29 NOVEMBER 1913

Page 1

We must now very briefly summarize the points of Mr.

The Spectator

Asquith's speech. He dealt first with the reproaches of the Little-Navyites, and while admitting that he shared their disquietude, and promising to neglect no opportunity of...

On Wednesday Lord Hardinge, the Viceroy of India, made what

The Spectator

we feel bound to call a very injudicious speech in regard to the problem of the Indians in Natal. Replying to an address from the Indian Mercantile Association, he regretted...

Nevertheless it was, from the point of view both of

The Spectator

Ireland and Great Britain, of high importance that the new system in Ireland should not start upon the basis of civil strife. It was equally important that the decision come to...

For ourselves, we suspect that Mr. Asquith is still simply

The Spectator

playing for a better position. We cannot help saying, however, that the lateness of the hour makes such play extraordinarily dangerous. It would be excusable in a leader of the...

Next Lord Hardinge actually proceeded to a direct censure of

The Spectator

the Government of the Union :- "But the most recent developments have taken a serious turn. We have seen the widest publicity given to allegations that passive resistance has...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

T HE most important political event of the week in home politics has been Mr. Asquith's speech on Thursday at Leeds. A strict verbal analysis of the speech shows that there is...

* * a The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript in any

The Spectator

case.

Page 2

Last Saturday at Oxford Mr. Lloyd George received three deputations

The Spectator

on woman suffrage. First came the Men's Political Union, who sympathize with militancy, led by Mr. Nevinson. They hotly abused the Government for breaking their pledges. Mr....

Mr. Boner Law went on to point out that since

The Spectator

Mr. Churchill had said that Ulster should be treated with con- sideration Mr. Runciman had poured contempt on the whole idea of exclusion, but Mr. Bonar Law refused to believe...

Mr. Lloyd George was the guest of the Oxford Union

The Spectator

on Friday week, when lie spoke of his land policy before a crowded house and in the customary atmosphere of chaff or solemn badinage. The account in the Manchester Guardian says...

At Birmingham on Friday week, Mr. Bonar Law said that

The Spectator

the people were at last beginning to recognize how terrible would be the consequences if the Government carried the Home Rule Bill in its present form. It was in vain at the...

Thursday's papers publish a remarkable statement issued by the business

The Spectator

men of the three southern provinces of Ireland. It is a reasoned protest against the Home Rule Bill, on the ground of the disastrous results which would inevitably follow from...

We must point out the extreme danger of Lord Hardinge's

The Spectator

action. It is only too likely to lead to recriminations on the part of the Ministers of the Union—Colonial opinion is almost sure to force them to such recrimination in order to...

Last Saturday at the South African Nationalist Party Congress the

The Spectator

long controversy between General Botha, who represents a moderate Imperialism, and General Hertzog, who stands for the narrow Dutch tradition of Kruger and Steyn, ended in a...

The Anti-Slavery and Aborigines Protection Society have called the attention

The Spectator

of the Foreign Office to the evils of the peonage system in the Amazon valley. Their charges are largely based on the evidence of Mr. J. F. Woodroffe, who has been engaged in...

Page 3

The Board of Trade Report on the Aisgill railway disaster

The Spectator

was issued on Tuesday night. Major Pringle makes several recommendations. He begins by observing that some form of automatic train-stop is necessary, and, pending the acceptance...

Mr. T. W. Russell addressed a meeting of the Dublin

The Spectator

and Counties Liberal Association on Monday night on the Ex- clusion question. He dismissed the exclusion of the whole of Ulster as incompatible with the continuance of peace,...

During the week an agitation has been begun for the

The Spectator

total abolition of the laws against blasphemy, the immediate cause being the sentence of four months' imprisonment recently passed upon Thomas William Stewart at the...

Mr. Larkin's manifesto, addressed to the workers of Great Britain,

The Spectator

has led to damaging retorts from English trade union leaders. In particular Mr. Havelock Wilson, the President of the National Seamen and Firemen's Union, has issued a vigorous...

Mr. Walter Long was the principal speaker at the annual

The Spectator

dinner of the Melksham Agricultural Society on Tuesday. In regard to land reform he deprecated an attitude of mere negation. Those who lived by the land courted the fullest...

The reasonable provision against unnecessary outrages on the deepest feelings

The Spectator

of religious people should, in fact, be made a general law applicable to all forms and all sects of religion or no religion. We would not allow a clergyman to abuse agnostics or...

Turning to the housing problem, he maintained that it was

The Spectator

the duty of every owner of land to find enough cottages for the cultivation of the land, and to see that they were in a thoroughly sanitary and satisfactory condition. The State...

The Spectator

Page 4

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

THE FEDERALIST NINE-DOSE CURE. NI R. OLIVER is a very able and very sincere man, but we cannot say that we like his Federalist nine-dose cure set forth in the pamphlet, The...

Page 5

THE TERRITORIALS AND NATIONAL SERVICE.

The Spectator

I T is always difficult to judge from newspaper reports as to the real effect of a Minister's speech to a deputation. There are so many compliments, and the superincumbent...

Page 6

THE SAD POSITION OF THE LITTLE- NAVYITE S. F ROM the

The Spectator

Westminster Palace Hotel, where last week the demand for retrenchment was indignantly formu- lated by Lord Welby, Sir Sydney Olivier, and others (though what Sir Sydney Olivier,...

Page 7

THE TRUE JACOBIN.

The Spectator

B Y far the most significant of recent political utterances is Mr. Lloyd George's frank admission that if the Insurance Bill had been submitted to a Poll of the People it would...

Page 8

STERNE.

The Spectator

N EVER were humour and sentimentality combined in such a curious manner as in Laurence Sterne, the bicentenary of whose birth was celebrated on Monday. It is inaccurate,...

Page 9

COLONEL HARWOOD'S ADVICE.

The Spectator

F OR some reason which is not very apparent people are surprised to come upon an old statement of political or military difficulties which perplexed their ancestors and to...

Page 11

BOOKS FOR "BOWER BIRDS."

The Spectator

G REAT interest seems to be felt just now in the art of housekeeping, in all its infinite mass of detail. By housekeeping we do not, of course, mean the daily ordering of...

Page 12

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR."]

The Spectator

Sin,—While being an admirer of your sane publication I have received rather a shock to such a sentiment by reading the article on "What Civil War Means for the Army," in the...

[To TUB EDITOR OP THE •' SPECTATOR. " ] SIR,—AS a bystander

The Spectator

taking much interest in current events, may I suggest that you seem to make too much of the necessity of civil war if the Home Rule Bill is finally passed. In common with many...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

WHAT CIVIL WAR MEANS FOR THE ARMY. [To THE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR, —I have read your article under the above heading with an interest which was considerable but at...

THE PROBLEM OF EXCLUSION.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE "SPECTATOR."] SIR,—There is one contingency with which you have not dealt in considering possible issues of the present situation of the Irish question....

Page 13

MR. BIRRELL IN IRELAND.

The Spectator

ETD THE EDITOR or VIZ "SPECTATOR."J Birrell's ignominious in-and-out policy with regard to Mr. Larkin, on which you comment with just severity, is by no means an isolated...

THE POSITION OF MR. REDMOND AND THE REVOLUTIONARIES.

The Spectator

[To TEE EDITOR Or THE "SrzeTsToe. •• ] Sin,—In the controversy at present raging over the Home Rule Bill, some allowance should be made for the domestic difficulties Mr. Redmond...

Page 14

MR. REDMOND AND THE ROMAN CHURCH.

The Spectator

[To TRH EDITOR OP TER " SPECTATOR.":1_ SIR, — Mr. Redmond's speech, as reported in to-day's papers, may possibly afford comfort to those who are persuaded that " Home Rule means...

PROVINCIAL GO VERNMENT FOR IRELAND.

The Spectator

[TO TER EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR. ") SIR, — Why not give Ireland provincial government P Not only Ireland, but every shire or province in the United King. dom. The present...

RELIGIOUS INTOLERANCE IN DUBLIN. [To THE EDITOR Or TER SPECTATOR."1

The Spectator

SIR, — I enclose cutting from the Guardian of November 14th, which is very enlightening as to the fate of Protestants in Ulster should Home Rule ever become law.—I am, Sir,...

" TOLERATION," 1912-13.

The Spectator

[To TER EDITOR OF TER "SPECTATOR.") SIR, — The enclosed is, except for the alteration of names, a literal transcript of a conversation I held a few weeks ago with a farmer near...

Page 15

COUNTY COTTAGE EXHIBITION GROUNDS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.") Sin,—It will doubtless be a matter of interest to many readers of the Spectator to know that, as an outcome of Mr. St. Loe Strachey's...

Page 16

COTTAGES THAT PAY.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR Or THE "SPECTATOR. "] Sin,—On a previous occasion you allowed me to appeal through your columns for capital to build cottages on an economic basis. Partly as a...

PISb c , BUILDING.

The Spectator

[TO TEM EDITOR Or TER " SPECTATOR. "] SIR,—I should like to draw the attention of your readers to the following extract from Cottage Building :— "PISt-DE-TERRE METHOD OF...

[To THE EDITOR 07 THE "SPECTATOR.') SIR,—I read the letter

The Spectator

of your correspondent " Z " in your issue of the 22nd instant with great interest, and especially the information there imparted of building of Pied houses in the Colonies. The...

Page 17

THE INDIANS IN SOUTH AFRICA.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR "] SIR,—In your leading article on this subject in the issue of November 22nd you emphasize the fact "that although the right of self-government...

" MESS OF POTTAGE."

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR:1 SIR, —The Spectator so often opens its leaves for the solu- tion of difficulties that I now appeal to it. Whence is the term "mess of...

THE TERRITORIALS AND " THE BETTER VULGAR."

The Spectator

(To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR " ] SIR,—The writing of this letter has been long delayed, for the circumstances which prompted the idea of addressing you occurred in July...

PORTUGUESE SLAVERY.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR1 Sin,—The following extract from a letter from Portuguese East Africa may interest you :- "Thanks for the Spectator r slavery' articles—they...

Page 18

MRS. FOX AND GEORGE IV.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR 07 THE "SPECTATOR " ] STE, — If you can give this letter a place in the columns of the Spectator I should esteem it a favour. Possibly it may interest a few of...

"AS I REM - FIMBER THEM."

The Spectator

[To THY EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR:1 SIR,—A very interesting book of random Western biographies has reached me from Salt Lake City. The writer, Judge C. C. Goodwin, must be...

THE LATE SIR ROBERT BALL.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR 07 THE "SPECTATOR. "] Srs,—Sir Robert Ball, the eminent astronomer, who died at Cambridge on the 25th inst., was, like the late Professor Tyndall, a most...

" CATHOLIC."

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR 07 THE " SPECTATOR."1 Sin,—In the most solemn service of our Church we are asked to pray for "the whole state of Christ's Church militant here on earth," and...

Page 19

LINKS WITH THE PAST.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR. "] Sra,—My grandfather, who was born in 1734, as a boy of twelve stood at the roadside and watched the King's troops marching northwards...

THE PRESIDENT OF MAGDALENE COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SrEcraroa."] SIR,—A reviewer who sets out to correct what he calls "careless" mistakes may just as well verify his own state- ments. The writer who...

MUSIC•

The Spectator

MUSIC AS A REMUNERATIVE PROFESSION. ONE of Martial's most interesting poems takes the form of an ironical letter to a friend (v. 56) who was always consulting him about his...

PLAGIARISM OR COINCIDENCE ?

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR."] Sin,—In reply to Mr. De S. Fowke I beg to say that the whole of the beautiful ballad entitled, " It was a' for our rightfu' King" [sent by...

POETRY.

The Spectator

CONSTABLE'S COUNTRY. DEAR John, most friendly poet of the field, I have been walking at your heels to-day; There was no tree that had not seen you pass, No field but knew your...

NOTICE.—When "Correspondence" or Articles are signed with the writer's name

The Spectator

or initials, or with a pseudonym, or are marked "Communicated," the Editor must not necessarily be held to be in agreement with the views therein expressed or with the mode of...

Page 20

BOOKS.

The Spectator

APOLLONIUS RHODIUS.* APOLLONIUS RHODIUS is a poet who, it would seem, has of late aroused new interest in this country. For almost a century and a half Shaw's edition, although...

Page 21

SOUTH AFRICA.*

The Spectator

POLITICIANS, when they have to deal with the affairs of a foreign country, frequently shed some portion of the opinions which they have formed at home, and adapt their political...

Page 22

MR. GEORGE TREVELYAN'S ESSAYS" Ma. GEORGE TREVELYAN'S essays delight us

The Spectator

with something of the same charm as his history ; they are the expression of no barren patchwork soul, but of one stalwartly equipped with an individuality, a teuWer, a few...

Page 23

MODERN ATHLETICS.* Now that, fortunately or unfortunately, international games are

The Spectator

an established fact, we are sure to have many works on the science of training, and special treatises on the various branches of athletics. We have before us two books which are...

Page 24

HYDE DE NEITVILT51• IT is many years since the nieces

The Spectator

of Baron Hyde de Neuville undertook and carried through the important task of arrang- ing and editing the various manuscripts left in their care. These included, besides the...

Page 25

JAMES S. WADSWORTH OF GENESE0.*

The Spectator

EXCELLENT as is the work of the Comte de Paris, the history of the great civil war has yet to be written. Our regret at this delay is tempered by the fact that the longer the...

AS OTHERS SEE US.*

The Spectator

IT is only to be expected that the work of a man who has devoted the best years of his life to party journalism should • Pillars of Society. By A. G. Gardiner. London: Nisbet...

Page 26

THE EVERYMAN LIBRARY.* Axone the twenty-four new volumes of the

The Spectator

Everyman series comes a moat valiant collection of the works of English essayists, ranging from Caxton to the writers of to-day. Although the maker of this anthology shows his...

FICTION.

The Spectator

THE GENTLE LOVER* THE reviewer of modern novels has no lack of epithets and phrases which he can conscientiously apply to the work of their writers. They are " strong " and "...

Page 27

The Children of the Sea : a Romance. By H.

The Spectator

de Vere Stacpoole. (Hutchinson and Co. 6s.)—Mr. de Vere Stacpoole's new book is of the school of Kipling ; indeed, much of it, especially the first part, with its absorbing...

Prodigals and Sons. By John Ayscough. (Chatto and Windus. 6s.)—There

The Spectator

is one supremely good story among the twenty-seven which compose this book, and that is the account, which is called " Changed," of the result of an old farmer persuading a...

Edward Bacedale's Will. By Mark Hardy. (Mills and Boon. 6s.)—It

The Spectator

is a great pity that Mr. Hardy should have chosen to turn his energies and powers to the writing of a story so extravagant and fantastical as Edward Racedale's Will, where the...

Page 28

Lip-Reading : Principles and Practice. By Edward B. Nitchie. (Methuen

The Spectator

and Co. Sc. net.)—Although lip-reading is not a subject that can be studied satisfactorily from a book, it is to be hoped that Mr. Nitchie's careful study will prove a most...

READABLE NOVELS.—" Disarm ! Disarm ! "—By Andrea Hofer Proudfoot.

The Spectator

(Hodder and Stoughton. 6s.)—An anti- war romance of the last century, translated from the German of Baroness von Suttner ; it is written in the form of an autobiography.—Dirk :...

is deserved by the admirable little anthology of letters which

The Spectator

has just been added to " The World's Classics." Its range extends from Sir Thomas More at the end of the fifteenth century to the Brownings in the middle of the nineteenth. Our...

The Romance of Tristan and Iseult. Drawn from the best

The Spectator

French Sources and Re-told by J. Bedier. Rendered into English by H. Belloc. (George Allen. 2s. 6d. net.)—Mr. Belloc's rather affected style will hardly satisfy those who have...

Boows OF REFEILEACE.—The ' Daily Mail' Year Book for 1914

The Spectator

is as good as ever, and that is saying a great deal. It is, of course, quite small as books of reference go nowadays, but the information is all useful, up-to-date, and very...

SOI'LLE BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

U , ,.er this heading we notice such Books of the teak as have not been reserved for racism in other forms.] The Reporters' Gallery. By Michael Macdonagh. (Hodder and Stoughton....

Page 29

NEW EDITIONS.—Edinburgh Revisited. By James Bone. (Sidgwick and Jackson. 5s.

The Spectator

net.)—We are delighted to see this cheaper edition of Mr. Bone's charmingly written account of Edinburgh, together with Mr. nonslip Fletcher's attractive drawings.—Flint and...