27 APRIL 1907

Page 3

iwittrarp Oupplemmt.

The Spectator

LONDON: APRIL 27th, 1907.

BOOKS.

The Spectator

LETTERS OF LITERARY MEN.* SIR Tnocuis MORE was imprisoned in the Tower for denying the headship of the King in matters ecclesiastical in England. Not long before he was...

Page 4

THE KINGDOM OF MAN.*

The Spectator

A woma of interest and scientific insight was to be expected from Professor Ray Lankester, and in his latest book that expectation is fulfilled. The work is divided into three...

Page 5

ENGLISH LITERATURE.*

The Spectator

WE cannot pretend to review the judgments which Messrs. Seccombe and Robertson Nicoll—the preface assigns the greater part of the work to Mr. Seccombe, and 'associates the name...

CURRENT LITERATURE.

The Spectator

AN ANTHOLOGY OF AITSTRALIAN VERSE. An Anthology of Australian Verse. Edited by Bertram Stevens. (Macmillan and Co. 3s. 6d. net.)—Mr. Stevens has prefaced his anthology by a...

Page 6

THE PASSING OF KOREA.

The Spectator

The Passing of Korea. By Homer B. Hulbert, A.M., F.R.G.S. (W. Heinemann. 165. net.)—This book has been written with the avowed object of interesting the reading public in a...

A HISTORY OF SOCIALISM.

The Spectator

A History of Socialism, By Thomas Kirkup, Third Edition, Revised and Enlarged. (A. and C. Black. 75. net.)—Mr. Kirkup's work has already achieved an honourable place in the...

THE FlJTURE OF RUSSIA.

The Spectator

The Future of Russia. By Rudolf Martin. Translated from the German by Hulda Friedrichs. (Smith, Elder, and Co. 7s. 6d. net.)—This little volume is by a member of the Prussian...

Page 7

TWO THEOLOGICAL BOOKS..

The Spectator

The Epistle of Jude and the Second Epistle of Peter. By Joseph B. Mayor. (Macmillan and Co. 14s. net.)—This volume, with its introduction, notes, commentary, and elaborately...

Page 8

RAE'S "THEORY OF CAPITAL."

The Spectator

' The Sociological Theory of' Capital : being a Complete Reprint of the New Principles of Political Economy, 1834. By John Rae, M.A. (Macmillan and Co. na. net.)—Dr. Charles...

A FAUNA OF THE TAY BASIN.

The Spectator

Fauna of the Tay Basin and Strathmore. By J. A. Harvie- Brown, F.R.S.E, F.Z.S. (David Douglas, Edinburgh. 30s.)— This volume is the tenth of a series started some eighteen years...

Page 9

A FAMOUS SCOTCH CRIMINAL.

The Spectator

The Trial of Deacon Brodie. Edited by William Roughead, Writer to the Signet. With Portraits and Illustrations. "Notable Scottish Trials" Series. (Sweet and Maxwell. Is. net )...

IDEALISM AND EXPERIENCE. environment. Dr. Bernie points out in his

The Spectator

preface that it is not enough to make experience intelligible by merely resolving it into ideal—that is, intelligible—elements, or by leaving experience outside the explanation....

Page 10

CAMBRIDGE: A BRIEF STUDY IN SOCIAL QUESTIONS.

The Spectator

Cambridge a Brief Study in Social Questions. By Eglantyne Jebb. (Macmillan and Bowes, Cambridge. 45. gd. net.)—Miss Jebb and her friends have written an admirable little book....

THE WESTMINSTER PLAYS.

The Spectator

Luaus Alteri Westmonasteriensis. Curantibus R. S. Mitre, J. Sargeaunt, J. Gow. (In Domo Ashburnhamiana.)—This volume contains the prologues and epilogues of the Westminster play...

THE AUSTINIAN THEORY OF LAW.

The Spectator

The Austinian Theory of Law. By W. Jethro Brown, LL.D. (Camb.), Litt.D. (Dublin). (John Murray. 10s. fid. net.)—This volume is stated to be an edition of Lectures I., V., and...

Page 11

ABYSSINIA OF TO-DAY.

The Spectator

Abyssinia of To - clay: an Account of the First Mission Sent by the American Government to the Court of the King of Kings, 1903-1904. By Robert P. Skinner. (Edward Arnold. 12s....

ITNTRATELLED ENGLAND.

The Spectator

Untravelled England. By James John Hissey. (Macmillan and Co. 16s.)—This book is, like most storks of the same kind from the same pen, a delightful—and delightfully Pickwickian-...

THE TRON KIRK OF EDINBURGH.

The Spectator

The Tron Kirk of Edinburgh, or Christ's Kirk at the Tron: Rev. Dr. James Macgregor contributes a chapter of reminiscences to this very interesting volume. He was minister of the...

Page 12

THE LAST DAYS OF WASHINGTON.

The Spectator

Letters and Recollections of George Washington : being Letters to Tobias Lear and Others between 1793 and 1799, showing the First American in the Management of his Estate and...

LETTERS AND JOURNALS OF SAMUEL GRIDLEY HOWE.

The Spectator

Letters and Journals of Samuel Gridley Howe. Edited by his Daughter, Laura E. Richards. (John Lane. 16s. net.)—S. G. Howe was known in after life by the admirable work which he...

THE WRITINGS OF ST. FRANCIS OF ASSISI.

The Spectator

The Writings of St. Francis of Assisi. Translated into English by Father Paschal Robinson. (J. M. Dent and Co. 3s. 6d. not.)—The writings of St. Francis of Assisi afford us...

NYASALAND.

The Spectator

Nyasaland under the Foreign Office. By H. L. Duff. (G. Bell and Sons. Is. 8d. net.)—Mr; Duff is a member of the British Central Africa Administration, and he has written almost...

Page 13

THE CITIES OF PROVENCE.

The Spectator

Romantic Cities of Provence. By Mona Caird. Illustrated from Sketches by Joseph Pennell and Edward M. Synge. (T. Fisher ITnwin. 155. net.)—This book does not by any means, like...

A PASTORAL BISHOP.

The Spectator

A Pastoral Bishop a Memoir of A. Chinnery-Haldane. By Thomas Isaac Ball, LL.D. (Longmaus and Co. Os. 6d. net.)— Mr. Chinnery-Haldane was ordained in the Anglican Church, but...

SIR WILLIAM FLOWER.

The Spectator

Sir William Flower. By R. Lydekker. (J. M. Dent and Co. 2s. 6d. net.)—This is a volume of the "English Men of Science" Series. Naturally it is chiefly devoted to the scientifie...

KING'S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE.

The Spectator

King's College, Cambridge. By C. R. Fay. (j. M. Dent and Co. 2s. net.)—Mr. Fay's pen and Mr. Edmund H. New's pencil combine to make a very pleasing volume. Perhaps the strongest...

BRIER-PATCH PHILOSOPHY.

The Spectator

Brier-Patch Philosophy. By William J. Long. Illustrated by Charles Copeland. (Ginn and Co. 6s.)—When Mr. Long is describing the habits of animals, and telling us stories about...

THE OLD ROOF-TREE.

The Spectator

The Old Roof-Tree: Letters of Ishbel to her Half-Brother, Mark Latimer. (Longmans and Co. 5s. net.)—Something of an intro- duction to tell us the point of view from which "...

THE DEFENCE OF THE REALME.

The Spectator

The Defence of the Realms. By Sir Henry Knyvett, 1596. With Introduction by Charles Hughes. (Clarendon Press. 5s. net.)— Sir Henry Knyvett, of Charlton, near Malmesbury, drew up...

Page 14

The Thames from Chelsea to the Nore. By Thomas R

The Spectator

Way and Walter G. BelL (John Lane. 42a. net.)—We have lately had several books about the Thames, but none in which the lower course of the river is more graphically pictured....

The Gate of Death: a Diary. (Smith, Elder, and Co.

The Spectator

78. 6d. net.) —This is a very striking book. It describes with extreme minute- ness the mental and physical sensations of the author as he approaches "the gate of death." The...

Page 16

Lennox Printed by Lars & ISIaLconson (Limited) at Nos. 4

The Spectator

and 5 Ddan Street, Holborn, W.C. ; and Published by loan Bases for the "Sescrarea (Limited) at their Office, No. 1 Wellington Street, in the Precinct of the Savoy, Strand, in...

Page 17

The Peking correspondent of the Times states in last Saturday's

The Spectator

paper that at the end of last year Imperial dedrees were passed which raised the Sage Confucius from the level of the sun and moon to the level of the heaven and earth, and...

The latest trouble between France and Germany in Morocco has

The Spectator

come to a speedy and satisfactory end. It will be remem- bered that the Makhzan gave an order for works at Tangier, including a drainage system and a marine boulevard, to a...

Noncs.—With this week's "Srzarszoa" is issued, gratis, a

The Spectator

LITERARY SUPPLEMENT.

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

T HE visit of the King and Queen to King Victor Emmanuel at Gaeta on Thursday week had no worse sequel than mutterings in the German Press. The visit was simply an act of...

• ,,,* The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript, in

The Spectator

any case.

ro?

The Spectator

MAY 9 1907 TiTo. 4,113.] FOB TES WtEK ENDING SATURDAY, APRIL 27, 1907. [ REGISTERED AS a l Psma ....,...6s. NEWSPAPER Br POST-8111. POSTAGE Assess 1 D.

The water-supply of Egypt is dealt with in an interesting

The Spectator

despatch from Lord Cromer issued as a Parliamentary Paper on Monday. Lord Cromer summarises the enormous benefits conferred on Egypt by the perennial irrigation furnished by the...

On Tuesday General von Einem, the German Minister for War,

The Spectator

explained in the Reichstag the Estimates for rearma- ment and the reconstruction of fortresses. He had been pressed to spread the expenditure over a shorter time, but he hoped...

The event of the week in the affaiis of the

The Spectator

Duma bas,been the reception by the Emperor of M. Golovin, the President. Considerable importance is attached to this audience, which is taken as a sign of the Emperor's...

The mention of the descendant of Confucius recalls the striking

The Spectator

passage in Gibbon's autobiography in which the historian declares that "the family of Confucius is, in my opinion, the noblest upon earth. Seventy authentic genera- tions have...

Page 18

The Colonial Premiers were entertained at luncheon on Wednesday by

The Spectator

the Houses of Parliament in Westminster Hall. Sir Henry Campbell-Bannernian, who presided, welcomed the Premiers in a cordial speech in which he declared that there was neither...

From a summary of the discussions which preceded the adoption

The Spectator

of the resolution it appears that the abandonment of an Imperial Council (i.e., a body formed of the present members plus a permanent Imperial Civil Committee). and the limiting...

Mr. Balfour's speech, except for the passage which we have

The Spectator

dealt with at length in a leading article, was one of the ablest and weightiest be has delivered this Session. Specially excellent was his defence of the Militia. Do not let us,...

The debate on the Army Bill was resumed on Tuesday,

The Spectator

when Mr. Ramsay Macdonald, the Labour M.P. for Leicester, criticised Mr. Haldane's scheme in a speech of very great ability. The Labour Party, he declared, were not in favour of...

The official report of the proceedings of the Imperial Con-

The Spectator

ference issued on Monday announced that a resolution bad been unanimously adopted with regard to the style and con- stitution of the Conference and the establishment of a...

We do not of course agree with the spirit of

The Spectator

Mr. Ramsay Macdonald's criticisms, and we think that his references to what he called conscription were particularly unfair, for ho should surely know that no one advocates...

Page 19

On Wednesday afternoon Lord Avebury presided at the annual meeting

The Spectator

of the Proportional Representation Society, held at his house in St. James's Square. Re pointed out that in 1886 the Unionists obtained a majority of a hundred and four seats at...

At the Caxton Hall on Wednesday, Mr. W. M. Hughes,

The Spectator

Member of the Parliament of the Australian Commonwealth, gave an address on "Compulsory Military Training from the Point of View of an Australian Labour Leader," in which he...

On Monday in the House of Lords Lord Bath called

The Spectator

atten- tion to the memorial on the appointment of Magistrates presented to the Lord Chancellor in December, and moved for papers. The Lord Chancellor laid it down that there...

On Tuesday night Mr. Austen Chamberlain, speaking at a Liberal

The Spectator

Unionist dinner and making a plea for Unionist unity, declared that " he was led to make these remarks because he saw that a speech of his, made a little time ago, was inter-...

The resumed debate on the Budget on Wednesday was noticeable

The Spectator

for a bitter attack on Mr. Asquith's proposals from Mr. Snowden, the Labour Member for Blackburn. No Chancellor of the Exchequer, he declared, bad had so magnificent an...

The land question was raised in the House of Lords

The Spectator

on Thursday by Lord Lansdowne, who, while urging that the movement to bring back more and more people to the soil should have the support of both political parties, described...

Bank Bate, 4 per cent., changed from 41 per cent.

The Spectator

Apr. 25th. Consols (2k) were on Friday 85f—on Fri day week 86}.

Page 20

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

THE . LAND POLICY OF THE GOVERNMENT. T HAT it is desirable from every point of view, moral, physical, and social, to encourage men to live and make their living in the country...

Page 21

THE DISMISSAL OF SIR HORACE PLUNKETT.

The Spectator

I T seems that there is no place for a moderate man in Ireland. The decision of the Government shortly to remove Sir Horace Plunkett from his office as Vice-President of the...

Page 22

UNIVERSAL MILITARY TRAINING.

The Spectator

W E have dealt elsewhere with Mr. Balfour's speech in the House of Commons during the debate on Mr. Haldane's Bill. The greater part of that speech was quite admirable, and,...

Page 23

THE INCIDENT AT LAHORE.

The Spectator

T HE incident at Lahore reported in the Times of April 18th is of some importance,—first, because it shows that the dislike of Europeans, which has been growing in India,...

Page 24

FEARS AND HOPES OF MR. AUSTEN CHAMBERLAIN.

The Spectator

M R. AUSTEN CHAMBERLAIN'S speech on Monday was an unusually interesting contribution to the Budget debate. The Chancellor of the Exchequer for the time being is necessarily...

Page 25

FREEDOM IN THE CHURCH.

The Spectator

A STRONG and able plea for "freedom in the Church" comes to us from America. It is written by Dr. A. V. Allen, a Professor in the Episcopal Theological School iu Cambridge, and...

Page 26

EXPERIENCE BY PROXY.

The Spectator

'W E are told sometimes by people who reckon themselves competent observers that the English character is changing; that it becomes more mercurial and less stable, more Southern...

Page 27

WILD FLOWER GARDENS.

The Spectator

H ERE and there not man, but the genius of the place, seems to say to himself, "I will make a garden." On the clean slope of a Sussex hill, in the deep quiet of a Surrey wood,...

Page 28

CORRESPONDENCE.

The Spectator

POLO ON DONKEYS. [TO TIEN EDITOR ON TUN "SPNOTATOR:3 Sts,—Your reference in the " News of the Week " of April 13th to polo on donkeys, and to the possibilities of importing...

Page 29

LETTERS TO TIT E EDITOR.

The Spectator

[To Tea Eorrox or Tam Srscmort...] SIR, — Would you allow me to enter a modest protest against Mr. Haldane's summary sentence upon the Roman Empire in his excellent speech at...

Page 30

[To TER EDITOR or THY 5PICTATOR.1 Sts,—Referring to Colonel Harcourt's

The Spectator

interesting letter, 'fp your issue of April 20th, it may be useful to point out that there is a delightful little book written by Colonel John Biddulph entitled "Striiger...

A PARLIAMENT OF WOMEN.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR 07 THY SPICTAT011.1 Sia,—I venture to make a suggestion with reference to the vexed question of female suffrage, which evidently, for good or for evil, will force...

CLIVE AND STRINGER LAWRENCE. [To ram EDITOR 07 TIM .SozoraTon.1

The Spectator

SI8,—In a letter in your issue of April 20th Colonel Harcourt, in his desire to do justice to the honoured memory of Colonel Stringer Lawrence, has done much less than justice...

Page 31

THE ATTACK ON SIR HORACE PLUNKETT. [To THE EDITOR or

The Spectator

THE "SPECTATOR. "] SIE,--•" D.'s" letter in last week's Spectator is most valuable at the present time, and every lover of Ireland should be roused by it to agitate against such...

COMPULSORY MILITARY TRAINING.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE "SPECTATOR."] Sra,---Only Mr. Punch has so far taken any serious notice of the manifesto of the Social Democratic Federation on Mr. Haldane's Army...

THE TREATMENT OF SEDITION IN INDIA. [To Tat EDITOR Or

The Spectator

THE "SPECTATOR. "] SIR,—In your issue of March 9th, just to hand, I have read with interest a letter from your correspondent Sir H. Evan M. James on " The Treatment of Sedition...

COTTON TRADE PROFITS.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR. or TIM .Semcreron..1 SIE, — Your correspondent " Manufacturer " of April 20th is evidently more familiar with the weaving of cloth from bought yarn than with...

RAID OR INVASION?—A. FRENCH OPINION. [To THE EDITOR or Tut

The Spectator

"SPECTATOR.] Snc,—There is a statement in the Spectator of April 20th (p. 623, col. 1) which must appear quite startling to many of your readers. It is this:- " What is obvious...

Page 32

MIXED METAPHORS.

The Spectator

[TO TUX EDITOR OP TUX .5PIL0TATOR.1 think your readers may be interested in a mixed metaphor which recently appeared in the Egyptian Standard, the paper of Moustapha Kernel...

A LINK WITH THE PAST.

The Spectator

[To TR it EDITOR 05 TITS EP MOUTON:I SIR, — May I add an instance to those which have lately appeared in the Spectator of the long period which may be covered by the lives of...

A MILITARY ATTACHE.

The Spectator

[TO TUN EDITOR Or TUX Sr scraron..] SIR, I seem to see now again, as I saw many years ago, a little man walking across a stoned courtyard, entre cons et jardin, on his way to...

THE METHODS OF BENGALI AGITATION.

The Spectator

[To TIM EDITOR OP Tel " SPECTATOR:1 Sur,—The Bengal Provincial Conference, an appanage of the " Congress," is holding its annual meeting at Berhampore, in the district of...

"SOLES OCCIDERE ET REHIRE POSSTTNT."

The Spectator

LTO TUX Raises or :ram "SrICTATOR.1 " haunting lines" from Catallus which your corre- spondent in the Spectator of April 20th thinks have never been rendered into English have,...

Page 33

POETRY.

The Spectator

ON CHAPMAN BARROWS.* THE lark that rises from his sheltered nest, No swifter is to greet the coming day Than he whose feet the ancient grasses pressed, In years long passed...

ART.

The Spectator

THE NEW GALLERY. WHEN making a general survey of the pictures hung in a gallery one cannot help recalling the effect of previous Exhibitions in the same place. While looking at...

La i . We have received and forwarded to Messrs. Baring Brothers,

The Spectator

8 Bishopsgate Within, E.C., the sum of .85 for the ;Wash= Famine Fund from "Sympathiser."]

Page 34

BOOKS.

The Spectator

RUSSIA AND REFORM.• IF Mr. Pares tells us nothing sensational in this stout volume, we are all the more ready to believe his word—in England we have been asked to believe...

Page 36

VITTORIA. COLONNA.*

The Spectator

IF the useful bibliography at the end of Mrs. Jerrold's book is entirely to be trusted, this is only the second time that a complete Life of Vittoria Colonna has been written in...

THE SCOTLAND OF YESTERDAY.* AT one time volumes of Scottish

The Spectator

reminiscences were common on publishers' lists. From Lord Cockburn's Memorials onward, there flowed a goodly stream, and the house of Blackwood was foremost in their production....

Page 37

NOVELS.

The Spectator

GHETTO COMEDIES.• Ma. ZANOWILL'S new volume forms a fitting pendant to his Ghetto Tragedies, and in that bald statement we desire to pay fitting tribute to his genius. Once...

Page 39

CURRENT LITERATURE.

The Spectator

THE QUARTERLIES. The last article in the Edinburgh Review, "Political Parties and the Country," is a masterly survey of the situation. So far, the writer thinks, the Ministry...

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

(Under this heeding so. 'lotto. Inch Book. of the week as Ions not been reserved for review in ether forma.] W. H. Caine, M.P. By John Newton. (J. Nisbet and Co. 105. 6d.)—The...

The Destruction of the Militia. (John Murray. ad. net.)—We are

The Spectator

delighted to notice a reprint of the Duke of Bedford's admirable speech on the Militia question, delivered in the House of Lords at the end of March. We have already noticed the...

READABLE NovEL8.—The Spanish Necklace. By B. M. Croker. (Chatto and

The Spectator

Windus. 2s. 6d. net.)—A. story of modern society, the scene of which passes chiefly at Biarritz.—The Plow-Woman. By Eleanor Gates. (Methuen and Co. 6s.)—A powerful story of life...

The Wingless Victory. By M. P. Willcocks. (John Lane. 6s.)—

The Spectator

Except for the descriptions of scenery in Devonshire and North COrnwall, it is impossible to call this a pleasant noveL The book is a psychological study of a woman who has...

Page 40

Beautiful Gardens : How to Make and Maintain Them By

The Spectator

- Walter P. Wright. (Cassell and Co. 6s. net.)—Mr. Wright, who fills the post of Horticultural Superintendent to the. Council , of Kent, the "Garden County!' of England, gives...

English Church History : 1649-1702. By the Rev. Alfred Plummer.

The Spectator

(T. and T. Clark. 3s. net.)—Dr. Plummer begins with a disquisition, which seems to us irrelevant, on the execution of Charles I. Surely the King was not a "prisoner of war." Had...

Ightham the Story of a Kentish Village. By J. Bennett.

The Spectator

(Homeland Association. 7s. 6d. net.)--Mr. Bennett, who has been assisted by Mr. Benjamin Harrison and other contributors, has found an excellent subject in the story of this...

Twenty Years' Railway Statistics. (F. C. Mathieson and Sons. Is.)

The Spectator

—This is a 'useful little volume, containing information which the investor would do well to study. On the whole, the outlook is not encouraging. The set of the tide is against...

Sweated Industry and the Minimum Wage. By Clementine Black. With

The Spectator

an Introduction by A. G. Gardiner. (Duckworth and Co. 38. 6d. net.)—There is, of course, a quantity of detail in this volume which it is not within our competence to examine....

Pictures and their Value. (Turner and Robinson, 6s. net.)— Here

The Spectator

we have the prices realised at picture-sales during the years 1905-6. Two indexes are given, one of painters (in oil and water), another of engravers, etohers, do. The details...

in the chapel •of Harrow School, and published as papers

The Spectator

in the magazine mentioned above. These eighteen discourses may be most emphatically recommended. Boys are not an altogether easy audience to address. But they are in some...

Messrs. T. C. and E. C. Jack send us three

The Spectator

reading-books which have a special use of their own. These are in the "Look-about- You " Nature Study Books, one about trees and another about a variety of common country...

Page 41

City of London Directory, 1907. (W. H. and L. Collingridge.

The Spectator

12e. 6d.)—This directory seems to be as complete and as well up to date as usual. Besides the information found in books of this kind, and its speciality—matters that have to do...

The Handbook to Cyprus, 1907. Compiled by Sir P. T.

The Spectator

Hutchin- son and Claude Delaval Cobham. (E. Stanford. 2s. 6d. net.)— Sir J. T. Hutchinson is Chief Justice of the island and Mr. Cob- ham is Commissioner at Larnaca. The...

NEW EDITIOES. — Original Lyrics. By Thomas Stanley. Edited by L. J.

The Spectator

Guiney. (J. R. Tutin, Hull. ls. 6d. net.)—Thomas Stanley was born in 1625 and died in 1675. An interesting appreciation of the man and his work is given by the editor.— In the "...