7 MARCH 1931

Page 1

News of the Week Lord Irwin and Mr. Gandhi T HE

The Spectator

most important hnd cheering news which we have had from India for a long time was published in the papers of Wednesday. In the early hours of that morning Lord Irwin and Mr....

It will be the part of unimaginative thinkers to exclaim

The Spectator

with horror that Lord Irwin has " surrendered " about the salt tax. As a matter of fact, he has yielded some- thing which only a craven fear of being called weak could have...

EDITORIAL. AND PUBLISHING OFFICES : 99 Gower Street, London, W.C.

The Spectator

1.—A Subscription to the SPECTATOR costs Thirty Shillings per annum, including postage, to any part of the world. The SpEc-reina is registered as a Newspaper. The Postage on...

Lord Irwin has evidently behaved like the commander of an

The Spectator

army who, although he knows that he has force at his disposal immensely superior to that of his enemy, wants to agree to conditions of peace which will not be wounding. The...

As for Lord Irwin, we cannot express too strongly our

The Spectator

grateful admiration of his moral courage. He has persisted in the face of much misrepresentation and disparagement, but he is bringing to India a harvest of peace which could...

Page 2

The Mixed Arbitral Tribunals The Mixed Arbitral Tribunals set up

The Spectator

under Article 304 of the Treaty of Versailles have been on the whole successful experiments. There is no doubt about the success of the Anglo-German tribunal, the principal...

The Confusion of the Parties The political confusion becomes worse.

The Spectator

Nobody knows what programme the Government will produce in order to replace the Bills which are being slaughtered one after another, though it is true that the Alternative Vote...

The Red Cross Two international conventions enlarging the scope of

The Spectator

Red Cross work in war-time were laid before Parliament on Monday. They were signed at Geneva in July, 1929, and are now to be ratified. One of them strengthens the Red Cross...

The Trade Disputes Bill We have written elsewhere about the

The Spectator

issue of the Trade Disputes Bill, but may mention here that before the Bill was abandoned on Tuesday there were many comings and goings between Cabinet Ministers and the Liberal...

We arc unfeignedly glad that Mr. Gandhi, on his side,

The Spectator

has dropped his inadmissible demand about the police. Last week we expressed our concern about this because long experience has shown that when a Government throws over, or...

Progress in China In spite of the temptation, in the

The Spectator

present state of China, to continue the present party dictatorship, the Central Executive of the Kuomintang has decided to draft a provisional Constitution. This represents a...

The New Australian Cabinet The new Australian Cabinet shows Mr.

The Spectator

Scullin in the ascendant. At the meeting of the Federal Labour Caucus on Monday all the Ministries were declared vacant, and a ballot was taken to fill the posts. Mr. Scullin...

In fine, the Labour-Liberal compact was in a fair way

The Spectator

to be continued, but these tactics broke down utterly before the determination of the ordinary Labour members and the ordinary Liberals not to compromise. We cannot be surprised...

Page 3

Sir Charles Trevelyan has resigned, his immediate reason being the

The Spectator

rejection of the School Attendance Bill by the Lords, but in his letter to the Prime Minister he added that he had been " very much out of sympathy " with the Government on...

Charing Cross Bridge Though - the full Report of the Committee

The Spectator

set up to advise the L.C.C. on Charing Cross Bridge is not yet available, it is clear from Sir Leslie Scott's speech on Tuesday that the majority favour a modified version of...

French Rugby Football The Rugby Football Union announced on Monday

The Spectator

that no further matches with French clubs could be played until the control and conduct of the game in France had been placed on a satisfactory basis. The decision, coming on...

Mr. Basil Mathews The newly-created American Professorship of Missions at

The Spectator

Boston has been accepted by Mr. Basil Mathews, the well-known missionary who is the author of the Clash of Colour and similar works. Recently he has been working at Geneva for...

In the Liberal Party, Sir John Simon pursues his independent

The Spectator

course. On Tuesday he had the temerity to make a tentatively Protectionist speech in the Free Trade Hall, Manchester. Yet this was not so bold as the delivery of such a speech...

Meanwhile there is a curious situation in the tradition- ally

The Spectator

Unionist constituency of St. George's, Westminster. Sir Ernest Petter has come forward as an independent candidate whose main policy seems to be " Out with Baldwin." The...

Insulin and Carotin The Medical Research Council in its Report

The Spectator

for 1929-30, gently reproaches the medical profession for not, making fuller use of insulin in the treatment of diabetes. The consumption of insulin has increased steadily since...

Bank Rate, 8 per cent., changed from 81 per cent.

The Spectator

on May 1st, 1930. War Loan (5 per cent.) was on -Wednesday 10311; , on Wednesday week, 1081; a year ago, 102. Funding Loan (4 per cent.) was on Wednesday 921 ; on Wednesday...

Page 4

France and Italy

The Spectator

T HE failure of France and Italy to agree at the London Naval Conference about the respective strengths of • their navies has hung like a black cloud over the political...

Page 5

The Trade Disputes Issue

The Spectator

rc HE defeat of the Government in Standing Committee on the essential clause of the Trade . Disputes Bill was deserved, and it is important that every thinking man and woman...

The Week in Parliament THE present situation is extraordinary, and

The Spectator

certainly - I - unparalleled in British politics.. A minority Government, clinging desperately to office, is maintained there with the utmost difficulty by a small and divided...

Page 6

The National Library of Scotland

The Spectator

BY G. M. THOMSON. [The Bill of the Trustees of the National Library for a Provisional Order will be before Parliament this month. Mr. Thermion puts the ease against the Bill,...

Page 7

The Agricultural Situation and the Government

The Spectator

Proposals—III BY CHRISTOPHER TURNOR [This is the third and last of Mr. Tumor's articles on the Govern- ment's proposals with regard to Agriculture. We would draw attention...

Page 8

Are We Over-Populated ?

The Spectator

By R. A. FISHER. [Dr. Fisher of the Statistical Department of Rothamsted Experimental Station is one of the most brilliant of our younger mathematicians and scientists. His...

Page 9

• Psychology and Religion

The Spectator

W.—The Psychology of Religious Dogma BY DR. ROBERT H. TIMULESS, M.A., PH.D. [Dr. Robert Thouless is Lecturer in Psychology at Glasgow University. Next week Rev. Fearon...

Page 10

On a Candle Lit by an Elephant

The Spectator

BY J. B. MORTON. T HE other day a man was charged with causing an elephant to be led in a prohibited area. The magistrate who heard the ease said : " I cannot imagine a more...

Page 11

Mr. J. L. Garvin

The Spectator

BY AmICUS. I N the figure there is alertness, vigilance, readiness to pounce : in the gnawed sidelong cigar, shrewdness ; in the eye—well, the eye is an eye " in fine frenzy...

My First Grief

The Spectator

BY RABINDRANATH TAGORE. [Translated from the original Bengali by Bhabani Bhattdcharya.] • T HE pathway that runs through the shades of the wood is now - covered with tall...

Page 12

The Cinema

The Spectator

[Cit_\RLIE Ch APLIN'S " CITY LIGHTS." DOMINION THEATRE.] " WE come to laugh at Charlie, not to criticize him." So I said to myself on arriving outside the Dominion Theatre to...

The Theatre

The Spectator

[" Ton CIRCLE." By W. SOMERSET MAUGHAM. AT THE VAUDEVILLE THEATRE. " DESIRE UNDER THE ELMS." BY EUGENE O'NEILL. AT THE GATE THEATRE STUDIO. " THE VENETIAN." By CLIFFORD RAX. AT...

Page 13

A Hundred Years Ago

The Spectator

THE " SPECTATOR," MARCH 5TH, 183!. THE REFORM BILL. The Great Measure has at length been laid before the public. It fully justifies the anticipations of the warmest friends of...

A New Competition

The Spectator

The Editor offers a prize of two guineas for the best new verse for " God Save the King," advocating world co-operation. This Competition will close on Friday, March 20th.

Report of the Competition

The Spectator

THE Editor offered a prize last week of two guineas for the best description on a postcard of the thoughts of Mr. Beer- bohm's caricature of Lord Cecil. We have decided to award...

Page 14

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

WANTED : A NEW REFORM BILL [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —The objections raised to " A New Reform Bill " in the three interesting letters in your issue of February...

Page 15

MATERNAL MORTALITY IN INDIA

The Spectator

. [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—Maternal mortality in India is a subject which has been - treated from various points of view by different observers. It is a...

THE COLOUR BAR

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—Referring to Mr. Sinanan's letter, I could quote numbers of instances where the colour bar in this country does not apply to cricket,...

Page 16

RUSSIAN TIMBER CAMPS [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —With

The Spectator

all due respect will you permit me to say that I think the theoristic, high-brow, callous tone of Mr. H. G. Metcalf's letter casts a shadow on our national honour ? Thousands of...

FORCED LABOUR IN KENYA [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—As you have had correspondence in your columns on the subject of forced labour in Kenya Colony, I think the following reply by Government to a question I asked in...

PROBATION OFFICERS [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —The barrier

The Spectator

which has excluded many men and women from the probation service because they were not communi- cants of the Church of England was not erected by Local Authorities. It was, in...

THE RECOGNITION OF OSTEOPATHS [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sm,—Your editorial comment upon the letter of " A General Medical Practitioner," in your last issue puts in a nutshell the case for legal recognition and regulation of...

Page 17

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin.—Three points seem to

The Spectator

be established by this corre- spondence : (1) The clergy in most places cannot accomplish properly the pastoral visitation of the whole parish. (2) If they endeavour to do so...

ANIMAL SUFFERING IN JAFFA

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—May I make an urgent appeal towards obtaining an ambulance for the Jaffa and Telaviv Society for the Pro- tection of Animals ? Thanks...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sra,—The Coal Owners' Association, according to Mr. Philip Gee's letter, have asked the Minister for Mines to "• insist " on the production of evidence of cruelties to pit...

THE . CALL OF THE CHURCH [To the Editor of the

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.] SIR ,—Your correspondent Mr. Jethro. Sable asks " how the parson discovers the sick and the infirm in his parish." Ile will find an answer to his inquiry in the...

PIT PONIES [To the Editor of the SchczAton.] Sin,—May I

The Spectator

be permitted to endorse the views expressed by your correspondent Mr. - Philip Gee, in your issue of Feb- ruary 14th ? If definite evidence to support Miss Gardner's charges...

Page 18

LEGLESS BIRDS

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,--On an early day in January, 1929, on the sands at Camber, near Rye, I watched for some time a ringed plover with only one leg, hopping...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sin,—In reply to Mr. B. E. Westbury may I suggest that the loss of a leg or legs in our river gulls is due either to fish (pike or eels most probably) or to rats? To the...

THE FUR CRUSADE

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, I have read with interest the letter in the Spectator of Jan. 17th from Mrs. Breck, President of the Anti-Steel-Trap League of Washington,...

The Red-Throated Diver

The Spectator

SHADOWED and frowned upon by Hope and Hee, Lashed into frenzy by the sudden squall, There lies a tarn. Few human footsteps fall Upon its banks, though passing hinds may see...

BURNS AND THE BIOGRAPHER

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—In my letter to the Spectator of November 8th I made grave specific charges against the Burns Federation. Sir Alexander Gibb, replying...

THE BRITISH MUSEUM

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—Mr. Squire, in his delightful references to some past frequenters of the British Museum Reading Room, suggests that " the silent aisles...

Page 19

mit spectator [351]

The Spectator

FINANCIAL SUPPLEMENT BANKING AND INSURANCE No. 5,358.] WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, MARCH •7, 1931. [GRATIS

Page 21

Banking in 193o

The Spectator

A Difficult Year TIIERE appears to be a popular belief in some quarters that no matter whether general conditions in the country are prosperous or not, the profession of...

Page 25

Banking in Scotland

The Spectator

ALTHOUGH, in- the main, general conditions affecting banking profits in Scotland have not differed vastly from those south of the Tweed, there have nevertheless been some points...

Page 27

Family Protection Policies

The Spectator

Ix the previous Financial Supplement of the Spectator brief allusion was made, in discussing the relative merits of whole, life and endowment assurances, to the problem of...

Page 29

London's Gold

The Spectator

rill: bullion market is one . Of the most 'romantic of London's institutions. Every year many million pounds! worth of solid gold are sold there like so much merchandise. The...

Page 31

Bankers and Industry The " MacMillan " Inquiry Ix October,

The Spectator

1929, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Mr. Philip Snowden, announced in the House of Commons the intention of the Government to appoint a committee to enquire into--the Bankin...

Page 34

London : Printed by \V. SPEAICIIT AND SONS, LTD., 98

The Spectator

and 99 Fetter Lane, E.C. 4, and Published by THE SPECTATOR, LTD., at their Offices. No. 99 Gower Street, London, W.C. 1.—Saturday, March 7, 1931.

Page 35

Monetary Science

The Spectator

Ma. KEYNES'S new TrEdfise on Money appears at a most opportune moment. It: comes just as the whole world is bewildered by a rapid and disastrous fall in prices, which is...

Page 36

Recollections of Oxford

The Spectator

MRS. COURTNEY'S book is good company. We envy her recollections of Oxford in those more beautiful days when the suburbs were not built and the cars and the crowds had not come...

Page 37

Lord Eustace Percy's Plan Democracy on Trial. By Lord Eustace

The Spectator

Percy, M.P. (John Lane. is. 6d.) A TIME of national depression is always an occasion for newly invented remedies. It is the hey-day of the opportunist and the quack who is...

Travels in South America

The Spectator

Green Hell. By Julian Duguid. (Cape. 10s. 6d.) WE owe a real debt to the Spanish peoples for preserving a substantial part of the new world from dullness, and it is a debt...

Page 38

The Brontes through French Eyes The Brontë' Sisters. By Emilie

The Spectator

and Georges Romieu. (Skeffuigton. 12s. 6d.) • IF only the Brontës had had a good stepinother ! Some amiable lady, not too young, with a little money, common sense and...

The German Submarine War, 1914-1918

The Spectator

The German Submarine War, 1914-1918. By R. H. Gibson and Maurice Prendergast. (Constable. 36s.) TJIF authors of this book have admirably gathered together all the more important...

Page 39

A Fragrant Book

The Spectator

Tins is indeed a fragrant book ! Besides the technical information, the nomenclature, and the plain instructions for growing the most scented varieties of an endless number of...

A Prince of Music Letters of Hans Von Bulow. Edited,

The Spectator

with an Introduction, by Count Du Moulin Eckert. The Translation edited with a Preface and Notes by Scott Goddard. (Knopf. 1,000 copies at 218.) THERE is still a large number of...

Page 40

The Palace

The Spectator

THE London home of the King and Queen was known to be full of beautiful things. But the descriptions and photo- graphs of the Royal treasures in Mr. Clifford Smith's fine and...

Fiction

The Spectator

Value for Money Ships In The Bay ! By D. K. Broster. (Heinemann. 7s. 6d.) Two novels of individual excellence, one by a practised hand, the other by a newcomer ; a swinging...

The World Around

The Spectator

The World Our Neighbour. By Vernon Bartlett. (Elki n Mathews and Marrot. 6s.) MR. VERNON BARTLETT, as a member of the League of Nations Secretariat, has, of course, no politics,...

Page 41

TUMULT IN THE NORTH. By George Preedy. (John Lane. 7s.

The Spectator

6d.)—A rattling story of the days of the Old Pretender by the most successful historical novelist of our generation. Heartily recommended to boys of all ages—from seventeen...

New Novels

The Spectator

THE ERL KING. By Edwin Granberry. (Constable' 7s. 6d.)—Mr. Granberry has several of the novelist's virtues, notably sincerity and feeling : but his story of the' Florida'...

COME JULIA. By Helen Granville Barker. (Sidgwick and Jackson. 7s.

The Spectator

6d.)—A story of distinction by a novelist who, more intent upon inner than outer drama, justifies her choice by humour," sympathy, and a precise observa- tion of human character.

MARKET TOWN. By Ena Limebeer. (Cape. 7s. 6d.)— The town

The Spectator

is in Hampshire and is peopled principally by Pecksniffs and congenital idiots. Well-written, but surely libellous.

ARCHY AND MEHITABEL. By Don Marquis. (Berm. 8s. 6d.)—What a

The Spectator

magnificent couple ! An alley cat who in spite of everything is " always the lady ' and an aggrieved cockroach with a gift for typing. A delicious example of dry and ribald...

DEAD MAN'S SHADOW. By Basil Carey. (Constable. 7s. 6d.)—Rival crews

The Spectator

of two stout sailing ships in the South Seas, a murder, a beautiful girl and stolen jewels make an exciting yarn for juvenile grown-ups.

EACH STANDS ALONE. By Arthur Wellings. (Dent, 7s. 6d.)—An intentionally

The Spectator

mechanical and telegraphic record of a girl clerk's emotions in office, suburbia and love. A " Strange Interlude " in Wimbledon.

In THE PAISLEY SHAWL (Collins, 7s. 6d.) Mr. Frederick Niven

The Spectator

is on his second speed. He tries us rather hard in extracting a tinkle or two out of the eternal triangle.

THE TRAIL OF THE BLACK KING. By Anthony Arm- strong.

The Spectator

(Methuen. 7s. 6d.)—Tracking down a black- mailer becomes quite a jolly affair with sleuths like Jimmy Lezaire and his irrepressible assistant. Good fun and innocuous excitement.

THE DOG AND DUCK MYSTERY. By Hogan Bogue. (Jarrolds. 7s.

The Spectator

6d.)—" A cheerful murder story," says the author. A normal specimen of modern, machine- made melodrama for the million. Here's to more and merrier murders !

CONSCIENCE. By Aceituna Griffin. (Murray. 7s. 6d.)-- People who are

The Spectator

above all snobs are poor soil for the development of the tragic psychological implications of a concealed murder. Smoothly written, however, and holds the interest.

TATIANA. By H. 0. S. Wright. (Shaylor. 7s. 6d.)—A Russian

The Spectator

girl comes unscathed through the worst horrors of the revolution to wed a Labour M.P. A brisk, brutal and super-sensational yarn.

GOVERNOR HARDY. By Hamish Blair. (Blackwood. 75. 6a.)—A ucpressing, but

The Spectator

fortunately incredible, story of India thirty years hence. Governor Hardy trium- phantly sweeps away politicians, lawyers and Bolsheviks, and restores the iron hand. Soothing...

Page 42

The Magazines

The Spectator

THE. Nineteenth Century for March leads off with the inevitable article on India, in this case by Lord Meston, who disparages 'the achievements of the Conference, and writes, we...

From Mr. W. D. Bowman's The Story of Surnames (Rout-

The Spectator

ledge, 7s. 6d.) the uncritical reader will get some instruction, he will be interested in the origin and meaning of many curious names, and he will learn by copious examples...

Some Books of the Week

The Spectator

A FINE piece of history is Mr. Shan Bullock's After Sixty Years (Sampson Low, 8s. 6d.), and a fine and faithful picture it draws of the tranquil but iron-hard life led by Lough...

Screamed at by religious bigots, plotted against by an unscrupulous

The Spectator

and corrupt gang of nobles (her own half- brother their fugleman), diplomatically undermined by Elizabeth of England, and with the haughty Guise blood surging hot within her,...

The disquisitions on art, life, religion, morals and the corruption

The Spectator

of society which Mr. Dreiser pours forth with special reference to the American scene in his book HO Rub-a-Dub-Dub (Constable, 7s. 6d.) are yet further example' of that...

Page 44

The contents of Amulets and Superstitions, by Sir E. A.

The Spectator

Wallis Budge (Humphrey Milford, 30s.), are professedly answers to some of the numerous questions which were put by the general public to the author, while he was keeper of the...

" He (James Whitcombe Riley) met me in a red

The Spectator

under- phirt and black trousers, busily adjusting gold studs in the bosom of a hard-boiled shirt " is an extract from Mr. Hamli n Garland's Roadside Meetings (Lane, 12s. 6d.)....

Two new B.B.C. pamphlets at threepence each are The Census

The Spectator

and Science in the Making ; they relate to talks being given at 7.25 and 8.0 p.m. respectively, every Tuesday until March 24th. The first pamphlet is by Mr. Gerald Heard, and...

Carl Akeley, zoologist and hunter (the - order is deliberate) was

The Spectator

firmly convinced that the game of Africa is doomed to extinction within the next few years, thanks to economic development and to the modern rifle - wedded in an unholy alliance...

A Hundred Years of English Poetry, selected by Edward B.

The Spectator

Powley (Cambridge University Press, 4s. 6d.) should prove of use to students and others. Palgrave's Golden Treasury was published in 1855, and in the early pages of his book Mr....

Father W. Schmidt's " original views " on comparative religion

The Spectator

(as the wrapper Characterizes them) are so well known to students of ethnology that the scholarly translation pro- vided by Professor IL J. Rose under the title The Origin and...

The Hogarth Press have published three more of their Day

The Spectator

to Day Pamphlets, the first of which was Mr. Maurice Dobb's interesting and informative pamphlet on Russia To-day and To-morrow (1s. 6d.). No. 4 also deals with Russia : it is...

It is a pleasure to welcome a dainty piece of

The Spectator

scholarly work from the United States. A Walk to Horace's Farm is published in Oxford (B. Blackwell, 6s.), but Mr. E. K. Rand hails from Cambridge, Massuchusetts, where the...

Mr. Langdon-Davies referred in his Gramophone Notes in last week's

The Spectator

issue of the Spectator to a selection of records recommended by Mr. A. C. de Busay. The name should have been Mr. A. D. C. D de BrisaT. - _ — _

A happy, likeable book is Harry Randall : Old Time

The Spectator

Come- dian. By Himself. (Sampson Low, 12s. 641.). For thirty 'years this clever mirth-provoking artist has been convulsing music-hall and other audiences with plain honest fun,...

Page 46

The Modern Home

The Spectator

British Cotton Fabrics BY MRS. E. V. LUCAS. , • Tim British Cotton Textile Exhibition which closed on February 28th could scarcely have been more attractive d ither in the...

General Knowledge Questions

The Spectator

OUR weekly prize of one guinea for the best thirteen Questioni submitted is awarded this week to Mr. Louis de Winton, Linford, Ringwood, Hampshire, for the following :— ....

Page 48

Answers to Questions on Relations and in-laws I. By marrying

The Spectator

his mother's brother's wife's sister.-2. She was my second-cousin ; married my mother's brother, who deceased. and -then myself.-3. I was a widower, and my son married my second...

Travel

The Spectator

The C.P.R. Jubilee FOR Mr. Kipling, " Romance -brings up the 9.145." There is assuredly romance in the jubilee of the Canadian Pacific Railway Company, which has ,just been...

Page 50

Finance—Public & Private

The Spectator

Railways, the Public and the Investor POSSIBLY by the time that this article is in print the Award will have been given in the matter of the recent discussion with regard to...

Page 54

AN EXCELLENT REPORT.

The Spectator

In these days of industrial depression it is encouraging come across so cheerful a report as that recently published Thomas Tilling, Ltd. Indeed, in some respects Industrials...

Financial Notes

The Spectator

A BETTER FEELING. IN spite of the wintry elements out of doors, there has bee a touch of Spring in the air on the Stock Exchange, and uncle the influence of a slightly more...

Page 56

REFUGE ASSURANCE.

The Spectator

The Report, which was placed before shareholders and policy-holders of the Refuge Assurance Company at the recent meeting was a thoroughly satisfactory one. Both in the Ordin-...

Scorrisu Winows.

The Spectator

Remarkable progress continues to' be made by the Scottish Widow's Fund and Life Assurance Society, and for last year the new business established a fresh high record, the total...

A PROSPEROUS BUILDING SOCIETY.

The Spectator

The Report of the Abbey Road Building Society for the past year shows that the rate of progress noticeable. for some years was increased in 1930. The number of share- holders...

SELFRIDGES.

The Spectator

Not unnaturally the heads of some of our big Stores have felt it incumbent upon them to take up the point which has been raised in many quarters with regard to the lag in retail...