4 JANUARY 1930

Page 1

INDEX FROM JANUARY 4th TO JUNE 28th, 1930, INCLUSIVE.

The Spectator

TOPICS OF THE DAY. A GNEW, Ewan .. .. 422 .t1LAgricultural Programme, an .. 42 Agriculture, liow to Save .. 693 — and Wasted Transport .. 727 — an All-Party Policy for .....

Page 5

r-Generg Smuts in the United - States .

The Spectator

: Not much attention has been given to the -visit 'cif :General Smuts to the United States, but: it would not the surprising if this visit turned out to be extraordinarily...

EDITORIAL AND PUBLLSITING OFFICES: 99 Gower Street, London, W.C. 1.—A

The Spectator

Subscription to the SPECTATOR costs Thirty Shillings per annum, including postage, to any part of the world. The SPECTATOR is registered as a Newspaper. The Postage on this...

Why does not the Prime Minister use his great power

The Spectator

Of nabial persuasion more vigorously ? Does he not admit that we are in the presence of an industrial and financial crisis which requires a vast common effort comparable to that...

News of the Week

The Spectator

The Government and the New Year A T the opening of the New Year the burdens and anxieties of the Government are ominously heavy. Unemployment is a persistent nightmare ; and...

- Americans, unhappily, are much too -apt to think of

The Spectator

the League as representing an obsolete European - ten- dency to force the will of a majority - upon those who dissent. If they had studied the laborious architectural work...

The Prime Minister seems to be so immersed in the

The Spectator

preliminaries of the Naval Conference that he has less . „time and..-inclination_than. . could , wish . for demanding in seffokt-- eoeXtensive -With - the - nation...

Page 6

But Mr. Henderson, of course, never contemplated the tearing up

The Spectator

of the Treaties. China, as a member of the League, necessarily subscribes to international law under which . Treaties can be ended only by giving the prescribed notice or by...

On Tuesday when Mr. Gandhi denounced violence. and moved a

The Spectator

resolution condemning the bomb outrage on the Viceroy's train he found that it was impossible to confine the frenzy which he had unwittingly aroused. He spoke amid persistent...

The full Congress opened last Saturday and was remarkable for

The Spectator

a violent speech by the President, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, who was educated at Harrow. He declared that the brief day of European domination was approaching its end. South...

On Friday, December 27th, the Subjects Committee of the National

The Spectator

Congress at Lahore accepted an extreme resolution which Mr. Gandhi had submitted to them on the previous day. The resolution—afterwards adopted by an overwhelming majority in...

China and the Treaties Last Saturday the Chinese Government at

The Spectator

Nanking issued a Rescript subjecting all foreigners from New Year's Day onwards to the laws of the Nankink Government and of its local representatives. Thus the Nanking...

It is precisely in the work of spreading information, and

The Spectator

enlisting sympathy and understanding for the labours of Europe that General Smuts may perform the function of a great missionary. No thinking European wants a conflict at any...

A singularly ironical comment on this speech was afforded by

The Spectator

the daily scenes at the Congress Car* where impassive onlookers watched the curiously excited antics of the Congress Volunteers. These Volunteers, singing a revolutionary song...

India We have discussed the new Indian situation in a

The Spectator

leading article, and here we need not do more than record the chief events. Lord Irwin's interview at Delhi with the leaders of the National Congress on Monday, December 23rd,...

Page 7

The Government are to be warmly congratulated on their choice

The Spectator

of the British Delegation for the International Labour Office Conference on wages, hours, and working conditions in the coal industry, which opens at Geneva next Monday. The...

Before The Hague Conference No pains have been spared to

The Spectator

make the second and final Hague Conference fireproof. The German delegation, appointed at a Cabinet meeting last Saturday, is impressive. It contains the heads of the four...

The Honours List The New Year's Honours List, contrary to

The Spectator

expectation, has not appreciably added to the list of Labour Peers. Six new Peerages are created and of these only two go to members of the Labour Party—Mr. Arthur Ponsonby...

A Cinema Disaster On Tuesday there occurred one of the

The Spectator

most terrible panics ever known in this country. In a cinema theatre in Paisley a film caught fire in the operator's room and the smoke was blown into the hall. In the ensuing...

Bank Bate, 5 per cent., changed from 5/ per cent.

The Spectator

on December 12th, 1929. War Loan (5 per cent.) was on Tuesday 100*; on Tuesday week, 100; a year ago, 102k; Funding Loan (4 per cent.) was on Tuesday 851; on Tuesday week, 851...

Mr. Snowden and Safeguarding On Monday, December 23rd, Mr. Snowden

The Spectator

made his statement in the House of Commons with regard to the Safeguarding Duties, and, as was expected, he delivered sentence of death. Taking his stand on constitutional...

The .German Referendum The Referendum on December 22nd against the

The Spectator

"enslavement of the German people" was the fiasco that it was expected to be. Only about six million people were prevailed upon to record a vote. This result has provoked wry...

The Coal Industry It is admitted, not only in the

The Spectator

Labour Party, that the fireworks "and the voting in Parliament on the Coal Bill set up a smoke screen which has obscured the country's opinion of that Bill. Mr. Graham has lost...

Page 8

Mr. Gandhi's New Policy

The Spectator

B RITISH Governments have often faced a situation in a provisionally dependent country as confusing and as discouraging as that which we now see in India, and if the present...

Page 9

The French Naval Memorandum T_TOVVEVER abruptly France may have brought

The Spectator

an end to dreams of an easy agreement at the London Naval Conference she ought to be applauded . for the excellent clearness and the dialectical vigour of her Naval Memorandum....

Page 10

In Defence of the Faith VII.—Faith and Works rrofessor Rudolf

The Spectator

Otto, one of the most influential of living theologians, is well known in this country by his great work, The idea of the Holy.—ED. Spectator.] W HAT is the true meaning of...

Page 11

Indian Legislators.—I [In the days of Lord Curzon Mr. Arnold

The Spectator

Ward spent a year and a half travelling in India as a newspaper correspondent. He at in the House of' Commons from 1910 to 1918 as Unionist Member for Watford. Last winter he...

Page 13

Towards International Understanding

The Spectator

[The Board of Education has set in operation a system of ex- chang e of assistants between English and German secondary schools. This as led to the formation of sub-committees...

Page 14

• The Anarchy of Books

The Spectator

TO WHERE could the principles of Malthus be - LI applied with such beneficial effect as in the world of books. In no other sphere do we suffer so much from the discomfort of...

Page 15

The Cat

The Spectator

M ISS AUGUSTA sat down on a seat in St. James's Park, trembling with terror. It was only yesterday that she had allowed herself to realize the truth ; but, since then, she...

Page 16

Correspondence

The Spectator

A LETTER FROM MOSCOW. [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—It is, perhaps, not generally realized that the past year has brought to the Soviet Union a new revolution, in...

Page 17

A Hundred Years Ago

The Spectator

THE " SPECTATOR," JANUARY 2ND, 1830. 1829. We had a sincere respect for 1829, and we love the recollection of its great deeds. Abroad and at home, tho cause of liberty and...

Art

The Spectator

[Tun ITALIAN EXHIBITION.] A CONSIDERED article on the Italian Exhibition that opened in Burlington House this week is not poosible at a day's notice, which is the time...

Page 18

Florida Purity League at the outset of a campaign to

The Spectator

prohibit psycho-analysis and "other insidious teaching under the guise of science ' " in American schools and colleges supported by public funds. With a zeal which refuses to be...

American Notes of the Week

The Spectator

THE NEW SESSION OF CONGRESS. Congress, convening on January 6th, is faced with a long, arduous and controversial Session. The fight over the Tariff Bill, between regular...

NEW YORK AT LAW.

The Spectator

Two unusual suits have been launched in the United States Supreme Court, with the States of New Jersey and New York as litigants. In the first, New Jersey seeks to restrain New...

American college administrators in denouncing the popular American belief that

The Spectator

it necessarily does a student good to work his way through college. "The notion," an official bulletin from Cornell declares, "is as false as it is queer. Self-support handicaps...

THE DEVELOPMENT OF ALASKA.

The Spectator

The United States becomes increasingly conscious of the excellence of the bargain which it made when it bought Alaska for the nominal sum of $7,200,000. Several official reports...

THE TIMBER SITUATION.

The Spectator

Impelled by the urgent need to provide timber supplies for the future, the New York State Reforestation Commission recommends adoption of an unusually ambitious plan. This calls...

Page 19

The League of Nations

The Spectator

Pacific Relations [Our New. York correspondent sends us this interesting account of the recent meeting of the Institute of Pacific Relations at Kyoto. He was also present at...

Page 20

* *

The Spectator

A COCK YEAR. A keeper of my acquaintance bred this last year a good many pheasants, and bred them very successfully ; but his birds exhibited an anomaly. Out of every ten eight...

A BABY SQUIRREL.

The Spectator

In a district of Berkshire, where the species is still found in good quantity, a red squirrel was seen hopping along the ground with what looked like a ball held in the...

The luck of the ballot has fallen to the author

The Spectator

of the new Bill for preservation. It is a good Bill as well as a lucky one. Let us welcome the omen, and try the " Sortes Vergilianas." The passage on which my eyes alight turns...

UNPOPULOUS LAURELS.

The Spectator

May I make a suggestion as to a small and unimportant detail of beautification ? The great reservoirs which hold London's water are enclosed by high sloping banks on which a...

THE LUCKY EAST.

The Spectator

It has not been realized in the great floods of last December how great has been the contrasting rainfall in the West and East. "The forecast has almost always been wrong in...

TRAVEL.

The Spectator

Owing to great pressure on our space the usual Travel Article is held over this week.—ED. SPECTATOR.

Country Life

The Spectator

" CONCILIA PIORUM." It is a very good sign of the times that an "amenity group" has come into being in the - House of Commons, and is showing great and wise activity. It is not...

A MIGRATION QUERY.

The Spectator

Some curiosities of bird life in England have to be recorded. A large eagle has been making its appearance in Essex. A bird lover who was told of the locality went down from...

Page 21

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

.Sin,—Anyone interested in Temperance Reform will have read Lord D'Abernon's remarks in the Spectator for Dec- ember 7th and 14th, with great respect, but not without wonder....

Letters to the Editor LORD D'ABERNON'S TEMPERANCE POLICY

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SrEcrAroit.1 Sntr.—As one of Lord D'Abernon's colleagues on the War- time Liquor Control Board, I should like to point out that your contributor, "...

Page 22

SELF-GOVERNMENT IN INDIA [To the Editor of the SPECTATORJ

The Spectator

is to be regretted that the Daily Mail should have succeeded in persuading a number of former high officials from India to contribute to• its columns a deplorable series of...

SOVIET RUSSIA [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sm,—Many of your readers will have read with interest, and perhaps some sympathy, the very lucid and clever account of the objects and aims of the Soviet Government contained...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Permit me to thank

The Spectator

you 'very sincerely for your cour- ageous, just, and timely article in last week's Spectator anent India. For the past forty-five years I have had many relatives there, so Iknow...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—While we are striving for a new and better outlook in India, as advocated in your leading article on December 28th, would it not be well to be quite clear what we mean...

Page 23

THE SANTA CLAUS MYTH [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—I entirely agree with your correspondent in thinking it unwise to deceive children about Santa Claus—like "Molly," in the example given in his letter, I vividly...

WHO SPEAKS FOR THE UNIONIST PARTY?

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Yes, more Unionists do agree with Mr. Churchill than you suppose.—! am, Sir, &c., H. J. SADLER. 21 Argyll Road, Kensington, W.8.

TRADE REALITIES [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Snt,—The article headed "Trade Realities" in your issue of the 14th ult.. calls for some reply. To say with the writer that we are losing ground as compared with our trade...

THE MODERN ATTITUDE TO THE BIBLE

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPEcrxron.1 Sm,—Your correspondent, Mr. Taylor, is quite right and is sutoported by the latest results of scientific research. Christ's words, correctly...

Page 24

AN INCREASE IN ROMAN CATHOLICISM?

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sia,—In a recent number of the Spectator the statement was quoted about Christian Science that in the United States "many regard it as likely...

OTTER HUNTING

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—Being a great -lover of animals, I have just read with the greatest interest Mr. John Galsworthy's article "Animals and Birds" in your...

THE PASTEUR TREATMENT

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—Your issue of December 28th contains a letter from Dr. Roux, of the Pasteur Institute, criticizing a letter of mine that appeared in...

IN DEFENCE OF THE FAITH

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sia,—In the prefatory note to ray article, Number V in the "Defence of the Faith" series, you describe me as having "produced a translation...

THE EXPORT OF HORSES

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—In the issue of November 30th the Honorary Organizing Secretary of the International League Against the Export of Horses for Butchery...

Page 25

"PLOUGH MONDAY" [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sm,—Plough Monday being at hand, you may be interested to have the Plough Boy's Play, which is still done in the York- shire villages. To my knowledge it has never been...

WOES OF THE CAGED [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sin,—On behalf of the Scottish S.P.C.A., I trust you will permit me to thank Major Yeats-Brown for his strong indictment of the cruelties inseparable from the performing...

THE LEAGUE OF NATIONS UNION [To the Editor of the

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.] Sra,—May I take the occasion of the recent meeting of the General Council of the League of Nations Union to draw the attention of your readers to certain aspects...

VITTORIO VENETO

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] S1R,—A correspondent in the Spectator of November 9th seeks elucidation of the reference to the French and British divisions as "the spear...

Page 26

POINTS FROM LETTERS

The Spectator

THE MOHAMMEDANS IN CEYLON. In your issue of December 21st you have an interesting article on "The Experiment in Ceylon "; but towards the bottom of the second paragraph, when...

The Crow

The Spectator

I KNOW a willow tree, unpollarded, neglected, Where sits a ruminative crow, • Who, in the grey canal below, Hour after hour, perceives himself reflected. Or does he watch...

The Kingfisher

The Spectator

THE meadow lands are waterlogged to-day, A monochrome of cold, metallic grey Saddens the eyes. Skeleton trees, with roots submerged in mud Like masts of stranded ships, about...

Page 27

The influence of great men in after ages is a

The Spectator

subject of great interest. In The Mantle of Caesar, by Friedrich Gundolf, translated by J. W. Hartmann (Grant Richards and H. Toulmin, 15s.) we have a learned and engaging study...

A New Competition IN his Country Life article of November

The Spectator

30th, SIR W. BEAcrt TriosiAs suggested that "what we want is really some little rhyme that will be the motto of the tidiers." We, therefore, offer a prize of five guineas for...

Some Books of the Week

The Spectator

THERE possibly was a time when, for the anthropologist, culture was "essentially something static," but that time has long since passed away. If there is one thing which...

Although Sir Jagadis Bose has nothing of startling novelty to

The Spectator

offer to the general reader in his new volume of researches into plant-physiology—Growth and Tropic Movement of Plants (Longmans, 21s.)—he has made an important scientific...

Those who would understand China may be commended to Dr.

The Spectator

Richard Wilhelm's Short History of Chinese Civilization, admirably translated by Miss Joan Joshua, with an intro- duction by Dr. Lionel Giles (Harrap, 12s. 6d.). Dr. Wilhelm...

A hundred years ago there was no need to be

The Spectator

puzzled in decid- ing on a Christmas or New Year present. Keepsakes and Remem- brancers and Friendship's Offerings appeared in timely season and in prodigious numbers. The most...

As a spirited attack upon the excesses of French writers,

The Spectator

such as Henri de Montherlant, Barres and Gauthier, who have found in Spain precisely the illusions which they first took there themselves, Mr. Mario Praz's Unromantic Spain...

The Spectator

We congratulate the Scottish Motor Traction Company on their enterprise

The Spectator

and, enthusiasm in publishing a new and enlarged form of the S. M. T. Magazine and, above all, on the support which the editor intends to give to all movements having at heart...

Page 28

Shakespeare the Schoolmaster

The Spectator

Shakespeare's Henry VI and Richard III. By Peter Alexander. (Cambridge Univ. Press. 8s. 6d.) AMONG the traditions of Shakespeare's life before he came to London there is one...

A Book of Life

The Spectator

Chief Justice Coke, His Family and Descendants at Ho1kham By C. W. James. (Country Life. 30s.) THE appearance of a book of this kind makes Us praise Heaven for the evidence on...

Page 29

A Page of Russian - History THE last Commander-in-Chief of the

The Spectator

old Russian Army was a gallant cavalry leader and a fine figure of a man in his Circassian tunic.- General Wrangel took no part in polities until the debdde of 1917. The year...

From Midshipman to Millionaire The Autobiography of a British Yarn

The Spectator

Merchant. By W. F. M. Weston-Webb. (Cayme Press. 10s. 6d.) IT is true, as Mr. Stephen Gwynn says in his introduction to this interating book, that we know very little about the...

Page 30

Mostly Italian

The Spectator

An Introduction to Italian Painting. By Sir Charles Holmes. With forty plates. (Cassell. 10s. 6d.) The Italian Masters : a Survey and a Guide. By Horace BOTH Sir Charles Holmes...

THE INDEX TO VOLUME 143 OF THE " SPECTATOR. "

The Spectator

WILL BE READY FOR DELIVERY ON JANUARY 20TH, 1930. Readers resident outside the British Idea, and Lararits Overseas, are asked to inform the SPECTATOR Office in advance as to...

Page 31

The Phantom Walls

The Spectator

PROFESSOR SniFSON wisely points out that "one of the great aeeds in an age of rapidly increasing scientific specialism is for each specialist occasionally to sit back and think...

Newness of Life

The Spectator

The Influence of Christ in the Ancient World. By T. R. Glover, {Cambridge University Press. as.) No living writer approaches Dr. Glover in the power of com- bining the results...

Page 32

Life in Old China

The Spectator

Tu Fu, the Man who delights in Beauty, lived during the T'ang dynasty of China, in the 8th century A.D. and wrote his life in poetry. It was a full, exciting and perambulatory...

Dinosaurs and Whales

The Spectator

Ends of the Earth. By Roy Chapman Andrews. (Putnam. 16s.) ALL the world 'knows how Mr. Andrews' expedition in the Gobi Desert went bird's-nesting for clutches of dinosaur's...

Page 33

Fiction

The Spectator

THE LIFE FASHIONABLE. By Peter Traill. (Bren- tano. 75. Od.)—We have often suspected that the eternal triangle was really a quadrilateral and that the novelist's weakness for...

Ghosts

The Spectator

The Gothick North. II. These Sad Ruins. By Sacheverell Sitwell. • (Duckworth. 8s. 6d.) IF, as we believe; it was a mistake to publish The Visit of the Gypsies by itself, it...

FORTY-ONE. A Romance by Alan Downey (Duffy, Dublin, 5s.).—Ireland has

The Spectator

lacked a Walter Scott and its picturesque and chequered ages of romance have been left to the his- torians. Mr. Alan Downey's historical romance of the events which led to the...

THE SEVEN STABS. By John Cameron. (Gollancz. 75. 6d.)—This is

The Spectator

the right sort of detective story. Murders, clues, new theories and other fresh developments occur on every page. We suspect every member of the house-party in turn, for they...

EVERY DOG, by E. and V. Pringle-West. (Benn. 7s. 6d.)

The Spectator

—Here we have a farce of the most wildly extravagant nature, which is unfortunately treated as though it were a very mild little comedy. It begins with Lord Pavington's...

Reference Books

The Spectator

Debretes Peerage, 1930. (Dean. £3 15s.) -The People's Year Book, 1930. (Co-operative Wholesale Society, 1 Balloon Street, Manchester. 3s.) Post Office London Directory, 1980....

Page 34

Sir Owen Seaman has done a gentle deed by disturbing

The Spectator

the dusty files of Punch which have accumulated during the last twenty-one years, and extracting therefrom those lyrics, written from a "bat's back," which still retain a little...

The contents of Mr. Markov's How We Tried to Save

The Spectator

the Tsaritsa (Putnam, 15s.) are singularly at variance with its title. He and his little circle made no real attempt to save their royal mistress (it is interesting to find...

A foreword by Aloysius Horn and a preface by Rosita

The Spectator

Forbes leave little for a mere reviewer to say about The Fortunate Islands, by Amelia Defries (Cecil Palmer, 7s. 6d.). What remains to be said after Mr. Horn has exclaimed :...

However eminent and vocal, Mayfair is a very small part

The Spectator

of London, and even Deauville does not loom very large in the scheme of things. If certain men and women of Kenya are Tarred with the Same Brush, by le Comte de Janze...

* * • 4.

The Spectator

A belief in magic is the root of all evil. So at least thinks M. Raoul Allier, whose latest book, Le non-civilise et nous, has been translated by Mr. Fred Rothwell, under the...

Surely the public is by this time bored by reading

The Spectator

about Cora Pearl, Maria Manning and Lola Montes, but Mr. Horace Wyndham by issuing Feminine Frailty (Berm, 18s.) seems to think otherwise. In addition to matter that has been...

Professor Mawer, who with Professor Stenton founded the English Place-name

The Spectator

Society, and is editing its excellent volumes on the counties, has printed his recent King's College lectures on Problems of Place-name Study (Cambridge University Press, Os.)....

More Books of the Week (Continued from page 23.) Twentieth

The Spectator

Century Stage Decoration (Knopf, /5 5s.) will serve better than any known to us as a work of reference in regard to the work of the Idealist Theatre—defining that term as the...

Undeniably clever as is Mr. Ralph Barton's God's Country (Knopf,

The Spectator

10s. 6d.) this comic history of the United States by the illustrator of Gentlemen Prefer Blondes has too strong and bitter a flavour to be to the taste of English readers. A...

Among the four or five of London's most distinguished territorial

The Spectator

regiments the Artists' Rifles holds a high place. It is therefore fitting that their already high sense of esprit de corps should be still further strengthened by Colonel May's...

General Knowledge Questions

The Spectator

Oust weekly prize of one guinea for the best thirteen Questions submitted is awarded this week to M. J. C. Meiklejohn, 136 Coombe Lane, S.W. 20, for the following :— -...

Page 37

Finance Public and Private

The Spectator

The Outlook for 1930 THERE is a rather striking contrast between the optimism which marked the closing of 1929 and the soberness, not to say sombreness, with which the...

Page 38

NEW CAPITAL IN 1929.

The Spectator

Naturally enough, the break in Stock Exchange activity , during the second half of 1929 occasioned a smart reaction in respect of capital creations. This is clearly shown in the...

MONETARY PROSPECTS.

The Spectator

On the whole, the monetary prospects for January are fairly good, though whether they will lead to an early reduction in the Bank Rate remains to be seen. Much, no doubt, will...

NEW ZEALAND AND RIVER PLATE LAND.

The Spectator

Once again, and notwithstanding the fact that conditions in Argentina have been less favourable for some time past, the report of the New Zealand and River Plate Land Mortgage...

Financ i al Notes

The Spectator

INVESTMENTS FIRM. FoLLowniu upon the depression during the greater part of December, the stock markets wound up the year in tolerably cheerful fashion. End of the year...

LONDON TIN SYNDICATE.

The Spectator

The impending important fusion in the tin industry imparted additional interest to the recent meeting of the London Tin Syndicate. Lord Askwith, who presided, gave a very...

Page 40

* * * * A DECLINING REVENUE.

The Spectator

The figures of the National Revenue for the first nine months of the current fiscal year are not very encouraging, though they just about fulfil market expectations. Briefly...