5 NOVEMBER 1887

Page 1

The speaking on both sides of the great political issue

The Spectator

of the day outruns so vastly the needs of the reading public, that it can only be justified at all on the ground that the great mass of the electors do not read, and are only...

The riots this week have been slight, but burdensome to

The Spectator

the police, the unemployed every day parading the most thronged thoroughfares, and using occasionally most menacing lan- guage. Some of their leaders threaten a great riot on...

This day week, Sir George Trevelyan made two speeches at

The Spectator

Carnarvon. In the first of these, he called the Liberal Unionists' objection to Home-rule "the miserable excuse of a difference of opinion about a Bill introduced eighteen...

NOTICE. — With this week's " SPECTATOR " is issued, gratis, O

The Spectator

Lrrausity Suerwanwr.

'V The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript, in any

The Spectator

case.

It was expected for a moment in Paris that the

The Spectator

Republican Party, which is now greatly embarrassed by the Wilson scandal, would take advantage of the proposal for the conversion of the Four-and-a-Half per Cent. Loan to turn...

NOT/CE TO ADVERTISERS.

The Spectator

With the " SpEcrexon." of Saturday, November 19th, will be issued, gratis, a SPECIAL LITERARY SUPPLEMENT, the outside pages of which will be devoted to Advertisements....

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

T HE Vienna correspondent of the Times announces that the German Government has changed its Bulgarian policy, and will now earnestly support the Administration of Prince...

Page 2

On Monday, Sir George Trevelyan delivered a speech at Acre.

The Spectator

fair, about two miles from Ruabon, in which he made a sharp attack on the House of Lords, asserting that it is of no use for Irish Members to introduce into the House of Commons...

Perhaps the most immediately important part of Lord Hartington's speech

The Spectator

was his explicit declaration that, till Ireland should surrender the cry for a Parliament which would be a distinctly national Parliament and practically independent of Great...

Mr. Dillon made another furious speech at Limerick on Tuesday,

The Spectator

in the course of which he urged Irishmen not to purchase their farms, but to carry out the " Plan of Campaign," which could be worked this winter more easily than ever. " We,"...

At the same meeting, Lord Hartington made a very forcible

The Spectator

criticism on Sir William Harcourt's remark that the authority of Mr. Gladstone in this country resembles the authority formerly wielded by Cavour in Italy, and that now wielded...

The sentence of three months' imprisonment on Mr. O'Brien for

The Spectator

inciting resistance to the law, has been confirmed on appeal by the Recorder of Cork. When the judgment was delivered on Monday, the warrant for Mr. O'Brien's removal had not...

In his speech at Truro on Monday, Mr. Courtney pointed

The Spectator

out the remarkable position taken by Mr. John Morley in main- taining frankly that what they wanted was to make the Irish- man a " new creature," and that the only way of doing...

The attacks of Mr. Gladstone and Mr. John Morley on

The Spectator

Irish officials have received somewhat uncomfortable contradictions, to which neither Mr. Gladstone nor Mr. Morley has replied satisfac- torily. Mr. Gladstone in his Nottingham...

Page 3

Lord Derby, in a speech at Liverpool on Tuesday, expressed

The Spectator

some apprehension as to the future of national bondholders. He said Europe now owed £1,000,000,000 sterling,—that is, she paid £160,000,000 a year " to the descendants of her...

Immediately after the last order was given to evacuate Egypt,

The Spectator

the Mandi's army began to descend the Nile. The evacuation, therefore, stopped. It is now again proposed to evacuate every- thing but Alexandria, and the European force is being...

The first new cathedral built since the Reformation was con-

The Spectator

secrated on Thursday, at Truro, by the Bishop of the diocese, the Archbishop of Canterbury (who was formerly Bishop of Truro) preaching the sermon, and the Prince of Wales, who...

We deeply regret to record the death of Jenny Lind

The Spectator

(Mrs. Otto Goldschmidt), which occurred on Tuesday. She occupied a special place in Europe. First in her art, perhaps the greatest vocalist who ever lived, she was the one...

Mr. Morley had said in his speech at Halifax that

The Spectator

a Resident Magistrate in Ireland had admitted in the case of Mr. O'Brien, that " he had made up his mind what sentence to pass before he had heard what the prisoner had to say...

The Spectator

A strong party is rising in Canada, with Mr. Goldwin

The Spectator

Smith for spokesman, who advocate Free-trade with the United States. Mr. Goldwin Smith, in a letter published in the Times on Thursday, declares that the subject will be...

The " Congregation " of the University of Oxford was

The Spectator

equally divided on Tuesday on the subject of the statute for creating an honours school in Modern Languages,-92 against 92,—and the result, of course, was that the Proctor gave...

Page 4

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

THE NEXT STEP. -NAT E trust that the Government, in the Cabinet Councils which must be eo frequent this month, will thoroughly thresh out the question of introducing or...

Page 5

this is just what he does not propose to do,—apart

The Spectator

from this to have five years to run before the people can be asked to fact these were not the points on which, a year and a half confirm or retract their judgment on the most...

Page 6

THE BRITISH EMBASSY IN PARIS.

The Spectator

THERE are two theories about the use of the British 1 Embassy in Paris, and Lord Salisbury, in selecting Lord Lytton to succeed Lord Lyons, has acted on the older and, as we...

Page 7

THE ENDACOTT CASE.

The Spectator

T HE trial of Police-Constable Endacott has ended as, from the evidence, it was bound to end, and as it was all along probable it would end, unless popular feeling was to...

THE RUMOURS OF CHANGE.

The Spectator

W E wonder what those critics of the Government who suggest some radical alteration in its constitution or its policy every other day, would think of it if Lord Salisbury were...

Page 8

MR. ARNOLD-FORSTER'S SCHEME.

The Spectator

M R. ARNOLD-POINTER'S scheme for buying Ireland and presenting it to its people, described at length in the November number of the _Nineteenth Century, will need much discussion...

Page 9

THE ROYAL UNIVERSITY OF IRELAND.

The Spectator

A T the public conferring of the degrees of the Royal University of Ireland last week, Lord Emly, the Vice- Chancellor of the University, though he expressed his sense of the...

Page 10

EXAGGERATION.

The Spectator

W E wonder whether it is trne that exaggeration is popular with ordinary people. That must certainly be the impression of the speakers and writers who so recklessly indulge...

Page 11

THE NEW ATTACK ON MISSIONARIES.

The Spectator

W E are not concerned to press home to Canon Taylor his statistical errors. We did not reprint his figures, which were on the face of them preposterous ; and we had previously...

Page 12

M. COQUELIN AT THE ROYALTY THEATRE. A LTHOUGH it is unfortunate that

The Spectator

Mr. Mayer has been unable to procure a more spacious and convenient theatre for his nineteenth season of French plays, the draw- backs of the Royalty do but furnish an...

Page 13

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

WESTERN AUSTRALIA. rTo THE EDITOR OE TEE SEECTAT011...] Sta,—In an article in the Spectator of October 22nd, headed "A Modest Demand," the writer disposes in a somewhat off-...

Page 14

LIBERALISM AND COERCION.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF TIM "eremarea."] BIER In these days of emasculated Liberalism and sentimental Radicalism, when cant seems bodily transferred from the sphere of religion to...

[To TER EDITOR OF TEE SPECTATOR."]

The Spectator

Stn,—The article on" A Roman Catholic Ideal," in the Spectator of October 29th, suggests one or two thoughts that seem to have escaped the notice of the writer. He appreciates...

THE NUMBER OP ANTI-HOME-RULERS IN IRELAND. [To THE EDITOR OP

The Spectator

TEE "SPECTATOR. " ] SIR, —Being a constant reader of your paper, I have several times lately seen it stated in your columns, directly or indirectly, that two out of the five...

THE ROMAN CATHOLIC IDEAL.

The Spectator

rT. TRE EDITOR Or THE "SPECTATOR. "] Stn,—While agreeing with most of your comments on the recently published Life of Miss Vaughan, I yet desire to point out that the matter...

Page 15

LATIN PRONUNCIATION.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR Or THE SPECTETOR.”f Sin, — There is a story told of the late Dean Stanley to the effect that one day when travelling in Roumania, he addressed a small peasant...

WORK FOR THE UNEMPLOYED.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP TEE SPECTATOR."] SIR,—I overlooked the remark quoted by your correspondent, " S. L. P., " or I would have at once answered your challenge. I do not, of...

A JEWISH HUMOURIST. [To TEE EDITOR OP WI •' SPEOTETOE. " . 1

The Spectator

Sin, — It is stated in the article on " A Jewish Hamourist, " which appeared in the Spectator of October 22nd, that M. G. Saphir ' s father was a pedlar. This is a mistake. His...

FACTS FROM GWEEDORE.

The Spectator

[TO TEE EDITOR OF THE SPECTATOR:1 SIR,—Might I be permitted shortly to reply to Mr. Hill ' s letter P The " rundale " system was only applicable to the amble portion of land...

THE LATE MR. TIMING.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF TRH SPECTATOR:1 SIR,—" Honour to whom honour is due. " I am glad to read in the Spectator of October 29th the well-deserved tribute of admiration to the late...

" THE NEW ANTIGONE. "

The Spectator

its THE EDITOR OF TILE “Sexcuma."] SIR,—Your kindness in dealing with my book tempts me to submit for your consideration a remark or two on the point where my critic detects a...

Page 16

BOOKS.

The Spectator

THE LATE DUO DE BROGLIE.* [FIRST NOTICE.] Now that the Souvenirs of the late Doe de Broglie, published in France a year ago, have been translated into English, it is time to...

IN RUGBY CHAPEL.

The Spectator

ARNOLD and Stanley, sowers of good seed, Master and pupil here are graven in stone ; One with strong brow to crush the evil down, Strong faith to inspire, to renovate, to lead :...

POET It Y.

The Spectator

EDWARD THRING. He made men seers, young dreamers to desire The one thing good,—to do the difficult right ; He cast Truth's heart into the fiercest fight, And bade us battle on...

A CARTHUSIAN MONASTERY IN TYROL.

The Spectator

The writer of the interesting letter on the Monastery at Carthans, near Meran, which we published is the Spectator of September 10th, has received the following acknowledgment...

Page 18

PRINCE LUCIFER.*

The Spectator

THERE is much beautiful poetry in this fantasy, for we can hardly call it a drama. We suppose the drift of it to be that while in woman perfect love cannot face death without...

Page 19

HISTOIRE DUNE GRANDE DAME.*

The Spectator

THERE delightful memoirs divide themselves naturally, and are divided by M. Perey, into two parts ; the first, entitled " L'Abbaye- aux-Bois," consisting almost entirely of the...

Page 20

HALDANE'S LIFE OF ADAM SMITH.*

The Spectator

Mn. HALDANE will forgive us for saying that his well-intentioned, and in many respects well-executed, " study " of Adam Smith suggests, in the first place, Emerson's view of...

Page 21

ITALIAN POPULAR POETRY.* " FOLIZ-SONGS," says Miss Busk, "are the

The Spectator

intimate expressions of the ideas of the people." It is an amiable platitude, this, and venerable from its antiquity, originally propounded, perhaps, in that comparatively...

Page 22

NOTABLE PAPERS IN THE MAGAZINES.

The Spectator

ME magazines are a little dull this month, though they contain some readable papers. The one which will excite most atten- tion is the article in the Fortnightly Review on "The...

Page 23

CURRENT LITERATURE.

The Spectator

We are very glad to see a new English edition, prepared by Pro- fessor A. H. Keane, of Dr. Rudolf Gneist's Student's History of the English Parliament. (H. Grevel and Co.) It is...

Page 24

The Best Books : a Reader's Guide to the Choice

The Spectator

of the Beat Available Books (about Tmenty.five Thousand) in every Department of Science, Art, and Literature. By William Swan Sonnenschein. (Swan Sonnensehein and Co.)—It would...

Prison•Life in Siberia. By Feeder Dostoleffeky. Sole and authorised translation,

The Spectator

by H. Sutherland Edwards. (T. and E. Maxwell.)—The title of this book, if not actually deceptive, is decidedly misleading. The work purports to be a translation of...

Shores and Alps of Alaska. By H. W. Seton Karr,

The Spectator

F.G.S. (Sampson Low and Co.)—This is a model book of travel. "The clearest and simplest manner of describing a journey of exploration, of sport, or of adventure," says Mr. Karr,...

Gretchen a Novel. By "Rita." (Ward and Downey.) — The no- sophisticated

The Spectator

maiden who talks prettily to herself in a green wood, within hearing of the golden youth who shall presently awaken her fair soul, and speedily induce her to trust her future to...

A Paraguayan Treasure. By Alexander F. Baillie, F.R.G.S. (Simpkin, Marshall,

The Spectator

and Co.)—This book is so realistic, in its best sense, that it took us some time to decide whether it was a true history or a fictitious narrative. The author is evidently of...

Page 25

New EDIT1ON3. — The Odyssey of Homer, done into English Prose by

The Spectator

S. H. Butcher, M.A., and A. Lang, M.A. (Macmillan), a "new and cheaper edition" of a translation which has taken an unques- tioned place aa a standard.—The Geology of England...

The Lady's World (Cassell and Co.) has, with the November

The Spectator

part, become the Woman's World, and is now edited by Mr. Oscar Wilde, who has already obtained for the magazine the support of a large number of ladies both of culture and of...

PUBLICATIONS OP THE WEEK.

The Spectator

Adventures Ashore and Afloat, cr Svo (R.T.S 1 2,0 Anderson (A. A.), Twenty-Five Team in a Waggon, 2 vole. (Chapman A Hall) 24/0 Athanasios on the Incarnation, translated by F....

BOOKS B.ECE1VED. — Patents Conveyancing a Collection of Precedents in Conveyancing. By

The Spectator

Robert Morris, M.A. (Stevens and Sons.)—The Anglo-Indian Codes. Edited by Whitley Stokes, D.C.L. Vol. I., Sub- stantive Laws. (The Clarendon Press.)—The Duties and Rights of...

Page 26

The Spectator

Applications for Copies of the SPECTATOR, and Communications upon matters

The Spectator

of business, should not be addressed to the EDITOR, but to the PUBLISHER, 1 Wellington Street, Strand, W.C.

DEATH.

The Spectator

JECONS. — On the 3rd inst., at 11 Weimer Road, Birkdale, Southport, Elise Augusta. the wife of William Alfred Jevons, aged 6/ years.

The SPECTATOR is on Sale regularly at MESSRS. CUPPLES, Uralar,

The Spectator

AND CO. ' S, 283 Washington Street, Boston, Mass., 17.S.A., where single Copies can be obtained, and Subscriptions are received.

The Spectator

Page 32

Lone.: Printed by J03171 Cease... of No. 1 Wellington Street,

The Spectator

in the Precinct of the Savoy, Strand, in the County of Middlesex. at 18 Exeter Street, Mrs. ; and Published by him at the" Bremsroa" Office, No. 1 Wellington Street, Strand,...

Page 33

SPECIAL LITERARY SUPPLEMENT

The Spectator

TO the vrtator No. 3,097.] FoIt THE WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 5, 1887. [ T „,,==,%„=,,,}oB.A.ria.

Page 35

BOOKS.

The Spectator

MUSIC AND MANNERS.* Is it savours not a little of sacrilege to criticise the utterances of a writer who boasts "a somewhat exhaustive acquaintance with European despots," and...

iiterarp Ouppitnunt.

The Spectator

LONDON: NOVEMBER 5, 1887.

Page 36

MARZIO'S CRUCIFIX.*

The Spectator

Ir no doubt sometimes happens that the person who reads a book, or looks at a picture, sees more meaning, more suggestion of one kind or another, than the writer or painter...

Page 37

RUSSIAN AND FRENCH PRISONS.*

The Spectator

ON all matters appertaining to the prisons of Russia and France, Prince Kropotkin is able to speak with authority. He has spent in them several years of his life, and his first...

Page 39

M. EBERS'S " BRIDE OF THE NILE."

The Spectator

IT ie impossible to g ive an outline, concise and yet complete, of a narrative which, like M. Ebers's Bride of the Nile, forms one consecutive stream of episode and action,—one...

THE NEW EDITION OF LUCAN'S " PHA.RSALIA."* As this edition

The Spectator

is expressly desi g ned for "Students at the University and the hi g her forms in schools," it is difficult to understand why Mr. Haskin g s has deviated from the common...

Page 41

COLONIAL FRANCE.* Tin: title of these two books is a

The Spectator

significant one. There is not, there never has been, a "Colonial" Britain, unless the Crown Colonies may be grouped under such a designation ; for our Colonies, almost from...

SINGING SCOTCH ROUND THE WORLD.*

The Spectator

GLOBE-TROTTING, whether for pleasure or on what are euphemistically but inaccurately styled " professional tours," is so overdone, that but for special circumstances, which are...

Page 43

The Massage Case. By Cyril Bennett. 3 vols. (T. Fisher

The Spectator

Unwin ) —The author of this novel seems to have some grievances which he or she (let ns say, by preference, " she") has to air, aversions which she wishes to denounce, and...

is, by the trial of " Alloard Skinner "—to tell

The Spectator

the history of the Sisterhood of St. Mary-at-the-Cross. And he has done this in a most 'satisfactory way, by publishing a number of letters written from time to time, and...

Ancient Egypt. By George Rawlinson, M.A. (T. Fisher Unwin.)— This

The Spectator

volume is one of a series which has more than once been noticed in our columns, "The Story of the Nations." Something more, perhaps, might have been said about Egyptian...

The Book of Patience. By Walter Wood. (W. H. Allen

The Spectator

and Co.)— Mr. Wood describes and gives directions for playing more than thirty games of " patience." Some of them he illustrates, and it is on these that he recommends the...

CURRENT LITERATURE.

The Spectator

Incidents of Indian Life. By the Rev. J. Cave-Browne. (W. H. Allen and Co.)—A retired Indian Chaplain here tells, and tells very well, some striking stories of the East. These...

Page 44

Of technical books we have received :—Sprains: their Consequences and

The Spectator

Treatment. By C. W. Mansell Moak!. (II. K. Lewis.)—It would have been as well to say expressly whether they aro in- tended for the profession or for lay readers. There are...

Charles Haddon Spurgeon. By G. Holden Pike. (Hodder and Stonghton.)—If

The Spectator

posthumonsbiographies are commonly too laudatory, what shall we say of those that are published in the subject's lifetime ? However, it is the fashion of the time, and it is...

Fashionable Philosophy, and other Sketches. By Laurence Oliphant. (W. Blackwood

The Spectator

and Sons.)—This volume displays in a remarkable way the versatility of this writer. "The Brigand's Bride" is a most charming little story, with merits curiously different from...

Farthing Dinners, by George Herbert Sargent (Simpkin and Marshall), is

The Spectator

an interesting little pamphlet, relating some really wonderful results. "The very cheapest dinners," he says, " are by far the most popular." What are these dinners ? may be...

Passions Subdued. By Louisa Lacy. (London Literary Society.) —This is

The Spectator

a very quaint book. Brongh Duval is left in charge of two brothers much younger than himself, whom he trains by a liberal one of the horsewhip. Brough had very decided views. He...

Witnesses for Christ. By Edward Baokhouse and George Tyler. 2

The Spectator

vole. (Hamilton, Adams, and Co.)—These two volumes are, in fact, a fragmentary Church history, giving an account of prominent per- sonages and events during a period of about...

The Reformed Church of Ireland (1537-1886). By the Right Hon.

The Spectator

P. F. Ball. (Longmans, London ; Hodges, Figgie, and Co., Dublin.) —Dr. Ball's volume is a contribution of some value to ecclesiastical history, especially as regards the...

The Misrule of Henry III. ; and Edward III. and

The Spectator

his Wars,--the first edited by the Rev. W. H. Hatton, the second by W. J. Ashley, M.A. (David Nutt),—belong to a series which is appearing under the super- intendence of Mr....

We have received the fifth volume of The Expositor. Edited

The Spectator

by the Rev. W. Robertson Nicoll, M.A.: (Hodder and Stonghton.)—No papers are more interesting than those is which Professor Sunday disousees "The Origin of the Christian...

Scott's Poems. (David Bryce and Son, Glasgow.)—Here are all the

The Spectator

poems in six miniature volumes, enclosed in a case. The case and all weigh together something less than 10 oz., and can be conveniently carried in a coat-pocket ; the separate...

Page 45

Seven Years among the Fjort. By R. C. Dennett. (Sampson

The Spectator

Low and Co.)—Mr. Dennett is anxious to make us know a little more about the negro, and certainly contrives to do so by means of pen and pencil. Photographs and drawings, which...

TALEa. — Locked Up. By Major Arthur Griffiths. (1V. Blackwood and Sons.)—Major

The Spectator

Griffiths has made the beet of a not very profitable story. An heiress concealed under the disguise of a shop-girl, and a young officer who falls in love with her, may be...

Cathedral Bays. By Anna Bowman Dodd. (Ward and Downey.) —"

The Spectator

We air a great nation," said Mr. Hannibal Chollop to Martin Chnzzlewit the younger ; "and we most be cracked up" (we quote from memory). Mrs. A. B. Dodd "cracks us np," and we...

Soap. By Constance McEwen. (Simpkin and Marshall.)—Miss McEwen tells a

The Spectator

story—if it may be called a story—of a gentleman who is clever and cultured and good, but labours under the double disadvantage of being rich and having made his money by soap....

Through Green Glasses. By F. M. Allen. Illustrated by M.

The Spectator

Fitzgerald. (Ward and Downey.)—So far as we remember, the name of F. M. Allen is a new one in literature, and as his title-page does not credit him with any previous works, we...

Scott's Marmion. Edited, with Introduction and Notes, by M. Macmillan,

The Spectator

B.A. Oxon. (Macmillan and Co.)—It is easy to point to the faults of Marmion an a work of art ; and Mr. Macmillan may perhaps be right in saying that it is the most unequal of...