21 JULY 1928

Page 1

News of the Week

The Spectator

T HE greatest event of . the week has .been Sir Austen Chamberlain's announcement.to the United States that the Government "mill be happy to sign " the Kellogg Peace Pact. The...

France explains that she understands that her signature of the

The Spectator

Pact - will not affect her alliances and agreements and that her • right of self-defence remains unimpaired: She points out that every sovereign nation must be the sole judge...

We assume that Sir Austen accepts Mr. Kellogg's explanations of

The Spectator

June 24th as satisfactory, and, like France, is content to have them on record without insisting that they shall be part of the Treaty. Sir Austen's delay in answering Mr....

The highly original Constitution which is proposed for Ceylon by

The Spectator

the Donoughmore Commission is unlike that of any Executive existing anywhere in the world. In form it suggests the League of Nations. Government in Ceylon had come to a deadlock...

Lord -Donoughmore's Commission now boldly propose that there should be

The Spectator

virtually. universal franchise, and that Ceylon OAR bethine :a self-governing Colony. As, however, there is not the lea:a:hope of the many small political. groups cohering' into...

EDITORIAL AND PUBLISHING OFFICES 13 York Street, Covent Garden, London,

The Spectator

W.C.2.—A Subscription to the SPEcresTott. costs Thirty Shillings per annum, including postage, to any part of the world. The SPECTATOR is registered as a Newspaper. The Postage...

Page 2

It was not thought that either candidate would venture to

The Spectator

interfere with the Eighteenth Amendment to the Constitution which is the basis of the Volstead Act, but Mr. Raskob has - announced that if, as a " result of careful study," Mr....

We have written in a leading article about the Savidge

The Spectator

Reports, but here we should like to say something about a matter which does not arise directly out of the inquiry. The debate in the House of COMmons whiCh will take place after...

Mr. Al. Smith, the Governor of New York and Demo-

The Spectator

cratic candidate for the Presidency, is not letting a blade of grass grow under his feet. He has a long and difficult, and many people think impossible, road to travel to the...

The decision by the Council of the League of Nations

The Spectator

to abandon its attempt to settle the dispute. between Rumania and Hungary is deplorable. The Treaty of Trianon laid upon the Council the duty of appointing a substitute for the...

. Signor Giolitti, who has died at the. age of

The Spectator

eighty-five, has sometimes been called the " Grand Old Man" of Italian politics. He was 'Liberal by name, it is true, but it was often difficult for foreigners to identify his...

General Obregon, the President-elect of Mexico, was assassinated at a

The Spectator

luncheon on Tuesday. The assassin was able to approach him by pretending to .be a car- toonist. General Obregon was shot five times through the chest. He was President before,...

The statement by Dr. Murphy, of New York, and Dr.

The Spectator

Leitch, of London, to the International Cancer Conference on Tnesday will raise anxious but hopeful expectations. Dr. Murphy has extracted from tumours in chickens a "...

Meanwhile, Mr. Smith's courtship of the farmers is prospering, and

The Spectator

the New York correspondent of the Times says that on Monday sixty-three leaders of agri- cultural organizations in the Middle West passed resolu- tions' practically pledging...

Page 3

The Krassin ' continued her voyage and next picked up

The Spectator

the four survivors of the party who had been under the command of Lieutenant Viglieri since the rescue of General Nobile himself by , aeroplane. Some of the would-be rescuers...

Messages from the search parties who have been trying to

The Spectator

rescue the survivors from the disaster to the ' Italia ' have contained harrowing details and unhappily these have become the cause of international ill-feeling. On Thursday,...

The result of the by-election in the Hallam Division of

The Spectator

Sheffield, necessitated by the appointment of Sir Frederick Sykes as GOvernor of Bombay, was declared on Monday as follows :- Mr. L. W. Smith (Unionist) .. 9,417 Mr. C. R....

The Conference of the Miners' Federation opened at Llandudno on

The Spectator

Tuesday. Mr. Herbert Smith, the Presi- dent, said that the membership had fallen from 957,000 in 1926 to 625,000. The loss of a third of the members is only too easily to be...

On Wednesday Mr. Churchill surprised the House of Commons by

The Spectator

announcing changes in the Betting Duty. He will reduce - the duty from 2 per cent. to 1 per cent. on the course and from 3i per cent. to 2 per cent. else- where ; but the...

The result of the Halifax by-election, declared on Friday, July

The Spectator

13th, was a gain for Labour. The figures were :- Alderman A. W. Longbottom (Labour) . . .. 17,536 Major Harry Barnes (Liberal) .. .. 12,585 Major Frank Crossley (Unionist) .....

The Swedish newspapers have been bitter about the loss of

The Spectator

Dr. Malmgren. They cannot understand why General Nobile permitted Dr. Malmgren, who, it is now said,-was 'badly injured - when the airship fell, to be one of the walking party,...

Bank Rate, 41- per cent., changed from 5 per cent.,

The Spectator

or. April 21st, 1927. War Loan (5 per cent.) was on Wednesday 10111 ; on Wednesday week 101-A- ; a ' year . ago 101-k, Funding Loan (4 per bent.) was on Wednesday 901- ; on...

Page 4

The Savidge Reports

The Spectator

. IT is extremely unfortunate that the Court of. Inquiry into the methods of interrogating Miss Savidge at Scotland Yard did not produce a unanimous Report. If it ha' done so...

Page 5

On Understanding the United States

The Spectator

I T is good news that Sir Austen Chamberlain has thought better of his tardy plan to deliver his reply to Mr. Kellogg's latest Note some time " before the end of the session."...

Page 6

The Hot Weather

The Spectator

N O one has yet fried an egg on the London pavement these summer days, as a citizen of New York is reported by cable to have done last week. But it has been hot in London, none...

Page 7

The Week in Parliament

The Spectator

T HE House of Commons is really an amazing assembly. After weeks of fulmination and com- motion, and a daily . crop of questions regarding the S midge case and the police force,...

Hospitality

The Spectator

W E have heard a great deal during the last week or two about hospitality and its abuse. Our sympathies have been enlisted by hostesses whose homes have been invaded by...

Page 8

The Working of the Rhodes Trust

The Spectator

T HE Rhodes Trust has been in existence approxi- mately twenty-two years: And almost from its inception there has been much criticism both of the Rhodes Scholars and the Rhodes...

Page 10

Qn Tu chuns

The Spectator

rENTIE closest parallel that Europe can show to the present state of China is Italy in the Middle Ages, with its condottieri selling their swords to the highest bidder, fighting...

Page 11

Seafaring Cats

The Spectator

C` C ATS," said Tubby meditatively, " are queer animals. I can easily understand their being associated with witches and black magic. They look at you out of their wise eyes as...

Page 12

Correspondence

The Spectator

THE YOUNGER POINT OF VIEW [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sm,—I do not intend to take up Mr. Hamilton's idea of Public School reform, in the issue of the Spectator for June...

Poetry

The Spectator

In Anglesey ALIGHT the gorse from shore to shore, And widely rolls the empurpled moor— The sea birds pipe, the sea-gulls soar, The sedges whisper evermore, In Anglesey. Here...

Page 13

The League of Nations

The Spectator

How the Covenant Became What It Is ONLY the assumption, not necessarily warranted by facts, that the framers of the League of Nations Covenant were completely omniscient would...

Page 14

A ROSE'S CIRCULATION.

The Spectator

We hear of books and newspapers and such things as having best-on-record circulations. Why do we hear little of the most widely circulated flower or shrub or such beautiful...

OXFORD INGENUITIES.

The Spectator

On the subject of this year's new machinery it is wholly remarkable with what rapid success Oxford University has taken up its function of studying agriculture mechanics on...

Country Life _

The Spectator

A PRIMULA FROM THIBET. Something was said the other day on this page about the blue poppy (Meconopsis Bayleyi) brought back by Mr. Ward from Thibet, of which the seed may now...

CONDEMNED FLOWERS.

The Spectator

New roses are produced every year (though it takes a good eight years to put a rose on the market), but more new roses are scrapped than are sold ; and some of the rejected have...

JULY, THE SUDDEN.

The Spectator

July heat proved so sudden and complete that it caught ' some producers, and many gardeners, napping: - Fruit, especially currants, ripened so quickly that they began to fall...

HARVESTING IN ONE.

The Spectator

Early this summer, it was given as a sign of the loss of capital in farming that no machinery was exhibited at an Eastern Counties' show. May we take it. as a symptom that...

BENEFICENT BACTERIA.

The Spectator

This immediacy in scrabbing up—and better in ploughing— the ground, is in accordance with recent discoveries by our men of science. It has been proved at Rothamsted that the...

CALIFORNIA V. COGGESHAI.L.

The Spectator

National rivalry in the production of new varieties of many flowers is hot. The British are still probably the best in delicacy of selection. A delightful account was given me...

THE BEST ROSE.

The Spectator

The best of all the new roses—to my mind, eyes, and nose— is Dame Edith Helen, a delicious pink with all the rose virtues in high measure. If it were an apple we should call it...

Page 15

THE CHURCH'S "INALIENABLE RIGHT"

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Snt,—In your issue of the 7th inst., in your article on " The Church's " Inalienable Right,' " you say " The true policy of the Church, then,...

" THE TRAGEDY OF TRIANON " [To the Editor of

The Spectator

the SPECTATOR.] Snt,—I cannot entirely agree with the conclusions arrived at by your correspondent " J. M. S." The Treaty of Trianon is so inequitable in its terms and so harsh...

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

SAVING THE LAKE DISTRICT [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Many readers of the Spectator must have spent pleasant holidays in the Lake District, and therefore will be...

Page 16

THE IL S; P.C. A.

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—With respect to your article in last week's Spectator, I feel sure that all who detest all cruelty to animals will agree to endorse your...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

shall be grateful if you will be good enough to afford me the opportunity of replying briefly to one or two points in Mr. Gaskoin's letter which appeared on July 7th, and was...

Page 17

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —It is with some

The Spectator

hesitation that I venture to take part in the discussion which is following the article by " Crusader " on " The Conquest of Cancer," for a not inconsiderable experience of...

THE MASON METHOD [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Six,--I am afraid that the earnest but slightly exasperated efforts of Mr. L. H. Scott to make me understand what Dr. Lyttelton meant by his letter on the Mason method of educa-...

RAILWAYS AND ROAD POWERS [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—In your article on the Railway Bills you say, rightly, that the Railway Companies subsidize the road motor con- cerns. You do not add that all ratepayers subsidize them,...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—I am not surprised that Mr. E. F. Benson fails to under- stand what I wrote about the Mason method in education. If an idea is both new and true you cannot explain it in a...

THE CONQUEST OF CANCER [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—I would like to endorse the views expressed by " Crusader " in your issue of the 7th, and of " Medoc " in your issue of the 14th. Cancer is preventable and curable. There...

Page 18

DOMESTIC SERVICE AND PUBLIC HEALTH

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—The connexion between the servant problem and public health may not be obvious, but it exists. Ask any doctor who attends the families of...

A LINK WITH NAPOLEON [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—If your correspondent, Mr. Cecil Wilson, of Weybridge, will look at an article in the July 1st number of the Revue des De= Mondes, he will see that Napoleon's habit of...

CLEAN FOOD

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, — On behalf of the New Health Society, may I be allowed to express our appreciation of the initiative taken by the Spectator in directing...

SEAFARING HOLIDAYS

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—I read with great interest your article on the above subject in your issue of July 14th. No doubt the number and variety of cruises make a...

Page 19

THE DISTRESS IN SOUTH WALES

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Will you accept my very deep and sincere feelings of gratitude on behalf of the poor and needy in the Rhondda Valley, for the very...

"THE SKULL OF SWIFT"

The Spectator

(To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.) SIR,—In,your review of The Skull of Swift, you say, "when he retired to Dublin, he was still anxious to rule an Empire ; but all he did was...

WERE THERE MINOAN FLEETS ?

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—It seems to me that your correspondents have all been -proving too much. My own sympathies were mainly with Mr. Massingham, but his...

THE HOUSING PROBLEM

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,--Everybody is very busy building new houses— most necessary and desirable.. But nobody seems busy enough over educating a certain class...

Page 20

SUNLIGHT LAMPS AND SAFETY

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] - Sur,—Recent legislation has definitely failed to restore enough of our needed natural sunlight to our shadowed lives in this coal-burning...

MEMORIAL TO OCTAVIA HILL

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sia,—In former years you frequently opened your columns to appeals by Miss Octavia Hill, on behalf of the National Trust, and always with most...

POINTS FROM LETTERS

The Spectator

WAR AND FORCE. Mr. Philip Kerr writes in your issue of July 14th : " If the Peace Pact is to be effective . . . we shall have to make a clear differentiation between war and...

Lighter Lyrics

The Spectator

The Three Crows THERE lived a witch upon a hill With three black crows to do her will. As soon as ever the red cock crew They flapped their wings and away they flew. Says...

Page 21

arlie 5p ectator

The Spectator

FINANCIAL SUPPLEMENT BANKING AND INSURANCE No. 5,221.] WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, JULY 21, 1928. [GRATIS.

Page 23

Banking and Democracy

The Spectator

Greater Publicity Desirable I SHALL make no excuse for attempting to deal in this article with a rathar difficult and, in some respects, a somewhat delicate matter, namely, the...

Page 24

The Present Banking Position

The Spectator

Deposits and Loans Rise Despite Trade Depression A rosT-WAR phase of British banking which will be long remembered is the manner in which deposits and loans, and especially the...

Page 27

A Romance of Scottish - Banking

The Spectator

The Royal Bank of Scotland* THIS most interesting volume purports to be a history of the Royal Bank of Scotland, which last year celebrated its bicentenary. It is, however,...

Page 29

Life Assurance the Best Investment

The Spectator

Absolute Security for Capital IT may, I suppose, be taken for granted that no person of average intelligence needs to be informed as to the why and wherefore of insurance. At...

Page 31

Essential Types of Policies

The Spectator

To Meet All Requirements WITHIN recent years controversy has been rife over the question as to which is the better form of policy from an economic point of view—the " with...

Page 36

Louden: Printed by W. SPF-11G1tT AhD SONS. LTD., 98 and

The Spectator

99 Fetter Lane. EC. 4, and .Publisitted by THE SPECTATOR, LTD, at their Offices, No. 13 York Street, Covent Garden, Loudon, W.C. 2.—Saturday, July 21, 1928.

Page 37

It is useful to have the text of the so-called

The Spectator

Polish Minorities Treaty with an account of the operation of the safeguards of minorities. (The Protection of Minorities. By L. P. Mair. (Christophers. 8s. 6d.) For that Treaty,...

Messrs. Philip's new Library Map of England and Wales, with

The Spectator

Southern Scotland, is a large-scale map (six miles to the inch), measuring five feet by six, of great dearness and attrac- tiveness. A map is a very civilized thing and a very...

Countless people who are interested in architecture, whethet as amateurs

The Spectator

or as professionals, owe a debt of gratitude to Sir Banister Fletcher for his History of Architecture on the Comparative Method. It is good to sec yet another edition— the...

Some Books of the Week

The Spectator

THE Cresset Press's beautiful edition of The Heroycall Epistles of the learned Poet, Publius Ovidius Naso, translated into English verse by George Turberville, with ten...

Those who follow the valuable but dry spade-work done at

The Spectator

Geneva can now get from Messrs. P. S. King and Son, for Os., the English version of the International Labour Office's Report on Wages and Hours of Work in the Coal Mining...

Mr. Keble Chatterton in his new book on the sea,

The Spectator

Ventures and Voyages (Longmans, 10s. 0d.), says that it is an " escape " book. That is what such a collection of adven- tures ought to be. Few people can really escape from a...

We have received the July number of Dr. Saleeby's Sunlight

The Spectator

(1s.), an excellent little journal imbued with the vigour and vitality of the sensible living it advocates. No doubt but that the Editor and his contributors practise what they...

(" More Books of the Week" and " General Knowledge

The Spectator

Competition" will be found on pages 112 and 116.)

Page 38

The Age of Bronze SOME three thousand years ago a

The Spectator

great civilization that had dominated the Aegean for two thousand years or more collapsed and vanished. Greek legends, used by poets and dramatists, preserved the memory of it,...

Monsieur de Geneve A e improved understanding of human character

The Spectator

and a more careful study of his life and writings have lately removed S. Francois de Sales from the class of amiable and lady-like saints to which he was once consigned, and...

Page 39

George Borrow's First Work

The Spectator

MESSRS. JONATHAN CAPE'S decision to reprint George Borrow's Celebrated Trials has been justified in the event. There is a curiosity about the first work of any writer who later...

Must England be Ugly ?

The Spectator

GOING ! Going !—Mr. Clough Williams-Ellis, that ingenious and imaginative architect, has turned for the moment into auctioneer and pamphleteer, and threatens to bring down the...

Page 40

A Russian Ernigree "Makes Good"

The Spectator

The Transplanting : A Narrative from the Letters of Marie Balascheff, a Russian Refugee in France. Edited by Martha Genung Stearns. (Macmillan. 10s. 6d.) IN a series of letters...

Prose

The Spectator

English Prose - Style. By Herbert Read. (Bell. 9s.) PROSE is already old when its writing becomes a self-conscious art. At first, words follow from the nature of the man and the...

Page 41

The Empire in Evolution Empire Government. By Manfred Nathan, K.C.

The Spectator

(Ceorgo Allen and Unwin. 10s.) TIIE old platitude tells us that we acquired the Empire " in a fit of absence of mind." However that may be, there seems some real danger that it...

Fiction

The Spectator

Past and Present Butterworth. 7s. 6d.) Beau Ideal. By P. C. Wren. (John Murray. 7s. 6d.) IN The Lost Fight the author of The Unhurrying Chase returns to the Middle Ages,...

Page 42

PUT ASUNDER. By Mrs. W. L. George. (Chapman and Hall.

The Spectator

7s. 6d.)—This is a sober and earnest novel, raising problems for which the writer wisely offers no universal solution. The story is very readable, and is the more con- vincing...

Page 44

More Books of the Week (Continued from page 105.)

The Spectator

A century ago little or nothing was known of Assyria. Since then the spade under skilled direction has unearthed a vast mass of material for Assyrian history. Its extent and...

ANOTHER COUNTRY. By H. de Coudray. (Philip Allan. 7s. 6d.)—The

The Spectator

masculine grip and the mature insight of this prize novel certainly do not suggest the amateur. It is a singular and ruthless analysis of the more contemptible side of humanity....

A Book on Architecture (Black, Is. 6d.) is a short,

The Spectator

popular exposition accompanied by excellent illustrations on which we may congratulate the author, Mr. G. H. Reed. He traces the history of architecture from the building of the...

THE GRIERSON MYSTERY. By Lloyd Osborne. (Heine- mann. 7s. 6d.)—An

The Spectator

exciting story, though the end, some may think, hardly fulfils the promise of the beginning. Grier- son, the chief bank clerk, is an original figure ; and when he and his motor...

Mr. E. E. Kellett, who was for many years a

The Spectator

prominent figure in Cambridge life, became known to a wider public through his book of literary essays entitled Suggestions, published several years ago. We now welcoine a new...

The author of Father O'Flynn has completed in 1928 a

The Spectator

project first mooted by him in 1901 (The Celtic Song Book, arranged by Alfred Perceval Graves, Benn, 10s. 6d.) this selection of Folk Songs, words and music, from the Gaels of...

LOVE'S CREATION. By Marie Carmichael. (Bale and Danielsson. 7s. 6d.)—This

The Spectator

is an oddly old-fashioned novel, written in a fluent old-fashioned style. Traces of Dr. Marie Stopes the palaeontologist appear in the account of the researches of Dr. Kenneth...

Nothing in Dr. Adler's " Individual psychology " has been

The Spectator

more famous than the " inferiority complex." Every- one recognizes the feeling of weakness or inadequacy from which men start in their efforts to gain success. Dr. Adler used...

BLISS AT EVENING. By Robert Hartley. (Alston Rivers. 7s. 6d.)—It

The Spectator

would be regrettable if, amid the vast output of clever and flashy fiction, this quiet and unobtrusive novel should miss the attention it deserves. It is the leisurely chronicle...

Page 47

Mr. Abel Chapman Ai a well-known sportsman and naturalist, and

The Spectator

has previously given us several extensive works on his field explorations in various parts of the world. In Retrospect (Gurney and Jackson, 25s.) he tells us of his sixty years'...

Finance-Public & Private

The Spectator

- Railway Stocks and the Investor WITHIN the next few weeks two important developments will have taken place in the railway world in both of which railway stockholders- have a...

Sylvester Douglas, first and only Lord Glenbervie in the peerage

The Spectator

of Ireland, was born in 1744. A member of the Privy Council, and for a short time Chief Secretary for Ireland, he held high appointments under Government was a Lord of the...

General Knowledge Questions

The Spectator

Questions on " Do You Know ? " Oun weekly prize of one guinea for the best thirteen Questions submitted is awarded this . week to Mr. .R. Richardson, 11 Raleigh Terrace ;...

A Library List

The Spectator

MISCELLANEOUS : - Lord Haig. By Sir George Arthur. (Heinemann. 6s.)-The Strange Necessity. Essays by Rebecca West. (Cape. 10s. 6d.) Robin Hood. By J. C. Squire. (Heinemann....

Page 48

- ' MOND NICKEL.

The Spectator

Not the least interesting feature at the recent annual meeting of Mond Nickel was the ' statement by Lord Melchett to the effect that it was proposed to increase the authorir t...

AUSTRALIAN WOOL INDUSTRY. '

The Spectator

I venture to think that there are few readers of the Spectator who are not deeply concerned with everything pertaining to Empire interests and Empire developments. I am glad,...

" CLOSER SETTLEMENT" PROBLEM.

The Spectator

In fact, as one reads the exhaustive statement of the position and the appalling character of the drought in certain areas, it is impossible not to conjecture what would be the...

Financial Notes

The Spectator

QUIET MARKETS. TEE Stock Markets are showing some signs of lassitude ' as the apex of the holiday season approaches, while the specu- lative markets are still disturbed by the...

Page 50

FURNESS WITHY.

The Spectator

The latest report of Furness Withy is a distinctly good one, the profit being 2627,750 against £603,511 for the pre- vious year, and only £523,044 for the year ending April...

Answers to " Do You Know ? " Questions

The Spectator

1. The " Hieroglyphic." 2. Two : " Phonetic," or signs denoting sounds, and Ideographic, denoting ideas.-3. The "Rosetta Stone," which bore an inscription in Hieroglyphic,...