spectator

TIM " Bnernoa."] Seta,—In an article headed " An Imperial Democratic Party," in your issue of December 31st, reference was made to the circum- stances under which the right of...

THE SOUTHERN IRISH LOYALISTS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF TER " SPECTATOR.") SIR,—The Spectator's scheme of compensating Southern loyalists who might wish to leave the country is simply impossible. Who would...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

[Letters of the length of one of our leading paragraphs are often more rcad,and therefore more effective, than those which fill treble the space.] THE " SPECTATOR " AND ITS...

MYTHS OF IRISH HISTORY.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or THE " SPECTATOR.") SIR,—" Exile of Erin's " letter on the above subject encourages me to draw attention, through you, to another current historical myth...

Page 14

A REDUCED GRANT TO THE UNIVERSITIES.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.") enclose a copy of a letter which the sister Universities of Birmingham, Durham, Leeds, Liverpool, Manchester and Sheffield have addressed...

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.")

The Spectator

Sin,—You say that, according to the Burnham Scale, there was to be an increase of about fifty per cent. in teachers' salaries. Here are the figures for a non-provided village...

THE ABBE DE SAINT-PIERRE.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or THE " SPECTATOR.") Sia,—Looking at the course of events, from the constitution of the League of Nations to the Conference at Washington, as tending to ensure...

Page 15

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR,-With the Grammar

The Spectator

School of Aberdeen deserves to be mentioned a small private school, the " Gymnasium," or " Chanonry House School," in old Aberdeen, familiarly known as the "Gym." It was founded...

[To THE EDITOR OF THE 4 ` SPECTATOR."] have read the

The Spectator

letters on dew ponds with much interest. The method of making these ponds in Wiltshire is as 'follows. The site is first excavated and the soil taken out thrown up as a 'bank so...

ABERDEEN AND EDUCATION.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR, It is with no intention to belittle Mr. Pirie's list of famous Aberdonians that I pan this note, still less to minimize the deduction...

DEW-PONDS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR,—How do those who assert that dew-ponds obtain their supply from rain alone account for the fact that •many of them have retained their...

THE TEACHING OF ENGLISH.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] Sia,—Through the Spectator might I offer a suggestion to those engaged in the training of youth to speak well, i.e., the employ- ment of...

Page 16

AMERICAN AUTHORS AND GREAT BRITAIN. [To THE EDITOR OF THE

The Spectator

" SPECTATOR."] SIR,—Many are bound to appreciate your admirable support to the friendly relations between Britain and America. In these fateful days of international politics it...

AUTHORS' FAVOURITE WORDS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR,—There is one prominent contemporary English writer who so far has had scant notice in your columns; he is serious, moral,...

REVOLUTIONARY PROPAGANDA AMONG CHILDREN. [To THE EDITOR or THE "

The Spectator

SPECTATOR."] Sin,—May I suggest that one of the most effective items in the campaign against this form of anarchy would be to send adequate reinforcements to all Christian and...

REIMS CATHEDRAL AND A RECITAL. [To THE EDITOR OF THE

The Spectator

" SPECTATOR."] SIR,—As a supporter of the British Empire Fund for the restoration of Reims Cathedral I should like to be allowed to tell your readers about a recital which is...

LINKS WITH THE PAST.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR,—A few dates known to me are more remote than those of your correspondent "J. G. B." My paternal grandfather was born in 1722, died...

LONGEVITY.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP TILE " SPECTATOR."] Sur,—Two or three years ago you mentioned in your columns some unusual instances of Ibilgevity. On September 3rd, 1921; the last of two...

THE SERVANT PROBLEM.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] Sur,—Perhaps your recent correspondents are delicate people. If so, they have my sincere sympathy. These are great days for all manner of...

A PSYCHOLOGICAL CHRIST.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECT/ITOR."] SIR,—Most readers will agree with your reviewer that certain features of the Freudian theory, always unwholesome, become poisonous when...

Page 17

A CORRECTION.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR,—In the review of Callimachus there is in the quotation of Cory's translation a slight error—perhaps hardly worth noticing. " With...

A WINTER BUTTERFLY. [To sus EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR."]

The Spectator

Sra„—In this week's issue of the Spectator I read that a "red admiral was. seen in Pembrokeshire on Christmas Day. Curiously enough, I found a very beautiful one the Sunday...

POETRY.

The Spectator

THE JEALOUS GODDESS. Idn.Exus left the mainland On a floating barrel of wine, His sail was plaited from peach-leaves, and The loaves of the fig and the vine. Small waves...

M IT S I C .

The Spectator

CAMILLE SAINT-SAINS.* STPaNGELY enough, the first English biography of the late M Saint-Salina was published a few weeks before he died. Mr. nervey, who has written it,...

The Editor cannot accept responsibility for .any article, poems, or

The Spectator

letters submitted to him, but when stamped and addressed envelopes are sent he will do his best to return contributions in case of rejection. Poems should be addressed to the...

NOTICE.—When " Correspondence" or Articles are signed with the writer's

The Spectator

name or initials, or with a pseudonym, or are marked " Communicated," the Editor must not necessarily be held to be in agreement with the views therein expressed or with the...

Page 18

BOOKS.

The Spectator

THE STORY OF JOB.* THE -Hebrew school of Wisdom writers reached the highest expression of its poetical genius in the Book of Job. -But the Book is much more than great poetry ;...

Page 19

NATIONAL WELFARE AND NATIONAL DECAY.* PROFESSOR MeDoneaea, the well-known American

The Spectator

writer on group psychology, draws an alarming picture of the racial suicide which he says is going on in England, France and America. The nations are breeding, he says, from the...

MEMOIRS OF THE FRENCH REVOLUTION.*

The Spectator

Tns revolution in Russia, with all its appalling consequences, has imparted a fresh interest to the study of the French Revolu- tion, the painful lessons of which have been...

Page 20

EUROPE—WHITHER BOUND ?*

The Spectator

Ma. STEPHEN GRAHAM'S book of letters from the capitals of Europe, which he visited in 1921, has plenty of good reading in it, whether we judge it by its observation or its...

Page 21

SOME RECENT WAR BOOKS. * AMONGST the military sentiments emphasized by

The Spectator

the late War may be counted that variety of esprit de corps which is known as esprit de division. To the majority of infantry officers and men, indeed, the division in which...

THE HAPSBURG SECRET TREATIES. * PROFESSOR CoounciE, of Harvard, has edited

The Spectator

a second volume of the English version of Professor Pribram's remarkable work on The Secret Treaties of Austria-Hungary, made between the years 1879 and 1914, which will be...

Page 22

THE WISDOM OF Mt, BEASTS.* HAVING been accused of an

The Spectator

over-use of technical terms in his serious books, Mr. C. A. Strong has written ten philosophical fables, in which he seeks to make honourable amends. His arguments, put into the...

AN ENCYCLOPAEDIA OF RELIGION - Si - Tax student who takes up this

The Spectator

" Encyclopaedia of Religions the Deities, Sacred Books, Rites and Ceremonies, Institutions, Sects, &c., among the ancient Babylonians, Egyptians, Hebrews, Greeks, Romans and...

Page 23

FICTION.

The Spectator

VOCATIONS.* THE reader, on closing Mr. O'Donovan's book, will probably feel, so far as the work as " a thing in itself " is concerned, astonish. ment at Mr. O'Donovan's...

INDIAN MONUMENTS.

The Spectator

Iar the Annual Report of the Director-General of Archaeology in India for 1918-19 (Calcutta : Superintendent of Government Printing, 2 rupees), Sir John Marshall is once again...

STRATFORD-ON-AVON RECORDS.

The Spectator

THE Dngdale Society, formed two years ago to promote the study of Warwickshire history by printing MS. records, has its home at Shakespeare's Birthplace, Stratford-upon-Avon. It...

ABOUT COLLECTING.

The Spectator

PSYCHOLOGISTS can supply an unattractive, if not actually repellent, explanation of the motives at the back of the amateur collector's mind when he genially displays his...

Page 24

POETS AND POETRY.

The Spectator

WHEELS, 1921.* I DO not think that this Sixth Cycle of Wheels is as attractive as usual. Mr. Aldous Huxley's " Picture by Goya "—a scene of murder elegant as some Dejeuner Sur...

Poems : 1916-1920. By John Middleton Murry. (Richard Cobden-Sanderson. es.

The Spectator

net.)—Poems by the well-known critio. NEw EnrrroNs.—Moral Erabkrna. By Robert Louis Stevenson. (Chatto and Windus. 5s. net.)—Four Plays for Dancers. By W. B. Yeats. (Macmillan...

Mr. Paul. By Gertrude Bone. (Jonathan Cape. 12e. 6d. net.)—Mr.

The Spectator

Paul is a country chronicle. It describes a few months in the life of an English village, and as a book it has many characteristics in common with the men and things of which it...

OTHER NOVELS. —In Ghostly Company. By Amyas Northcote. (John Lane.

The Spectator

7s. 6d. net.)—For some reason the supernatural appears to be considered appropriate reading for long, dark evenings. This book of stories is very unequal and the author's powers...

Page 25

A Textbook of Geology. By Amadeus W. Grabau. (Harrap. 2

The Spectator

vols. 64s. net.)—Professor Grabau's substantial treatise is well written and very fully illustrated, with special reference to America. The first volume deals with general...

- Science Progress, edited by Sir Ronald Ross, is a

The Spectator

most useful quarterly review of scientific work and thought. In the January number (Murray, 6s. net) we find an article entitled " Scientific Politics. I. Self-Determination,"...

Place Names in Kent. By Canon J. W. Horsley. (Maid-

The Spectator

stone : South-Eastern Gazette. 3s. 6d. net.)—The late Canon Horsley wrote this little book; he tells us, because he found that there was no work dealing with Kentish...

Mr. George Fletcher is editing a set of geographical text-

The Spectator

books on the provinces of Ireland, beginning with Ulster and Munster (Cambridge University Press; 6s. 6d. net each). He interprets geography in the widest sense, and includes...

Europe, 1789-1920. By Edward Raymond Turner. (Heine- mann. 21s. net.)—Professor

The Spectator

Turner, of Michigan University, has produced an uncommonly readable sketch of European history. Viewing our affairs frcm across the Atlantic, he is more dispassionate, perhaps,...

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

[Notice in this column does not necessarily preclude subsequent review.] The Army Quarterly for January (Cloves, 7s. 6d. net) contains several important articles on the history...

The January number of History, the admirable quarterly journal of

The Spectator

the Historical Association (Macmillan, 2s. net), contains the concluding part of a valuable paper by Miss E. Jeffries Davis on " London and its Records." " No city in the world,...

Dr. L. P. Jacks has printed the spirited address on

The Spectator

Education as a Mission which he gave to the Educational Associations on December 28th last (University of London Press, ls. net). He put the claims of education very high...

Princes of the Church. By Sir W. Robertson Nicoll. (Hodder

The Spectator

and Stoughton. 7s. 6d. net.)—The editor of the British IV eekly has collected from its pages thirty-four of his attractive essays on notable divines, including Newman, Liddon,...

Oil Shales. By H. B. Cronshaw. (Murray. 5s. net.)— This

The Spectator

new volume in the Imperial Institute's monographs on mineral resources, with special reference to the British Empire, gives a concise account of the oil shale deposits...

Ypres to Verdun. (Country Life, Ltd. 15s. net.)—Under this title

The Spectator

Sir Alexander Kennedy has collected a large number of photographs of the war areas in France and Flanders that will bring back grim memories to many of us, though his pictures...

Page 26

Queen Alexandra. By W. R. H. Trowbridge (T, Fisher Unwin.

The Spectator

21s. net).—Mr. Trowbridge's book is not exactly a model bio. graphy, but it will have many readers because it deals with a most popular and universally respected lady. It...

WORKS OF REFERENCE.—Willing's Press Guide, 1922 (James Willing, 2s. 6d.),

The Spectator

is the forty-ninth issue of this compact and useful book, which gives first an alphabetical list of journals, then a classified list, and finally a newspaper gazetteer.— The...

Early. American Portrait Painters in Miniature. By Theodore Bolton. (New

The Spectator

York : F. F. Sherman. London : Bromhead, Cutts and Co. 7 dollars 50 c.)—Mr. Bolton's dictionary of Ameri- can miniaturists up to 1850 is a scholarly and useful work. It includes...

Some Political Ideas and Persons. By John Bailey. (Murray. 6s.

The Spectator

net.)—Mr. Bailey has reprinted from the Times Literary Supplement some interesting articles on Disraeli, the elder Fox, Lord Grey of the Reform Bill, Lord Randolph Churchill,...