16 FEBRUARY 1929, Page 30

The method which Professor. H. W. Garrod applies in his

new critical study of, Collins (Clarendon Press, .5s.) is both serviceable and refreshing. He concentrates our logical attention on the poems of Collins ; and it is surprising to note how badly articulated most of them seem after any close examination. Vagueness and obScurity and rampant care- lessness are shown almost everywhere. The only poem which passes the test uninjured is the simplest and greatest, How Sleep the Brave ; even the Ode to Evening contains flaws ; at one point it is downright unintelligible. Professor Garrod's aim is not to be destructive ; and he does not lessen our regard for Collins. He makes it possible, however, to give

him 3t juste'- appreciation. _ ' 4 - . * - . *-