15 JANUARY 1916

Page 1

In the Eastern theatre of the war the week has

The Spectator

been marked by Russian advances of the most encouraging kind. With a gallantry and determination of the type which always dis- tinguishes the Russian Army at its best, the type...

Sir John Simon made another, though milder, attempt to ruin

The Spectator

his late colleagues. He opposed the Bill, he declared, on grounds of principle and on grounds of expediency. In his arduous hunt for arguments against the Bill he clutched...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

O F news from the Western front this week there is little, except that the Germans made an unsuccessful attack in Champagne in which three divisions were involved. Earlier in...

The only bad piece of news during the week, and

The Spectator

we must confess that it is very disagreeable, is that published on Wed- nesday. Mount Lovtchen, the position which overhangs the Austrian naval base at Cattaro, has been stormed...

We do not for a moment believe that any large

The Spectator

body of Eng- lishmen will take refuge behind this clause, and support by perjury their desire to escape the duty of serving their country in arms. The conscientious objector...

The debates on the Military Service Bill ended on Wednesday

The Spectator

night with a veritable triumph for the Government, the second reading being carried by the huge majority of 392, only 39 Members voting against the Bill and 431 for it. Thus the...

The standard of the speeches in Wednesday's debate was very

The Spectator

high. Mr. Ellis Griffith made a brave and able speech in which he gave a crushing reply to the accusation that he was acting against the traditions of his party. "I care nothing...

The Salonika news still continues good. We and the French

The Spectator

are every day gaining strength from reinforcements, and still more from the improvement in the line of field fortifications (strengthened by a powerful artillery), which runs...

Now the fruition of our fears allows us to speak

The Spectator

out. A.4 long as the Austrian Fleet remains in being the Allies are deprived of the use of the great opportunities given to them by the exposed sea front of Dalmatia and...

NOTICE.—With this neck's number of the " Sinter Amu" is

The Spectator

issued, gratis, an Eight-Page Supplement, containing the Half- Yearly Index and Title-Page—i.e., from July 3rd to December 25th, 1915, inclusive.

*** The Editor cannot undertake to return Manuscript in any

The Spectator

case.

Page 2

The second-reading debate on the Compulsion Bill was opened in

The Spectator

the House of Commons on Tuesday, when the rejection was moved by a Labour Member, Mr. Anderson. It is scarcely possible to imagine more depressing conditions for his task. Most...

. Mr. Asquith's. reply was exceedingly powerful. After vindi- cating

The Spectator

the policy of "unmarried men first" by a quotation of two verses from the delightful ballad describing Henry V.'s system of recruitment, he dealt with the attempt that has been...

On Thursday week in the Commons the features of the

The Spectator

first- reading debate were the speeches of Mr. Samuel and Mr. Balfour. Mr. Samuel tore into tatters the statistical web-spinning of Sir John Simon. It was inaccurate to say, as...

Colonel John Ward, the former secretary of the Navvies' Union,

The Spectator

delivered an impassioned speech in support of com- pulsion which made a deep impression on the House. Mr. G. N. Barnes also sturdily defended the Bill, and it was evident that...

During the week enlistment under the group system by the

The Spectator

young unmarried men has been distinctly good. Unless however, there is a. greater enlightenment among the compellable men a considerable number of them will still have to be...

Mr. Asquith ended a very able speech by an appeal

The Spectator

for unity. That was a very natural position for a Prime Minister at such a crisis. We venture to differ from him, however. We cannot help thinking that this is just a case in...

After an admirable speech from Colonel Page Croft, in which

The Spectator

he told the House how he found a peasant woman in France reading the announcement of the Government policy in a French newspaper, and how she said to him : "That means the...

As advocates for many years of the principle of compulsion,

The Spectator

we should like to add our assurance that, did we think the present Bill could by any possibility lead to any system by which men could be forced to work at their trades at Army...

After touching on the danger of an inconclusive peace, Mr.

The Spectator

Henderson dealt faithfully with Mr. Snowden's ridiculous allegation that the Bill was the outcome of a conspiracy by a certain section of the Cabinet. In the course of his...

In spite of Mr. Balfour's masterly appeal, a division was

The Spectator

forced. The result was 403 votes for the introduction of the Bill and 105 against. The minority was composed of fifty- eight Nationalists, thirty-four Liberals, and only...

Page 3

The German Embassy in Washington has announced that the German

The Spectator

Government are ready to satisfy the United States in the Lusitania ' dispute. The German Government are pre- pared to admit that the sinking of the vessel was an illegal act,...

It is quite likely, when the six hundred thousand men

The Spectator

who are the subject-matter of Mr. Asquith's Bill have been fined down, first by the voluntary enlistments, next by the decisions of the doctors, and finally by the exemptions as...

We much regret to record the loss of the battleship

The Spectator

'King Edward VU.,' which was sunk by a mine. The ship's company were taken off without loss of life in spite of a heavy sea, and only two men were injured. The King Edward VII.'...

No doubt the efforts of officers of all ranks, from

The Spectator

General to subaltern, and from subaltern to sergeant and corporal, will be strictly exerted to give the compelled men every possible chance and to prevent their being looked...

In Gallipoli miracle has followed upon miracle. It might have

The Spectator

been thought that the Turks, having suffered the great humiliation of allowing their enemy to slip away unobserved from Suvla, would not let the same thing happen at Helles ;...

. The Austrian Government have tried to add humour, though

The Spectator

that is no doubt impossible, to the tragedy of assassination by submarine. Through the United States they have appealed to the British Government to grant the request of...

The news from Mesopotamia shows that while General Town- shend

The Spectator

is besieged at Kut-el-Amara, General Aylmer has met with considerable resistance in his march along the Tigris to relieve the garrison. The Turks who are between General Aylmer...

Though the Prime Minister has as yet refrained from pointing

The Spectator

this out, we do sincerely hope that the Press and other leaders of public opinion will make it clear to what a disagreeable adventure the compelled man is exposing himself....

Sir George Reid, who is retiring from his position as

The Spectator

High Commissioner for Australia, has been returned to the House of Commons unopposed as Member for St. George's, Hanover Square. He was invited by both Liberals and...

The financial braggadocio of Dr. Helfferich seems to have done

The Spectator

more harm than good, as might have been expected, since you cannot allay the anxieties of the Bourses with rhetoric. In Switzerland the German exchange has dropped to 92—tho...

The Times of Wednesday gave some details of the brave

The Spectator

challenge issued by Cardinal Mercier and the Belgian Bishops to the German and Austrian Roman Catholic Episcopate to establish a tribunal of inquiry into the allegations of...

Bank Rate, 5 per cent., changed from 6 p.c. Aug.

The Spectator

8th, 1911.

Page 4

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

■ -•-■410.-■ "THE FREEDOM OF THE SEAS." T HE Times correspondent at Washington in Wednes- day's issue quotes the New York World as responsible for the statement that the...

Page 5

SIR IAN HAMILTON'S DESPATCH.

The Spectator

S IR IAN HAMILTON'S despatch describing the Dardanelles operations from the end of June to October 16th, 1915, will be read and re-read in ages to come as one of the most...

Page 6

THE POSITION OF THE GOVERNMENT. T HE Government are discovering a

The Spectator

fact which few men, and still fewer Governments, can be induced to believe, but which nevertheless is one of almost universal experience. In danger or difficulty a bold policy,...

Page 7

ECONOMIC WARFARE. T HE debate on Monday in the House of

The Spectator

Commons upon the desirability of taking definite measures to increase the economic pressure upon Germany during the war, and to meet the danger of an economic attack from her...

Page 8

OUR "DOWN GLASSES" POLICY.

The Spectator

ikv E suggest that those who agree with the policy of "Down Glasses during the War" should send us, -not for publication, but only for registration and reference, their names...

THE RUSSIAN FIGHTING MAN.

The Spectator

HE Russian soldier perhaps approaches more nearly than any other in the world to a combination of fatalism and energy. That combination is strictly impossible because each of...

Page 9

THE NEW HOPE.

The Spectator

T HE three cardinal Christian virtues are constantly changing their values. Faith is not just now accounted the greatest ; charity, which has for a long time taken easily the...

Page 10

THE BELOVED CAPTAIN.

The Spectator

E came in the early days, when we were still at recruit drill under the hot September sun. Tall, erect, smiling: so we first saw him, and so he remained to the last. At the...

Page 11

SHOULD THE CLERGY ENLIST?

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SFEcriTog."1 SIR,—With all that your correspondent sets forth in his admir- able article of last week the thinking part of the laity, and. let us hope,...

(TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTITOR."1

The Spectator

SLR, —If the brewers were allowed to de-aleoholize their beer down to the duty-free (one per cent.) standard, and no other beer allowed to be sold, there would be no need to...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

"DOWN GLASSES ! " (To THE BMWS OF THE " SPECTATOR.'1 supporting your policy of "Down Glasses," I beg to suggest as preliminary measures to securing the public opinion...

A MOBILIZATION OF THE CHURCH.

The Spectator

(TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTITOR.1 Strt,—The stirring article on the above subject by "A Student in Arms" in your last issue has a sterling ring about it which compels...

Page 12

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR,—In your issue

The Spectator

of January 8th "A Student in Arms" appears to recommend the enlistment of the younger clergy as a sure remedy for the existing severance between laymen and the clergy. For my...

ITO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.1

The Spectator

SIR,—I have sent my copy of the Spectator week by week to Australia, otherwise I should have sought to refresh my memory as to a previous article of A Student in Arms" with...

Page 13

TWO " SPECTATOR " ARTICLES.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR.'J Sm,—I should like to add my thanks to those of "II." for "The Religion of the Inarticulate" and "The Sacrament." In preaching to a large...

SOME GOOD RESULTS FROM WAR.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPEOTATOR."I SIR,—Would you permit the expression of a few thoughts occasioned by that interesting book, J'Accuse / by "A German" ? The author is of...

[TO THE EDITOR OPTHE "SPECTATOR."'

The Spectator

read under this heading an article in your paper of last Saturday which stated that the Bishops fear there might be a dearth of clergy after the war, and expressed the belief of...

"INARTICULATE RELIGION."

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."' Sin,—Your correspondent "M." may like to know that an odd sympathy with the sorrows and perplexities of war is felt by non-Christians in...

AMERICAN'S ARE ASHAMED ALREADY. [To THE EDITOR. OF THE "

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.'i SIR,—It gave me no pleasure to read in your issue of December 11th the letter from Mr. Edward Fuller, of Phila- delphia. As a native American, also of...

Page 14

COMPULSION VERSUS VOLUNTARY SERVICE. [To THE EDITOR OF THE "

The Spectator

SPECTATOR."' Sre,—In the debating of this subject there is a point which seems to me to be curiously overlooked. If you agree, perhaps you will make room for it in your...

IRELAND AND COMPULSORY MILITARY SERVICE.

The Spectator

ITO THE Torroa OF THE " SPECTATOR."' Sin,—Many people think it unjust that married men should be expected to join the Army while younger unmarried men have not joined. There is...

THE BRAVE HUMOUR OF WAR.

The Spectator

ITO THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR."' enclose a little article by Miss Agnes Repplier from one of the publications of the University of Pennsylvania—not because it is amusing and...

Page 15

[To THE Eorros OF THE "SPECTATOR?'] SIR,—Your correspondent Mr. C.

The Spectator

D. Leng asks where women workers are to be found. Let him apply to the office of tha Women's Farm and Garden Union, 45 Queen Anne's Chambers, Westminster. At present, owing to...

THE WA/TER MILITANT.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR:] Sra,—How is it that all thgse men waiters are here carrying tea round, lighting ladies' cigarettes—and our sons at the front ? Surely women...

SOME REAL WAR-BABIES.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE SPECTATOR:] Sru,—Early in the war much nonsense was talked about "war- babies." We were told that legions were coming, and that we must provide food and...

EMPIRE LAND SETTLEMENT.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR:1 Sin,—It may be of interest to the readers of the Spectator to know that Sir Rider Haggard has consented to visit Australasia as the honorary...

WOMEN WORKERS ON THE LAND.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR:1 SIR,—Judging from the contents of my postbag, a great many people are asking Mr. Leng's question : "Where can they be obtained ? " I receive...

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR:1

The Spectator

Sra,—I am a farmer and gardener by profession, so believe me this is not imagination, though possibly of no use to others.—I "DEAR BLANIC,—S0 you would help on the land, and...

OPULENCE VERSUS DEFENCE.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR:1 Sm,—Referring to your article in the last issue, as I understand them, Messrs. McKenna and Runciman argue that more workers cannot be spared...

Page 16

THE ARMY RESERVE.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR:1 SIR,—The poster calling up the second batch of groups is now published, and will be sent, together with leaflets dealing with the scheme, to...

" GERMANIA CONTRA MUNDUM " AND THE BLIND. [To THE

The Spectator

EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR:1 SIR, —It may perhaps interest you to know that some blind readers are sharing in the advantage of reading the interesting articles, "Germania contra...

THE CENTRAL ASSOCLANION OF VOLUNTEER TRAINING CORPS.

The Spectator

PEESIDENT: LORD DESBOROUGH. HON. SECRETARY : PERCY A. HARRIS, Esq. HEAD OFFICES : Judges' Quadrangle, Royal Courts of Justice (Carey Street entrance). The aims and objects of...

DR. PAGE-ROBERTS.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.'] SIR,--With your approval, I beg permission to say with what lively satisfaction I have read " X.'s " letter in your paper of the 8th inst....

. CANNING AND DISRAELI IN POLITICAL NOVELS.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " 5PECTATOR:1 SIH,—I am obliged by your insertion of my amateurish letter re .Disraeli. That "Beduin Sands" was intended for Monckton Milnes never...

Page 17

POETRY.

The Spectator

FAREWELL TO ANZAC. On! hump your swag and leave lads, the ships are in the bay, We've got our marching orders now, it's time to come away, And a long good-bye to Anzac beach,...

BOOKS.

The Spectator

DELANE OF THE "TIMES." * No survivor of the mid-Victorian period will be disposed to challenge the accuracy of Sir Edward Cook when he says : "The Tithes of Delane was a...

NOTICE.—When "Correspondence" or Articles are signed with the writer's name

The Spectator

or initials, or with a pseudonym, or are marked "Communicated," the Editor must not necessarily be held to be in agreement with the views therein expressed or with the mode of...

Page 18

WHAT GERMANY THINKS.*

The Spectator

IN his earlier book, The Soul of Germany, Dr. T. F. A. Smith, who was formerly English Lecturer in the University of Erlangen, virtually drew an indictment against the whole...

Page 19

ThE TRAGEDY OF POLAND.*

The Spectator

Ix the unhappy rivalry of martyrdom between various countries, Belgium, Serbia, Armenia, and Poland, brought about by the present war, Poland in many ways may claim a sad...

Page 20

SOME WAR BOOKS.*

The Spectator

Mn. L. COPE CORNFORD has long been an affectiOnate observer of the Navy, and in this small book 1 he writes of the Grand Fleet with his usual knowledge and happy use of words....

Page 21

THE RAEMAEKERS CARTOONS.* WE are delighted to see that Messrs.

The Spectator

Hodder and Stoughton have published the Raemaekers cartoons in book form at the price of twopence. Considering how low is the price, the work of reproduction must be pronounced...

Page 22

FICTION.

The Spectator

BROKEN STOWAGE.* MIL DAVID Boxe made good his claim in The Brassbounder to honourable mention amongst those who have not only gone down to the sea in ships, but can turn their...

SOUTH INDIAN BRONZES.*

The Spectator

Ma. GA1TGOLI is a little impressed by his own daring, being a native of Bengal, in writing of the numerous bronze figures of gods and benefactors with which the magnificent...

Page 23

• READABLE NOVELS.--Mia Billy—Married. By Eleanor H. Porter. (Stanley Paul

The Spectator

and Co. 6s.)—This pretty story is one of a series concerning the charming Miss Billy. It has con- siderable humour of a quiet kind.—The Lavender Hedge. By Florence Bone....

The Crimes of England. By G. K. Chesterton. (Palmer and

The Spectator

Hayward. 2s. 6d. net, or is. net.)—Mr. Chesterton fills in journalism and between the covers of this book the role of putting facts in an unexpected light and disturbing us with...

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

Welke in this column does not necessarily nrecluie subsequent ream.] The Dramas and Dramatic Dances of Non-European Races. By W. Ridgeway, F.B.A. (Cambridge University Press....

Beltane the Smith. By Jeffery Farnol. (Sampson Low, Marston, and

The Spectator

Co. 6s.)—We are inclined to think that pure romance is the only variety of fiction at all in tune with the present state of affairs. A " modern " novel, if it ignores the war,...

The Cambridge University Calendar for the Year 1915-1916. tUniversity Press.

The Spectator

7s. 6d, net.)—This appears late owing to shortage of staff at the University Press. Its form is as usual, and might seem to belie the fact modestly mentioned that ten thousand...

Page 24

The Magistrates' Practice, 1910. (Stevens and Sons, and Sweet and

The Spectator

Maxwell. 20s. net.)—The majority of Justices can hardly be expected to study nearly seventeen hundred pages (and very transparent ones) of instruction in the laws that they...