26 MAY 1928, Page 26

THE FOUR TRAGEDIES OF MEMWORTH : A Detec; tive Story.

By Lord Ernest Hamilton. (Gollancz. 7s. 6d.)— Here is a succession of really exciting incidents and an un- expected conclusion which leaves the reader guessing. The Prologue reveals why Dale Chantry's early perfidy in China Compels him to receive every thirteenth of January a red- written message of vengeance. In the story proper, young Jack Cunningham, engaged as secretary to that aged phila- telist, Lord Penfield, is shocked first by the murder of the heir, the said Dale Chantry, then by the suicide of the next-of- kin, Oliver Chantry, exasperated by public suspicion. Lord Penfield dies, and is succeeded by Hugh, an unknown Canadian relative, who, as Cunningham recognizes, has masqueraded in Memworth as a- footman called William. Though Cunning- ham's life is twice endangered, possibly by Hugh, he develops a considerable affection for him. But the Canadian Earl, as a final tragedy, is found shot dead in his own park, presumably by a blackmailer. His character is left enigmatic ; and if Dale was killed by him,-or Oliver, or-a mysterious Chinaman, you may decide according to your divination. Mr. Bewleigh is a promising figure who seems to disappear too early. The story holds the attention ; and the love-business is quite engaging.