21 NOVEMBER 1891

Page 3

BOOKS.

The Spectator

M. SCHERER ON ENGLISH LITERATURE.* ENGLISH readers owe Mr. Saintsbury thanks for the few richly laden sheaves he has gained from M. Scherer's extensive field of criticism. It...

Littrarp Ouppkmtnt.

The Spectator

LONDON : NOVEMBER 21, 1891.

Page 4

BIMINI REVISITED.* ME. EUGENE LEE-HAMILTON has done on a small

The Spectator

scale poetic work which is signally marked by largeness and dignity of style. One does not expect to see him fail when he chooses to contend in some ;Aro; Speithoc of literature...

Page 5

MYSTIC AND PAGAN ITALY.*

The Spectator

SIGNOR BARZELLOTTI, Professor of Ethics at the University of Naples, known for his careful, subtle writings on mystic and moral problems, incited by the perusal of Link...

Page 6

STRANDS OF HISTORY.* THESE are days of microscopic study, consequently

The Spectator

we may lose sight of the broader view of a subject ; but we certainly gain much in interest, and acquire a deeper insight into the first cause of many problems, both past and...

Page 8

A NEW FAIRY-TALE.*

The Spectator

Da. ATKINSON has taken an ingeniously novel departure in a kind of literature wherein novelty has long been held to be well-nigh impossible. Fairy-tales are written every year,...

THE SQUIRREL INN.* This is a happily characteristic specimen of

The Spectator

Mr. Frank Stockton's humorous writing. He has not written anything so genuinely entertaining since the inimitable Rudder Grange. There is nothing constrained about the fun ; if...

Page 9

The Cup of Loving Service. By Eliza Dean Taylor. (S.

The Spectator

Bagster and Sons.)—This is a well-intended little story, and told in good language. But why is it so doleful ? Of what material are children's hearts supposed to be, that they...

The Little Princes in the Tower. " England's Royal Series."

The Spectator

By C. Lysah. Illustrated by M. Smargiassi Santantico. (Trischler and Co.)—The artist who illustrates this book takes special pains to attain historical exactness. This doubtless...

CURRENT LITERATURE.

The Spectator

GIFT-BOOKS. Atalanta. Edited by L. T. Meade. (Trischler and Co.)—The last volume of this magazine is not inferior in point of literary or of artistic merit to any of its...

THE PICTURESQUE MEDITERRANEAN.* THIS second volume of The Picturesque Mediterranean

The Spectator

is a worthy successor of that which we noticed about this time last year. Its contents are not, indeed, so varied. Of its fourteen chapters, ten are given to Italy, if under...

Wild Meg and Wee Dickie. By Mary E. Ropes. (Blackie

The Spectator

and Son.)—It must be allowed that the characters and incidents in this story are somewhat idealised. The moral changes effected in the very unpromising dramatis persons are...

Barerock ; or, the Island of Pearls. By Henry Nash.

The Spectator

(E. Arnold.)—This is a story of the " Robinson Crusoe" kind. Two boys are shipwrecked, and thrown on a rocky islet somewhere in the South Atlantic. Here they make themselves...

Page 10

Lyra Heroica. A Book of Verse for Boys. Selected and

The Spectator

arranged by William Ernest Henley. (D. Nutt.)—No higher aim could well be than that which Mr. Henley has put before himself. His own words will best express it :—" To set forth,...

Stories from Fairyland. Translated from the Greek of Aristotle Kourtidos

The Spectator

by Mrs. Edmonds. (T. Fisher Unwin.)—This is the third volume of a series called " The Children's Library." It is explained to us that fairies proper have no existence in Greek,...

A King of Tyre. By James M. Ludlow. (Osgood, McIlvaine,

The Spectator

and Co.)—This "tale of the time of Ezra and Nehemiah " is chiefly concerned with the fortunes of a liberal-minded Prince who suc- ceeds to the throne of Tyre, and bends his...

Wild Bryonie. By Jennie Chappell. (S. W. Partridge.)—The moral of

The Spectator

this story might perhaps be expressed by the text, " Rejoice evermore." Annette Erroll is a person whose religion has the gloomiest of aspects. That everything pleasant is...

For King and Country. By Jane A. Nutt. (Sonnenschein and

The Spectator

Co.)—This is a graphic and sympathetic narrative of the patriotic war in La Vend4e. It takes the form of an autobiography, in the art of writing which the writer has shown...

Over the Hills Away ! Poems by Frederic E. Weatherley.

The Spectator

Illustrations by Harriet M. Bennett. (Hildesheimer and Faulkner.) —That the pictures are pleasing, there can be no doubt. There is a certain quaint mannerism about them; the...

Held Fast for England : a Tale of the Siege

The Spectator

of Gibraltar. By G. A. Henty. (Blackie and Son.)—The memorable Siege of Gibraltar was a capital motive for a story of adventure, and one wonders, indeed, why it comes so late in...

Page 11

Geoff and Jim. By Ismay Thorn. (Wells Gardner, Darton, and

The Spectator

Co.)—It is not easy to see why lady-writers of fiction have such a taste for stories of schoolboy-life. This life is really a very little-known region, and those who might be...

Elizabeth. By Henry J. Arden. (W. and R. Chambers.)—The heroine

The Spectator

is sent away from her home by a jealous mother, who is afraid lest she should win the heart of the son and heir of the house. This, however, has already been done, and things...

Ernest's Golden Thread. By Edith C. Kenyon. (W. and R.

The Spectator

Chambers.)—This is a story, touching, but not too harrowing, of a little lad who persistently holds on to the right under very adverse circumstances. The " golden thread " is an...

Nurse Heatherdale's Story. By Mrs. Molesworth. (Macmillan.) —This is a

The Spectator

simple little story, written in Mrs. Molesworth's best style. Sometimes, indeed, her pen carries her a little too far. The old nurse who is supposed to tell the tale could...

The Biography of a Locomotive. By Henry Frith. Illustrated. (Cassell

The Spectator

and Co.)—This is a story of adventure that every boy who has ever looked at an engine-driver and wondered what sort of a life he leads will be charmed with. It gives the reader...

The Quest of Jack Hazlewood. Illustrated. By Marion Andrews. (Gardner

The Spectator

and Co.)—We have not much to say regarding this tale ; it is best described by negatives. It is not exciting, it is not improbable, it is not so very stupid, and it has not a...

The Dash to Khartoum. By G. A. Henty. (Blackie and

The Spectator

Son.)— Mr. Henty begins this story with the well-worn complication of children changed at nurse. But he has given a certain novelty to it by arranging that the foster-mother—she...

The Great Show of Kobol - Land. By Frank R. Stockton. (Osgood,

The Spectator

Mcllvaine, and Co.)--This is a quaint, fanciful tale, which will certainly amuse, but not amuse in the overpowering fashion which we are accustomed to expect from Mr. Stockton....

Joan and Jerry. By Mrs. O'Reilly. (W. and R. Chambers.)—

The Spectator

Mrs. O'Reilly always tells her stories well. A fine taste keeps her from exaggeration in the drawing of character, and she can interest her readers without startling incidents...

The Lonely Pyramid. By J. H. Yoxall. Illustrated. (Blackie and

The Spectator

Son.)—This is a lively story of adventure in a lost oasis and pyramid, with El Mandi thrown in. The style is somewhat grandiloquent and exalted, and hardly accords with the...

The Children of Wilton Chase. By L. T. Meade. (W.

The Spectator

and R. Chambers.)—The heroine of Mrs. Meade's story is a naughty, we trust an exceptionally naughty, girl. She rebels against a gently inflicted punishment, tries to escape the...

Page 12

Bab. By Ismay Thorn. (Blackie and Son.)—Gladys and Bab represent

The Spectator

the old contrast which we find in " The Idle and the Industrious Apprentice," and in other tales without number. In this case it is a question of selfishness and unselfishness....

POETRY.—Lyrics. Selected from the Works of A. Mary F. Robinson

The Spectator

(Madame James Darmesteter). (T. Fisher Unwin.)— This little volume contains some seventy old pieces, and five new ones, these latter being certainly as good as their companions....

The Bewitched Lamp. By Mrs. Molesworth. (W. and R. Chambers.)—The

The Spectator

" bewitched lamp" is an heirloom which, according to a tradition, always makes its way back, however it may have been removed, to the house to which it belongs. It has done so...

Silas Verney. By Edgar Pickering. (Blackie and Son.)—This is a

The Spectator

tale of the days of King Charles II. The hero is the grand- son of an old Parliamentarian officer, and expects to be his heir,— as, indeed, he is by natural right. But a...

We have received new editions of the following :—The .Rover's

The Spectator

Secret. By Harry Collingwood. (Blackie and Son.)—Jack O'Lanthorn. By C. R. Coleridge. (A. D. Innes and Co.)—The Days of Queen Mary (Religious Tract Society), a book "containing...

P's and Q's ; and Little Lucy's Wonderful Globe. By

The Spectator

Charlotte M. Yonge. (Macmillan.)—The first half of this volume is occupied by a story of a slight kind, though told with Miss Yonge's accus- tomed charm Paullina Quintall thinks...

Friends of the Olden Time. By Alice Gardner. (E. Arnold.)—

The Spectator

Miss Gardner devotes her first chapter to " The Old Egyptians," of whose daily life, government, literature, &c., she gives a popular account. The rest of her volume gives...

Page 13

ScnooL-Booas.—No teacher, certainly, can complain of any want of variety

The Spectator

in the French reading-books from which he may make his choice ; nor, indeed, in the amplitude of the help with which editors commonly supplement the text of their originals....

Page 14

A Man's Conscience. By Avery Macalpine. 2 vols. (Sampson Low,

The Spectator

Marston, and Co.)—The lion. Godfrey Alleyne goes out to farm in a Western State, and there falls in with the very pretty daughter of a settler. His mother, hearing of his...

In Mathematical text-books, we have received :—Analytical Statics. By Edward

The Spectator

John Routh. Part I. (Cambridge University Press.)—The Theory of Determinants. Part I., " Determinants in General, Leibnitz (1693) to Cayley (1841)." By Thomas Muir, M.A....

Page 16

Lonnorr: Printed by Joan CllIwIELx. of No. 1 Wellington Street,

The Spectator

in the Precdnet of the Savoy. Strand, in the County of Middlesex. at 18 Exeter Street, Strand ; and Published by him at the "Elyacratost" OM" No. 1 Wellington Street, Strand,...

Page 17

The present French Government is evidently most anxious not to

The Spectator

quarrel with the extreme Liberals. It is treating the Labour demands with a deference which shows that, while it cannot yield to them, it is afraid to resist them strongly. In...

We regret to record the severe illness of Prince George

The Spectator

of Wales, who lies at Marlborthigh House sick of typhoid-fever. As yet the symptoms are favourable, but another week of danger has to be passed. The attack is severe, and the...

Mr. Chamberlain delivered a remarkable speech to his West Birmingham

The Spectator

constituents on Wednesday, which the Pall Mall Gazette treats chiefly as a " retractation " of the dictum that property should pay a " ransom " to save it from confiscation....

The South Molton election has yielded a great triumph to

The Spectator

the Gladstonians. Mr. Lambert is returned by 4,222 votes against 3,010 for Mr. Buller,—majority, 1,212. The Con- stituency has wheeled Completely round, and reversed the...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

frIHE Times of Wednesday published an immense letter from -I- its Paris correspondent, who, whether well informed or not, often acts as a speaking-trumpet for very imPortant...

NOTICE.—With this week's " SPECTATOR " is issued, gratis, a

The Spectator

LITERARY SUPPLEMENT.

FOR THE

The Spectator

• No. 3,308.] WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 21, 1891. [ a z i l=r•faucps,„,, ord.

4 . 4 The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript, in any

The Spectator

case.

Rumours are still current of financial troubles coming on the

The Spectator

Continent, but they take no definite form. It is clear, however, that in Vienna, Berlin, and Paris, there is acute apprehension, the idea being that powerful Banks are over-...

Page 18

Mr. Dillon and Mr. O'Brien, who spoke at Drogheda last

The Spectator

Saturday, are very anxious for a policy of conciliation towards the Parnellites, but they are not themselves very happy in their effort to set the example of conciliation. For...

Mr. Chamberlain related a story of an Irishman who was

The Spectator

found standing before a mirror with his eyes shut, and when asked what he was doing, said that he wanted to know how he looked when he was asleep. He thought that that was the...

Lord Hartington made a striking speech at Crieff on Thursday,

The Spectator

which was directed partly to the same end as Mr. Chamberlain's, but still more to warn the Gladstonians and Sir William Harcourt that the uniform victory of Liberalism over...

We have called attention elsewhere to the series of letters.

The Spectator

in the Times in which Mr. Arnold-Forster, who helped greatly by his letters to improve the efficiency of the Navy, is assailing the constitution of the Army. To our minds, the...

But this was a mere parenthesis in his speech, the

The Spectator

greater part of which was a most powerful demonstration that Mr. Glad- stone had taught the country to rely on the word of an Irish leader who is now by his own admirers...

Mr. Arthur Arnold (formerly M.P. for Salford, and now a

The Spectator

Gladstonian candidate who hopes to be re-elected at the General Election) writes to Wednesday's Times to protest indignantly against making the " details " of Mr. Gladstone's•...

The real practical pinch for the Anti-Parnellites is not any

The Spectator

difficulty in securing Irish support for their deter- mination not hastily to offend Mr. Gladstone, but lies else- where : first, in getting a leader powerful enough to replace...

Page 19

The news from Brazil is still not quite clear, the

The Spectator

reports of secession from Park, Bahia, and San Paolo being neither con- firmed nor denied. On Wednesday, however, a telegram was received from Monte Video which reads as if it...

New Consols (24) were on Friday 951. Bank Rate, 4

The Spectator

per cent.

Mr. Edison has just announced at Pittsburg that his plan

The Spectator

for superseding steam by electricity on railways is now perfect, and that he hopes to try it when the Chicago Exhibition is open on a great scale. He thinks Mr. H. Villard, of...

It is said, though we hear so little of it,

The Spectator

that a powerful party in Prussia is still attached to Prince Bismarck, and that should anything go wrong, they would struggle for his return to office. There is a lingering...

The Socialists are still gaining ground in Berlin. The -great

The Spectator

rise in the price of provisions caused by the Pro- tectionist policy, and by the demand for food in Western Russia, has exasperated the discontent in the poorer -classes, who...

Mr. McKinley has made a speech in Boston which shows

The Spectator

him as the very poet of Protection. He declares, it appears, that his tariff has created trade, and trade with all its profits on one side. "There is not a line in that Bill...

Mr. Goschen's Rectorial speech to the University of Edin- burgh

The Spectator

on Thursday, was far the most brilliant of the many Rectorial addresses which the present writer can remember. Indeed, it was so full of matter, and of eloquent insight into the...

Page 20

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

THE SOUTH MOLTON ELECTION. T HE Gladstonians have every reason to congratulate themselves on their triumph in North Devonshire. The South Molton election has resulted in a...

Page 21

THE VIENNESE SCARE.

The Spectator

W E published last week an article on " The Influence of Authority in Pecuniary Affairs," the object of which was to point out that vast numbers of well-to-do persons make and...

Page 22

MR. CHAMBERLAIN AND LORD HARTINGTON ON THE GLADSTONIAN DILEMMA. B OTH

The Spectator

Mr. Chamberlain and Lord Hartington have concentrated public attention this week on the dilemma in which the Gladstonians are placed by their absolute dependence on the Irish...

Page 23

THE VVEAK PLACE IN LONDON SCHOOL BOARD ELECTIONS. B EFORE our

The Spectator

next issue appears, the triennial elections to the London School Board will have been com- pleted, and we doubt if there is a man in London who is honestly hopeful as to the...

Page 24

MR. ARNOLD-FORSTER ON THE ARMY.

The Spectator

M R. ARNOLD-FORSTER must concentrate himself a little, or be will find, too late, that he has missed a magnificent opportunity. There never was a better time for calling the...

FRENCH ROYALISTS AND RADICALS.

The Spectator

T HE French Royalists have lately seen two gleams of light cross their otherwise dark horizon. M. Lafargue has been returned for Lille,—that is consolation number one. M....

Page 25

CHILDREN'S POETRY.

The Spectator

IN the spirited and already very popular selection of poetry especially adapted for children which Mr. Andrew Lang has compiled under the title of " The Blue Poetry-Book," he...

Page 26

THE MAHOMMEDANS OF LIVERPOOL.

The Spectator

I T is very interesting to notice the precise point at which the theory of religious liberty ceases in England to work with full completeness. Most of us are accustomed to...

Page 27

SCIENCE AND CONJECTURE.

The Spectator

T HE scientific authorities of to-day have fallen into a rather provoking and tantalising habit of taking the public into their confidence, making known to it discoveries that...

Page 28

THE EAGLE IN ENGLAND.

The Spectator

T HE spotted eagle which was caught near Colchester after the late gales has been more fortunate than most of its tribe whose visits are recorded in English newspapers. It...

Page 30

PRINCIPAL SHAIRP ON MATTHEW ARNOLD.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR:1 Sin—Is there not some mysterious mistake in the passage which appeared as a quotation from Principal Shairp, in the published report of Lord...

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR. "] Sra,—Two passages in the

The Spectator

Spectator of November 14th on Dr. Martineau's last great work must come home to many religions but unlearned readers, as indicating the doubts and difficulties they have...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

MR. McKINLEY'S TRIUMPH. [To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR:1 Slit, — In reference to the subject of your article, the fol- lowing quotation from a paper by the Hon. H. Cabot...

DR. MARTINEAU'S "SEAT OF AUTHORITY IN RELIGION."

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."1 Sin,—In your review of the third edition of Dr. Martineau's "Seat of Authority in Religion," you make some very true and natural remarks on...

Page 31

ART.

The Spectator

THREE EXHIBITIONS. AT the Fine Art Society's Gallery are exhibited some seventy small pictures by Mr. W. Logsdail illustrating the scenery of the Riviera. Mr. Logsdail...

THE OLDEST CHURCH IN ENGLAND.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] Sin, In your able and kindly critique of my " History of St. Martin's, Canterbury," there is one point in which you scarcely do me justice....

DIVINE WORSHIP.

The Spectator

ITO THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR. "] SIR, — Allow me to supplement your correspondent's sug- gestions on divine worship by making two remarks,—one general, the other particular....

" AND THERE WAS LIGHT."

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR."] SIR,—In the Spectator of November 14th, Mr. Flavell speaks of a clergyman having recently " completely spoilt the beauty " of the above...

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR. "] Sin,—Your correspondent of November

The Spectator

14th, " A Peripatetic Parson," tells us how one of his clerical brethren " completely spoilt " that sublime " And God said, Let there be light,' and there was light," by the...

IRISH STORIES.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR;'] SIR,—Under the above heading, some amusing anecdote's have appeared in the Spectator. The following may not be un- worthy of a place in your...

Page 32

BOOKS.

The Spectator

THE LAND OF THE LAMAS.* THE writer of this book, better prepared than most travellers for a rather perilous adventure, made a journey of several thousand miles through the...

Page 33

DARKNESS AND DAWN.*

The Spectator

THE problem which Archdeacon Farrar has endeavoured to illustrate in his " historical tale " is, in his own words, supreme and deeply interesting,—the problem, namely, afforded...

Page 34

MISS MILMAN'S "CHILDREN."* Miss MilattAx has a very pleasant gift

The Spectator

for drawing the character of children. She delights in their wayward and mischievous ways, and paints their naughty freaks with the most hearty sympathy. And yet her great...

Page 35

NABOTH'S VINEYARD.* IT is a curious but undeniable fact that

The Spectator

since the death of Lever and Le Fanu, Ireland has been represented in the domain of fiction almost entirely by women. We exempt the creator of Mulvaney from the category of...

Page 36

THE MODERN FACTORY SYSTEM.*

The Spectator

THE author of this book is also the author of an earlier one —Introduction to a History of the Factory System—which was published five years ago, and which received a cordial...

Page 37

Dagonet Ditties. By George B. Sims. (Chatto and Windus.)— Mr.

The Spectator

Sims reprints from the Referee some clever and amusing verses, Sometimes he is serious in tone; sometimes he is bent merely on fun ; for the most part, he seeks " to tell the...

The Lady of Raven's Combe. By E. H. Dering. 2

The Spectator

vols. (Art and Book Company.)—The closely printed pages of Mr. Dering's new story present anything but an attractive appearance, and inspire the very infrequent wish for an...

Con f irmation : its History and Meaning. By Julia S. Blunt.

The Spectator

(S.P.C.K.) — If the phrase " text-book " could fairly be used in this connection, we should say that this is as good a text-book of the subject as is needed. After an...

CURRENT LITERATURE.

The Spectator

The Poetical Works of Thomas Gray : English and Latin. " Aldine Edition." Edited by John Bradshaw, M.A., LL.D. (George B e ll and Sons.)—Gray's Poems. Edited, with Introduction...

Page 38

Letis's Diaries and Pocket-Books for 1892. These comprehend the "

The Spectator

Nonpareil Pocket Diary," in flexible calf ; the same in four other forms, less expensively bound ; a " Ladies' Diary and Pocket- Book," and larger forms for the housekeeper,...