3 MAY 1919

Page 1

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

T HE chief event of the week was the Budget statement of Mr. Austen Chamberlain on Wednesday. There is really only one point of view from which it is right to regard this...

He digressed at this point to remark that the famous

The Spectator

Land Values Duties of 1909-10 had proved unworkable, as most intelligent people predicted at the time. Mr. Lloyd George, their author, now agreed that the duties must be amended...

The current year, Mr. Chamberlain continued, would be wholly abnormal,

The Spectator

though the expenditure would be less than half that of last year. The Estimates which he had presented were largely conjectural. Since they were published, he had had to lend...

Mr. Chamberlain began by stating that the expendi- ture for

The Spectator

the past year had been £2,579,301,000— or £392,896,000 less than the estimate--and that the revenue had been £889,021,000—or £46,971,000 more than the estimatp. The deficit, met...

Mr. Chamberlain, recalling with filial pride his father's advocacy of

The Spectator

Imperial Preference, announced that the Budget would give effect to the decision of the Imperial War Cabinet and Conference of 1917, which in turn was founded on the policy...

Mr. Chamberlain impressed on the House the urgent need for

The Spectator

economy on the part of the Government and the private citizen. He outlined the Budget of a normal year, perhaps in or after 1922. The revenue would be £652,000,000 on the...

The National Debt, Mr. Chamberlain said, had risen from £645,000,000

The Spectator

at the outbreak of war to £7,435,000,000 on March 31st last—or £545,000,000 less than Mr. Boner Law anticipated a year ago. Of this vast total we owed £1,350,000,000 to foreign...

The new taxes, Mr. Chamberlain continued, would not include a

The Spectator

Luxury Tax nor any increase of the Income Tax and Super Tax, which were the subject of a full inquiry by a Royal Commission. He proposed to raise £19,850,000 by increasing the...

*** The Bdttor cannot accept responsibility for any articles or

The Spectator

lettere submitted to him, but when stamped and addressed envelopes are sent he will do his best to return contributions in caw of rejection.

Page 2

The American delegates, however, dissented from the emend part of

The Spectator

the Report. They propose that there should be penalties only for breaches of international Conventions, and not for particular deeds which have offended against the general...

The first of these clauses begins with the following words

The Spectator

: " The Allied and Associated Powers publicly arraign William II. of Hohenzollern, formerly German Emperor, not for an offence against criminal law, but for a supreme offence...

The Chancellor of the Exchequer concluded by saying that file

The Spectator

new taxes would yield in a full normal year £108,950,000, including the temporary Excess Profits Duty of £50,000,000, and would produce this year £41,450,000 in additional net...

The Report of the Peace Conference Committee on War Crimea

The Spectator

was summarized in the papers of Monday. According to this summary, it is divided into two parts. The first deals with the responsibility for the - war itself, and the second...

The Italian Chamber responded to Signor Orlando's appeal by affirming

The Spectator

its confidence in the Government. Three hundred and eighty Deputies voted for the motion ; only -forty advanced Socialists, who are always " agin the Government " on principle,...

It is essential for the Great Powers to make it

The Spectator

clearly under- stood that the legal agreements and moral customs of nations which have been so painfully built up by the growth-of civilization cannot: be defied without dire...

Signor Orlando:on his journey- through Italy was applauded by enthusiastic

The Spectator

crowds, and at Rome last Saturday he had an enthusiastic greeting. In a speech outside the railway station he said that Italy had a grave decision to take. " Food supplies are...

Mr. Adamson, for the Labour Party, •advised the Government to

The Spectator

practise economy—advice which comes oddly from such a quarter. He advocated the raising of the minimum taxable income to £250, and the abolition of indirect taxation on all...

We record with pleasure the appointment of Sir Eric Drum-

The Spectator

mond as Secretary-General to the League of Nations, with headquarters at Geneva. The choice of a British diplomatist for this important post is a high -compliment to Great...

Before leaving Paris on Thursday week, Signor Orlando issued a

The Spectator

statement in reply to the manifesto in which-President Wilson rejected the Italian claim to Fiume. The Italian Premier expressed regret that the President should have seemed to...

We have several times stated our opinion that the punish-

The Spectator

ment of the Kaiser and the high authorities who procured the war would be an act of genuine importance, impressive for both moral and symbolical reasons. If It were to be an act...

The German Peace Delegates, headedby the. Foreign Minister, Count Brockdorff-Reatzau,

The Spectator

arrived at Versailles on Tuesday. It is uncertain, as we write on Thursday, whether they have full powers to sign a Treaty, or when the Allied terms will be presented to them...

Page 3

President Wilson on Tuesday week formally recognized the British Protectorate

The Spectator

in Egypt. He said at the same time that the American people " have every sympathy with the legitimate aspirations of the Egyptian people for a further measure of self-...

The outbreak of disorder in India has been checked, but

The Spectator

there is still some -unrest in the Punjab, where flying columns have been employed to arrest rioters. The Moelem rowdies in the Punjab are said to have been incited by...

The Porter in Macbeth remarked that his place was "

The Spectator

too cold for hell " ; and even elderly maiden ladles, emboldened by the laxity in language learnt in war time, must be inclined to- echo his words at the close of a bitter...

When the House of Commons reassembled on Tuesday, Sir Robert

The Spectator

Home defended the administration of the unemploy- ment donation, which would be made the, subject of inquiry by a Committee. It had been abused, he said, but not so much as the...

The:Coal Commission resumed its sittings on Thursday week. Mr: Justice

The Spectator

Sankey said that- it would report not later than June 20th on the proposal to nationalize the coal-mines. The• ease against nationalization was well stated by Professor Carman,...

Lord Burnham, of the. Daily Telegraph, and Lord Rothermere, of the

The Spectator

Daily Mirror, as we have already said, both go up a step. Lord Burnham has been a most faithful liaison officer between the daily newspaper Press and the Government, and Lord...

We greatly regret to record the death on Wednesday of

The Spectator

Sir John Mahaffy, Provost of Trinity College, Dublin. He was eighty years of age. A learned scholar, an attractive writer, a brilliant talker, and a good sportsman, Sir John...

The Honours List was issued on Monday evening, during an

The Spectator

outburst on the part of our wonderful climate, which did its beet to make us forget that the List had been postponed from the New Year. The List contains four new Barons,...

Towards the end of last week the air was released

The Spectator

from war service-for civilian. purposes, and no doubt civilians of enterprise and courage will shortly use private two-seater biplanes for week-ending journeys to country...

The Coalition has lost a third seat in Central Aberdeenshire,

The Spectator

At the General , Election the late Colonel Gordon, as a Coalition Unionist, defeated the old Liberal Member, Mr. J. M. Henderson, by 638 votes. In the by-election, the result of...

Bank rate, 5 per eent.;changed from 5i. per cent. April

The Spectator

5, 1917.

Page 4

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

THE BUDGET. O UR fir st reflection on reading the Budget statement which Mr. Chamberlain made in the House of Commons on Wednesday is that we may thank our stars for having in...

Page 5

THE COVENANT.

The Spectator

IT is extremely di ffi cult to write in a spirit that will be both just and helpful about the final text of the Covenant creating the League of Nations. Let us say at once that...

Page 6

THE REAL AMERICAN VIEW OF THE IRISH -QUESTION.

The Spectator

T HE Irish Nationalists and their few remaining Liberal friends have revived of late the old and false argu- ment that we must give Ireland Home Rule, or inde- pendence, or...

Page 7

CHURCH: MU) STATE.—A, VINDICATION OF ENGLISH ERASTIANISM:—IV.

The Spectator

NONCONFORMITY AND TRH LAW OF THE LAND. T HE law of England would certainly seem to support the view that the object of the Articles, whatever their form, was to include rather...

Page 8

IMPERSONAL POSSESSIONS.

The Spectator

[ ' OR some natures envy does not exist, even in its most In innocent form—the longing to possess. It is not that they do not perceive beauty or know what is desirable, but the...

Page 9

WEEDS.

The Spectator

W EEDS postulate a weeder, and the enthusiastic weeder would asseverate that it is the practice of this craft which makes the garden " the purest of human pleasures." Bacon...

Page 10

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

[Letters of the length of one of our leading paragraphs are often more read, and therefore more effective, than those which fill treble the spaced THE METHODS OF INDIAN...

INDIA'S FUTURE.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or raa " SPECTATOR.") Sim —The recent disturbances in India and in Egypt will, it is to be hoped, somewhat moderate the zeal of those who are in favour of giving...

Page 11

CHURCH AND STATE.

The Spectator

(To TEL EDITOR 07 THE " SPECTATOR.") SIR.—Your interesting articles on the English Church and what it owes to being " establiehed " demand some protest, and one who is a...

"THE LIBERTY OF PROPHESYING." [To THE Enrroa OS THY "

The Spectator

SPECTATOR."] Sus.—Let me point out that the liberty spoken of in 2 Cor. iii. 17 is the setting free from the slavery of sin, not any other kind of liberty. So the author of the...

STATE HOUSING.

The Spectator

[To THE Enrroa or THE " SPECTATOR."] SM.—Your correspondent Mr. A. W. Carter in your issue of April 19th 'refers to a letter of mine which you were geed enough to insert in your...

ITo THE Enrroa Or Tae " SPECTATOR.")

The Spectator

SM.—Churchfolk in the country, and especially perhaps in the North, seta great store on their ancient parish churches in a way that dwellers in cities and towns scarcely...

[To THE EDITOR 07 TIM " Srzereroa."]

The Spectator

Sus,—Many a letter have you been good enough to accept from me during the last quarter of a century, which has had as its theme the warning "Beware of an-Churehing the nation !...

AN APPEAL FOR SIMPLICITY IN LEADERSHIP. [To un Emma or

The Spectator

um " SPIMT1Ten."1 See,—After reading "An Appeal for Simplicity in Leadership " in your issue of April 19th, I venture to call your attention to the following extracts from...

Page 12

THE RUMANIAN LOCOMOTIVES.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or THE " SPECTATOR.") SIR,—ID your illuminating article upon "Our Allies in Central Europe " you refer to the removal by the enemy of the Ruma- nian locomotives....

MUSEUM GUIDES.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.") STS, —Some readers of the article on "Museum Guides" in the Spectator of April 12th may be interested to know that in 1895 an effort, which...

LANGUAGE AND MUSIC... •

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or THE " SPECTATOR.") Sin,—When your contributor " Ignotus" cries that "language is the devil," and strives to find comfort in the thought that perhaps music is...

"THE HOME I WANT."

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR Or TER " SPECTAT01."3 Fte,—In your review of Captain Reiss'e book, The Home I Want, in your issue of April 12th I was glad to see the archi- tectural aspect of...

THE LIBRARY OF LOUVAIN.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or THE " SPECTATOR."] the subject of Sir Alfred Hopkinson's letter of appeal for the Library of Louvain, may I call the attention of the Sinn Feiners to the fact...

Page 13

KINDNESS TO ANIMALS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR Or THE " SPECTATOR.") Sin,—The reference by one of your correspondents to the kind treatment of animals in Norway (which greatly added to my own pleasure on the...

THE RACES OF IRELAND.

The Spectator

(To THY EDrfOR or THE "SPECTATOR.") Sot,—In a letter recently published in the Times Mr. Francis H. Skrine suggests that the Irish Provinces should be given separate local...

A PROPHETIC WARNING.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR. or THE " SPECTATOR.") SIE,—Pe-reading the poems of Mr. H. G. Hewlett (father of Mi. Maurice Hewlett), I have been much struck by the follow. ing sonnet to...

ENGLISH AND SCOTS SERMONS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or TAE " SPECTATOR.") SI2,—In the Spectator of April 19th your reviewer of The Religion of the Beatitudes draws a strong contrast between English and Scots...

PROHIBITION IN AMERICA.

The Spectator

(To THE Eorroa or ran " SPECTATOR.") Sra, 7be adoption of the Prohibition Amendment in the United States was simply the culmination of a movement which was greatly accelerated...

Page 14

MEN AND MEASURES.

The Spectator

ITo ens Enrroa or ems "8ezorson."3 Sue—Some time ago you published various criticisms of the Montagu-Chelmsford Report. It may, even now, interest your readers to know the views...

UNIVERSITY EXPENSES.

The Spectator

ITo THE EDITOR or TEE " SPELTA'POR.") SIR,—The letter from a College Bursar in your issue of April 19th illustrates the inequality of lots which these evil times have brought...

THE EXTRAORDINARY EPITAPH.

The Spectator

LT° ran Beams or an "SHOTAT03."3 • Sro,—It may interest you to know that the High Email tomb- -stone was erected to the memory of Elizabeth Barklamb—a name that would have...

A SAILOR'S DOG IN WAR TIME.

The Spectator

(To THE EDITOR or THE " SPECTLTOR.") SIR,—Many adventures have been thoroughly enjoyed by Yel, a magnificent Airedale terrier, the property of Commander Davenport, of...

ENGLISHMEN AND ANIMALS.

The Spectator

Pro THE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR.") Ste.—In the letter on the above subject, signed F. A. Starge, published in your issue of April 12th, the writer says: " Have you forgotten...

ght *Ftrtator

The Spectator

We suggest that there can be no better Present in Peace or War than an Annual Subscription to the Spectator. He or she who gives the Spectator as a present will give a weekly...

Page 15

POETRY.

The Spectator

THE BABY. Woo are you, Child? What the Company you passed upon the wing? What is your bourne? What theirs? What message do you bring? You are my Father and Mother, and I, I...

BOOKS.

The Spectator

THE YEARS BETWEEN.* Witte Tennyson died, and while the Laureateship was still in abeyance, the editors of the Idler invited a number of dis- tinguished living writers to suggest...

NOTICE.—When "Correspondence" or Articles are signed with the writer's name

The Spectator

or initials, or with a pseudonym, or are marked"Communicated," the Editor must not necessarily beheld to be in agreement with the views therein expressed or with the mode of...

Page 16

UNCLE REMUS.*

The Spectator

JOEL CHANDLER HARRIS, the creator of "Uncle Remus" and the best beloved of all Georgian worthies, came of good Georgian stock on his mother's aide. His father, an Irishman,...

Page 17

THE PROBLEM OF THE PACIFIC.*

The Spectator

THOSE who read Mr. Fletcher's important book on The New Pacific will be glad to know that he has returned to the subject. The Pacific is far away, but the importance of its...

Page 18

STUDIES IN CHRISTIANITY.•

The Spectator

Fear is often a more effectual solvent of theory than any rival theory. The stronger forms of Saeramentalism find the spiritu- ality of Quakerism, which has no Sacraments, a...

VESTIGIA.*

The Spectator

COLONEL REg/NGTON'S memoirs axe very well worth reading. He ends the book on the eve of the war, and, in obedience to a Censor who still flourishes despite the obituary notices...

Page 19

FIOTION.

The Spectator

WHAT NOT.* Tics late Mr. Oliver Onions gave tm some time ago an in- teresting imaginative romance of Reconstruction in the post- helium period. But while not discarding...

TOWNS TO LIVE LX.*

The Spectator

THE Civic Arts Association may well be proud of Professor Lethaby's addition to its little library. In Towns to Live in he concentrates the wisdom of a dozen tedious treatises...

Page 20

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

[Sake in Ibis column does not necessarily preclude subsequent review.] Judge Parry has amused himself, we are sure, in writing Drink and Industrial Unrest (True Temperance...

READABLE NOYELS.—The Land Girl's Love Story. By Berta Ruck. (Hodder

The Spectator

and Stoughton. 6s. net.)—An entertaining account of a Land Girls' Camp, in which the tender passion seems to have found an ample field for expression.--Countess Glika. By...

The People's Faith in the Time of Wyclif. By B.

The Spectator

L. Manning. (Cambridge University Press. 7e. 6d. net.)—This very able and stimulating essay on the Church and the popular religion of the later fourteenth century deserves...

Dr. Archibald Scott of SE. George's, Edinburgh, and his Timm•

The Spectator

By Lord Sands. (Blackwood. 16s. net.)—This book by a Scottish Judge about a popular Edinburgh minister, who died in 1909, is a very unconventional biography. -Lord Sands,...

Aristophanes and the War Party, By Gilbert Murray. (Allen and

The Spectator

Unwin. Is. net.)—This witty study in the contemporary criticism of the Peloponnesian War, chiefly in Aristophanes, formed the Creighton Lecture of November last. Professor...

Messrs. Constable have now published here The Education of Henry

The Spectator

Adams (21s. net), the American edition of which we reviewed at length some time ago. The title must not deter any one from reading this witty and fascinating autobiography. The...

Little Games for Coming Seasons. By Lady Bell. (Arthur L,

The Spectator

Humphreys. Is. net.)—Lady Bell's little social satires are inimitable. - They look so innocent that the unwary have been known to resort to them for hints as to new indoor...

Page 21

Pushed and the Return Push. By Quex. (Blackwood. 6s. net.)—This

The Spectator

spirited narrative of the enemy offensive of March, 1918, and of the British offensive that began on August 8th last, as seen by a gunner, has been eprinted from Blackwood's. It...

The Carnegie Endowment publishes through the Clarendon Press a volume

The Spectator

containing the first two of a series of Preliminary Viinomic Studies of the War, edited by Professor Kinley (4s. 6d. net). Mr. Adam Shortt describes the effects of the war upon...

Swings and Roundabouts. By T. McDonald.Rendle. (Chap- man and Hall.

The Spectator

15s. net.)—Mr. Rendle, looking back over thirty years of life in London as a hard-working journalist and an inveterate playgoer, describes for us the infinite variety of...

The State. By Woodrow Wilson. Revised by E. Elliott. (Heath.

The Spectator

10s. 6d. net.)—This is a revised edition of President Wilson's early work describing the Governments of the chief States, with brief historical notes. His brother-in-law,...

Messrs. Edward Stanford's new Peace Conference Atlas (3s.) is the

The Spectator

very thing that is needed to elucidate the boundary questions which are being debated so vigorously in Paris. It contains twenty-four maps, including an index map of Europe, and...

Messrs. Longman have reprinted William Morris's five well-known lectures on

The Spectator

Hopes and Fears for Art in a neat pocket edition (3s. 6d. net). His pie ; for a more serious consideration of architecture should be read again in these days of great building...