7 OCTOBER 1916, Page 24

NURSERY RHYMES:*

Nurae Leveckdd'a Legacy, besides "being: a mighty fine -col/cation of tho most noble, memorable and -veracious Nursery Rhymes," -as the title--page-has it, is a most engaging little book of a fashion:made familiar by the ultra-modem producers of the "-Flying Fame " broadsheets. Its inky embellishments by Mr. Levet Fraser are every whit as "- Period "

as the text, for which eighteenth- and early nineteenthoentury chap- books have been drawn upon. In, some eases the reader receives the sort of shook comparable to that erperienced when reading -the Bible

in the " other " version, or in the Greek cesis-m. al. For example

"-Patty-cake, Patty-cake, Baker's man, Bake me a cake

As fast as you can. Prick it and prick it And mark it -with T, -And put in the oven For Jacky. and.m.e."

Where are the dear familiar (if heretical) "Pat-a-cake," " Pat it and prick it," and "Tommy and me " ? None of the -present • writer's generation will ever question that in this instance evolution' has brought improvement, or that the version of their youth is the best of all possible

renderings, first folios and precious-early editions notwithstanding. Of course the juxtaposition of " T " and " Jacky" subtly introduces a problem likely to be fruitful of endless explanations and embroidery :

how "T," for instaneesas it-cannot-stand for " Jacky," must obviously stand for " Me,,' and how " Me " must therefore equally obviously be .Jacky's senior=his big brother, parent, -or guardian, or perhaps his little sister,-who would naturally take the-lead in dealings with a baker's

man, and whose initial (she being called Tilde). would very properly

grace the cake-in preference to that of Jacky, he being merely a brother. 'This particular explanation is specially prepared for little boys—a version appropriate to little girls would of course -differ. For an audience of " mixed infants " the problem -would -demand• yet another solution, if a moral is to be pointed. But the engaging feature of most of the old rhymes is that they are-utterly innocent -of any ulterior moral motive - -some, indeed, heing cynically subversive of the moral atmosphere proper. to a Christian nursery. Witness this-version Of• the aequel in the Jack and Jill- tragedy:—

"Then up Jack get And home did trot

As fast as he could caper,

And went to bed To -mend his head With vinegar and brown- paper."

Not a word, not a thought for poor Jill, lying 'there gelatinously helpless at the foot of the fatal hill. If she was indeed thus, it was -clearly " up to" Jack to stand by and " first-ald " her; Whilst -if, through' breaking her fall on Jack, she was merely shaken, her place would obviously be at

Jack's bedeide, smoothing his pillow and caressing his damaged crown. It is all very unsatisfactory.