11 DECEMBER 1971

Page 3

STEEL APPEALS

The Spectator

The Government's decision to write off up to 050m of the debts of the British Steel Corporation, and to raise its borrowing limits from £650m to £1,250m is both depressing and...

Page 4

RAISONS D'ETAT

The Spectator

IT IS ,clear enough that the present hostilities between India and Pakistan, which now amount to no less than an undeclared state of war, were begun on their present scale by...

Page 6

THE ,SPECTATOR'Sj NOTEBOOK

The Spectator

There were mutterings in Fleet Street and Westminster on Tuesday evening, and in the papers on Wednesday morning, about the wisdom of the Prime Minister in accepting the huge...

Page 7

POLITICAL COMMENTARY Hugh Macpheiiiiiiil —

The Spectator

"The pacification of Ireland at this moment, as I believe, depends on the concession to Ireland of the right to govern itself ... What is the alternative? Are you content after...

Page 8

EDUCATION

The Spectator

Student cash Anthony Flew The militants of the NUS call it, in their studious non-party way, milksnatcher Mrs Thatcher's threat to bash our unions. It actually is a...

NORTHERN IRELAND

The Spectator

Withdrawal when? John Vaizey A long summer spent reading the papers and watching the television, a summer and an autumn visit to Ireland, and what has happened since then...

Page 10

INDIA

The Spectator

Vishnu's press by A special correspondent William's arrival at the Grand Hotel Calcutta created a sudden resurgence of optimism among the weary press corps in the bar. "If The...

MEDICINE

The Spectator

John Rowan Wilson The problems of junior staff in hospitals are less obvious to most people than those of the general practitioner service, yet every year they are becoming...

Page 13

W. H. Auden on the young Mr Goethe

The Spectator

How wise it was of Goethe to wait until he was over sixty before attempting to tell the story of his childhood, adolescence and early manhood.* Only age can look at youth with...

Page 14

GENTRY BOOKS

The Spectator

for that especial present: like Lady Montagu of Beaulieu's `To The Manor Born' (0.25) `for the woman nearest your heart, an exquisitely beautiful and useful book' (James...

Page 15

Colin Wilson on Denis Wheatley

The Spectator

The Devil and All His Works Denis Wheatley (Hutchinson £4.50) The Ravishing of Lady Mary Ware Denis Wheatley (Hutchinson £2) For some years now I have been intrigued by the...

Page 16

Wise and foolish king

The Spectator

Charles Stuart Charles II: The Man and the Statesman Maurice Ashley (Weidenfeld and Nicolson 0.25) Charles II has always been the most interesting of the Stuart monarchs, as a...

Page 17

Beyond Lyonesse

The Spectator

Norman Hammond The Quest for America Geoffrey Ashe (Pall Mall £5) The Discovery of North America William P. Cumming, R. A. Skelton, David B. Quinn (Elek £10) It has been a...

Page 18

Building blocks

The Spectator

David Watkin William Butterfield Paul Thompson (Routledge and Kegan Paul £10) Pugin Phoebe Stanton (Thames and Hudson £2.95) At last it seems that some of the studies of...

Page 19

Believe it or else

The Spectator

Martin Amis The Guinness Book of Records Ross and Norris McWhirter (Guinness Superlatives E1.10) The review notes to this, the eighteenth edition, give a preview of "a few...

Sharp and Roth

The Spectator

Auberon Waugh The Innocents Margery Sharp (Heinemann £1.50) Our Gang Philip Roth (Cape M.75) , Miss Sharp's latest novel came out in October, un-noticed by any reviewer, so far...

Page 21

Shorter notices

The Spectator

Inglorious Rebellion: The Jacobite Risings of /708, 1715 and 1719 Christopher Sinclair-Stevenson (Hamish Hamilton £2.75) Cni't , cted Papers on the Jacobite Risings Val 1 Rupert...

Page 22

Bookend

The Spectator

It isn't often that publishers bring out books with exactly the same title in the same season, three weeks apart. An occasion for flying fists, bitter recriminations and...

Will Waspe's Whispers

The Spectator

Journalistic naiveté, which I had thought to reside only in the most youthful and starry-eyed of political commentators, survives also, it seems, in show business. The...

Page 23

THE ARTS

The Spectator

ART Going the whole Hogarth Evan Anthony While it is highly unlikely that any divorce court would have accepted it as evidence of mental or any other kind of cruelty, the...

Page 24

CINEMA

The Spectator

Making tracks Tony Palmer I remember once attending a BBC lecture course for radio producers, which, among other things, offered advice on the use of music in radio drama....

OPERA

The Spectator

Stylish nozze Hugh Macpherson John Copley's exuberant new production of Le Nozze di Figaro offers so much in good singing, as well as the triumphal return of an old favourite...

Page 25

BALLET

The Spectator

Cartier's jewels Robin Young Jean Albert Cartier must be something special: a director who gives a ballet company an identity and spirit of Its own without either taking on...

Page 26

SKINFLINT'S CITY DIARY

The Spectator

Richard King and Colin Forsyth, gay blades and snappy dressers both, have received the warm blessing of Sir Kenneth Keith's Hill Samuel bank on the back-toback sale of their Pan...

Page 28

MONEY New optimism

The Spectator

Nicholas Davenport Wonders will never cease. The usually pessimistic National Institute of Economic and Social Research has actually made an optimistic forecast in its latest...

Juliette's Weekly Frolic

The Spectator

I cannot see why United Racecourses wish to bury the charm and character of Sandown under the heap of steel and escalators which will undoubtedly follow their modernisation...

Page 29

Peter Quince

The Spectator

Winter can lie across the countryside like a flat grey blanket at times. We had had several days like this: leaden, unvarying skies, no movement in the moist air, everywhere...

Benny Green

The Spectator

After the end of the last war, whenever I walked due south along the Haymarket, a tiny question mark would take shape at the back of my mind. This moment of subliminal...

Page 30

Fair rents

The Spectator

From Mr H. E. Francis, QC Sir: I should be grateful if you would allow me to make the fcllowing comments on Mr Harry Samuels' letter on Fair Ren's (December 4). (1) The...

The Irish Mess

The Spectator

Sir: I read with interest the account in the November 27 issue of the banned World in Action programme on the Republic of Ireland. I had suspected that my contribution to this...

From Miss Muriel Anderson

The Spectator

Sir: How welcome was the reminder by John Graham (November 20) of the basic and unchanged realities and distortions of Ulster politics which are at the root of the present...

Sir: Mr Short (Letters, Novemhe 20) complains that in my

The Spectator

letter November 6 I ignored the hostilit , to the EEC, in both Northern Ire, land and certain sections of tit'. South. The subject of my letter ws' direct rule. My reference to...

Sir: The situation in Northe r t, Ireland is surely tragic enolig,„r:

The Spectator

and we should be spared pat. attempts by Irishmen, real and n called, to confuse the issue by use of meaningless statements. his letter of November 13 Mr FitzGibbon propounds...

Page 31

Anglo-Poles

The Spectator

Sir: The Anglo-Polish Conservative Society, of which the Rt Hon. John Boyd-Carpenter, QC, MP is President and Mr Tadeusz J. Sas is Chairman, is offering prizes of £250, £150,...

Trusting Smith

The Spectator

Sir: The proposed Rhodesia settlement is said to depend on trusting Mr Smith. His previous record does not encourage this. Immediately before declaring UDI, he deliberately...

Free communications

The Spectator

Sir: Dennis Hackett's contention (November 27) that the Free Communications Group, by attracting more members, will thereby become politically more balanced seems to rest on the...

Free floating

The Spectator

SIR: Your premise that "Mr Barber has movea towards cautious support of limited currency floating" in place of his chief's "erstwhile commitment to rigidly fixed e occhange...

Defending Nigeria

The Spectator

Sir: 1 read those two or three articles of Mr Palmer, in which he claimed to have found a most undesirable state of affairs in Nigeria, considering how much he believed the...

Waugh Baugh

The Spectator

Sir: Agreeable rumours persist that you are to lose the service; of Auberon Waugh as reviewer. Please accept my sincerest felicitations on this pleasant prospect. Please...

Gulliver rescued

The Spectator

Sir: The Gulliver's Journal in your November 20 issue really brought home to me how perceptive and ingenious the series is. But one question remains outstanding: who, is the...