1 MARCH 1930

Page 1

The Covenant, as- it, stands, • admits—in Articles 12,o w

The Spectator

13, and 15—the possibility of res ort - tar in certain . circumstances. These ' circumstances are when three months have elapsed after the th e of a judicial decision . - or...

News of the Week

The Spectator

The Covenant and the Pact T HE lull in the Naval Conference has been in one respect , a blessing. Public opinion has had a chance . to see beyond the technicalities ',based on...

EDITORIAL AND PUBLISHING OFFICES 99 - Cower Street, London, W.C. Subscription

The Spectator

to the SPECTATOR costs Thirty Shillings per annum, including postage, to any part of the porta. The SPECTATOR is registered as a Newspaper. The Postage on this issue is : Inland...

Here, as we see it, is the fundamental issue—the con-

The Spectator

flict between the psychological and the material schools of peace. The conflict is between those who would base the League on-mutual confidence, and those who still interpret...

We agree with M. Briand, and we note with satisfaction

The Spectator

that the critical importance of the present controversy is appreciated in this country, at least. It has been under- lined by several letters in the Times and the Manchester...

Page 2

The Downfall of M. Chautemps On Friday, February 21st, M.

The Spectator

Chautemps formed the new French Ministry. The President, M. Doumergue, had naturally turned first to him because it was he, at the head of the Radical-Socialists, who had done...

It would - indeed be ridiculous to - despair of the

The Spectator

Con- ference while many possibilities remain unexamined. For example,' the very formidable claims of Trance to an increase of naval building might well be' modified by some kind...

Moreover, as Dr. Delisle Burns pointed out, the experi- ence

The Spectator

of the last ten years has proved to what extent Governments can act together with advantage to their citizens, and to what extent already attempts to co- operate, under the...

The Naval Conference The prolonged French crisis means more delay

The Spectator

for the Naval Conference. On Wednesday the Conference had to decide whether to have a few more days' holiday in the hope that a new French Ministry would then be able to send...

The Japanese General Election The Liberal Government in Japan has

The Spectator

had a great success at the General Election. It has won 273 seats against the 174 of the Conservatives. This is a much larger majority than the Conservatives had. when they were...

Apart from the justifiable unwillingness of the British Government to

The Spectator

enter into any Pact on the Locarno model, such a proposal was ruled out by the Prime Minister before the Conference began. We are not sufficiently informed to say what the...

European Tariffs Conference The path to concerted economic action is

The Spectator

as arduous as the path to peace and disarmament. The essential quality for the traveller is confidence. A beginning in the creation of confidence has been made with the...

Page 3

Co-operation in the Cotton Industry The Joint Committee of Cotton

The Spectator

Trade Organizations has at last produced a scheme for more efficient production and marketing. A new body is to be created called the British Cotton Trade Textile Association....

British Shipping Mr. 3. H. Thomas at the annual dinner

The Spectator

of the Chamber of Shipping summarized the positiOn of the industry by saying that as compared with the days before - the War, freights had declined by . sixteen per cent. and...

The Crown and the Income Tax Payer In an Income

The Spectator

Tax appeal before the House of Lords on Tuesday Lord Dunedin delivered a very strong and welcome judgment. The appeal was by the Crown against a decision which would have saved...

Austrian Diplomacy . - The Austrian Chancellor, Herr Schober, seems

The Spectator

to be as successful with Austria's external difficulties as he has been with her Constitutional troubles. It is stated that the obstacles which have long prevented the signing...

Bank Rate, 4} per cent., changed from 5 per cent.

The Spectator

on February 6th, 1930. War Loan (5 per cent.) was on Wednesday 102 rs ; on Wednesday week, 1011 ; a year ago, 101* ; Funding Loan (4 per cent.) was on Wednesday 871 on Wednesday...

Pacing Trade Realities The untiring Mr. F. W. Goodenough continues

The Spectator

to tell those home truths about British salesmanship which have long been glossed over or evaded. On Friday, February 21st, he spoke at the Oxford Luncheon Club, _which usefully...

The Preservation of Rural Amenities On Friday, February 21st, Sir

The Spectator

Hilton Young obtained an unchallenged second reading for his Rural Amenities Bill. The Bill is necessary because local authorities have not used their power to pass by-laws....

Page 4

Our Business Statesmen and the Empire T ORD ROTHERMERE has

The Spectator

said that he trusts Lord Beaverbrook because he is a " business statesman." As Lord Rothermere, Lord Beaverbrook's collaborator, is contributing as much to the policy of the...

Page 5

Towards a National Housing Survey

The Spectator

M R. ARTHUR GREENWOODwill soon bring his long-expected Housing Bill before a House of Commons which is perhaps' better :qualified than any Parliament of recent years to give...

Page 6

The Week in Parliament

The Spectator

A LARUMS and excursions continue without. The Prime Minister has withdrawn from the I.L.P., a gesture of doubtful wisdom which will certainly involve a recrudescence of activity...

Prosperity Without Protection

The Spectator

Rationalize Markets—II A PREVIOUS article suggested that if rationalization, now so commonly invoked as the remedy for unemployment and depression, is to avoid the perhaps...

Page 8

In Defence of the Faith

The Spectator

XV.—Nature and Personality [The writer of this article, Dr. David Cairns, is a distinguished Scottish theologian. He has been Moderator of the Uitited Free Church and is...

Page 9

Russia's "Anti-God " Campaign in Practice

The Spectator

ONSTITUTION .\I, freedom of religion in Russia still exists, though modified by the decree of 1929. In judicial practice one finds little which does not accord with this...

Page 10

The Humorous Poets

The Spectator

T HERE was once a learned if rather pompous verse- maker, who laid it down that humour could have rio place in purely poetic expression. What he thought of, for instance, " The...

Page 11

Our Modest Utopia—A Farm in Provence

The Spectator

W E never took seriously the fantastic scheme of our V V friends to become farmers in the South of France. But they were so pressing and so enthusiastic about it that soinehow,...

Page 12

The Theatre

The Spectator

[" CHARLES AND MARY." BY JOAN TEMPLE. AT TIIE GLOBE THEATRE. " MICHAEL AND MARY." By A. A. MILNE. AT THE ST. JAMES'S THEATRE.] LET me wish full success to Miss Joan Temple's...

Capital Punishment

The Spectator

Essay Competition THE Select Committee of the House of Commons appointed to consider the question of Capital Punish- ment has been meeting weekly since the end of January. In...

THE SPECTATOR.

The Spectator

Before going abroad or away from home readers are advised to place an order for the SPECTATOR. The journal will be forwarded to any address at the following rates :- One Month •...

Page 13

Music

The Spectator

MAKING Music POPULAR. SIR HENRY Wool) has always been associated with the A3opu- larizirig of music in this country. The history of the Pro- menades " is largely the history of...

Correspondence

The Spectator

A LETTER FROM ROME. [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—Signor Mussolini did not, in spite of widespread expecta- tion, pay his first visit to the Pope on the anniversary of...

DIRECT subscribers who are changing their addresses are asked to

The Spectator

tiotify the SPECTATOR OffiCe BEFORE MIDDAY on MONDAY or EACH WEER. The previous address to which the paper has been sent and receipt reference number should be quoted.

Page 14

A Hundred Years Ago

The Spectator

THE SPECTATOR," FEBRUARY 27TH, 1830. GALT'S LAWRIE TODD. Oh that all real autobiographies were like this piece of admirable fiction ! would that they were even as true we...

The Mountain

The Spectator

Though it was noonday, and high summer, With tolerant warmth roaming through the town, Our hands, in touching, touched a ghost. Quickly we looked, ' to see if each had heard,...

Page 15

CHICAGO.

The Spectator

The bankruptcy of the city's finances is not deterring Chiciigo from going ahead with preparations for its World's Fair, although New York, influenced by the failure of...

* * * * THE CONFERENCE.

The Spectator

Official Washington is not pessimistic over the outlook for the Naval Conference. It is believed that there will be an agreement, with a net result that will be a saving to tax-...

THE BAUMES LAWS.

The Spectator

The Baumes Laws, whereby four successive convictions for felony in New . York State automatically condenm the offender to imprisonment for life, are once more the subject of...

CONGRESS AND THE DRUG TRAFFIC.

The Spectator

An object lesson in international interdependence has been afforded to Congress, recently, in connexion with its efforts to stamp out the illicit traffic in narcotic drugs....

American Notes of the Week

The Spectator

(By Cable) M. BRLAND AND THE SENATE. M. Briand's reported intention to ask that, in order to avoid appealing to the Senate, President Hoover should issue a presidential...

RELIGIOUS PERSECUTION IN RUSSIA.

The Spectator

Vigorous protestS continue to be made here at the reported religious persecutions in Russia. An influential committee has petitioned-the President to make it clear that the...

Page 16

The League of Nations

The Spectator

A Study in Co-operation TnE Bank of International Settlements has been described as a " financial League of Nations." There is, it is true, no official connexion between the...

Page 17

A MEDITATED Zoo.

The Spectator

The supreme fitness of Whipsnadc—the new country branch of the Regent's Park Zoo—is so sharp a contrast, with its hill and woods, to the narrow, fiat fields of Sununertown that...

Country Life

The Spectator

Tim SPANISH PEASANT. .I have been seeing something.of country life in Spain ; and the abrupt contrasts_ between rich lands and poor lands ; fields bearing sugar cane, the...

WINTER-CLEANING.

The Spectator

The habit that housewives call spring-cleaning is being generally adopted by fruit-gardeners, but they anticipate the date. Winter-cleaning becoMes one of themoSt important and...

NORFOLK BIRDS.

The Spectator

If any naturalist desires quaint and suggestive reading about birds he should read the humble, but rich, little pamphlet of the Wild Birds' Protection Society of the Norfolk and...

One example of the sharp contrast between races in such

The Spectator

things must have appealed to all who were present, A little crowd was on the seashore watching the fishermen drawing in their nets, all silvered with shoals of whitebait,and...

TRAPPED BIRDS.

The Spectator

It is, perhaps, no wonder that people so poor should kill even the smallest birds for food. Though Spain is, in parts, the richest country in Europe for many bigger birds, I...

* * The difference of latitude of course falsifies any

The Spectator

argument drawn from one country to the other. Though you have no money and scarcely a house, can you be said to be poor if you may sit in the sun and suck an orange ? Is a...

Page 18

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

THE UNITED EMPIRE PARTY [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—I think it was John Jorrocks who said that the best way to keep a pack of hounds together was " to kill off the...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sirt,—I have in despair

The Spectator

joined the Beaverbrook Party, because I am a Conservative and Mr. Baldwin is not. Here are my reasons : j1) Home Rule fen India without consulting colleagues ; (2) Votes for...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sra,—Let it be said at once that this is not criticism of what Lord Beaverbrook calls " the ultimate ideal " of " complete and unrestricted Free Trade within the Empire." It...

Page 19

THE CHURCH OF ENGLAND AND REUNION [To the Editor of

The Spectator

the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—Mr. Pollard's letter iri your issue of February 15th . on " Reunion " is a curious mixture of unproved dogmatic asser- tion and serious historical blunder....

THE COVENANT AND THE PACT [To the Editor of the

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.] SIR, —Everyone must, I imagine, endorse your welcome given to various letters in the Times insisting that public opinion must express itself more clearly through the...

CHILDREN'S RENT ALLOWANCES [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Srit,—Mr. W. L. Hare's letter in your issue of February 22nd launches a violent attack on children's rent allowances. Mr. Hare " takes his stand " on a series Of propositions...

Page 20

GERMAN EAST AFRICA AS BRITISH MANDATED TERRITORY

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—On February Ilth, Dr. Schnee, member of the Reichstag and ex-Governor of German East Africa, delivered a lecture - to the Society of...

[To the Editor of the SPECT_ATOR.I. • a letter which

The Spectator

appeared in your issue of February 15th , from the Anglican Chaplain at Istanbul,-he gives an interesting . account of. his relations with.the Orthodox Church and its...

Page 21

YET ANOTHER OUTLOOK ON INDIA

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—It has constantly been pointed out and explained that India is made up of what is practically a collection of different nations like...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,— Reproduced below is the

The Spectator

closing sentence of Gandhi's appeal to his English friends in the issue of January 23rd 'of his weekly, Young India.–"But whatever I do and 'whatever, happens, my English...

AN APPEAL FOR CO-OPERATION AND SERVICE

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—In view of the formation of the Economic Council with the object of increasing production and promoting employment, may I be allowed to...

THE SITUATION IN INDIA [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sns,—Your correspondent, " Twenty Nine years in India," would dispose once for all of the "die-hard position by asserting : " However much we may dislike the pledge of 1917, it...

Page 22

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

:SIR, —I think we are all tired of these futile arguments as to ,whether it is cruel or not to keep animals in cages. If we would give up thinking of what pleases or interests...

WOES OF THE CAGED

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] do not intend to continue this correspondence, as I venture to think that I have made my arguments sufficiently clear and cogent ; Mr. Cather...

SEATS FOR SHOP ASSISTANTS

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—It was pleasing to hear from Capt. Larking that his . Early Closing Association was largely responsible for the passing of the " Seats for...

POINTS FROM LETTERS

The Spectator

INTERNATIONAL EDUCATIONALSOCIETY. . _I think you will be interested to hear that, for the conveni- ence of Members of this Society, a Circulating Library of our lecture-records...

Page 23

FINANCIAL SUPPLEMENT

The Spectator

BANKING AND INSURANCE No. 5,305.1 WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, MARCH 1, 1930. [GRATIS

Page 25

London as a Monetary Centre

The Spectator

Will it be Challenged ? THAT many of our industries at the present time are suffering from keen' foreign competition is generally recognized. Is there a prospect of our great...

Page 26

Banking in 1929

The Spectator

IT may be doubted whether either during or since the War there has been a much more difficult . yeaf for banking than the one which has recently closed. It is popularly supposed...

Page 31

Bankers and Industry

The Spectator

POSSIBLY before the .Spectator supplement of a year hence has been issued there will have been published the Report of Mr. Snowden's .Committee which is now sitting to inquire...

Page 33

Security of Capital

The Spectator

EVENTS on the Stock Exchange during - the last few months have caused investors radically to revise their ideas of investing money. In order to avoid the high rate of income-tax...

Page 35

The Building Society Movement To-day

The Spectator

THE closing months of the past year brought disquiet and alarm to the financial world and created pronounced uneasiness among small capitalists rendered apprehensive by...

Buying a House

The Spectator

No better investment can be made than the purchase of a house for personal occupation. Nor is it necessary to possess more than a small proportion of the purchase money in order...

Page 38

London: Printed by W., SPEAIGIST AND Soss. LTD., 98 and

The Spectator

99 Fetter Lane, E.C. 4, and Published by THE SPECTATOR, Lie., at their Offices, No. 99 Gower Street, London W.C. 1.—Saturday, Marzh, 1, .1930.

Page 39

Like Hawkins and Drake to the Spaniards, no two men

The Spectator

seem to have struck the Romans with more real terror than Hamilcar and Hannibal, his greater son—the most formidable • menaces that (till later ages) the Roman commonwealth...

• Miss F. L. Turner is becoming known as a

The Spectator

trustworthy observer of bird,life and a writer on nature refreshingly simple and unaffected. She must be tired of being referred to as the one-time loneliest woman in England,"...

Mrs. Thorp's Verses (The Cayme Press, 5s.) are unequal. In

The Spectator

this particular she is indeed in good company—of what poet may not the same be said ? " The Hope of a Caged Lark " soars to our minds above her other pieces. The poor bird who "...

A salade de saison should be dressed not more than

The Spectator

ten minutes before its consumption with one-third vinegar (wine vinegar, of course) to two-thirds oil, freshly ground pepper and salt. Monsieur X. Marcel Boulestin and Mr. Jason...

Specialists in Jacobite history will like to know that Mi.

The Spectator

Duncan Warrand has edited a fourth volume of More Culloden Papers (Inverness : R. Carruthers, 15s.), drawri from the correspondence of Duncan Forbes of Culloden, the Lord...

Mr. Ralph Nevill has written his best book in The

The Spectator

Gay Victorians (Nash and Grayson, 21$.), and his best is very good as his worst is—not so good. We have found, in previous volumes by Mr. Nevill, occasional inaccuracies and-...

Some Books of the Week

The Spectator

DURING the past month the books most in. demand at the Times Book Club have been :— - FICTION :--Shepherds in Sackcloth, by Sheila Kaye-Smith ; Her Privates We, by Private 19022...

As an example of the popular fiction of a century

The Spectator

ago, when the Spectator was young, John Roby's Traditions of Lanca- shire (Warne, 7s. 6d.) is not without interest. This volume is a reprint, with the romantic illustrations, of...

The Competition

The Spectator

EVERYBODY is talking about the Italian Pictures. The Editor therefore offers a prize for the most entertaining or illuminating comment on them, or anecdote referring to them,...

The Spectator

Page 40

Conquistadores Then and Now

The Spectator

IF it is true that between genius and madness there exists a near alliance, was Columbus mad ? There is a sub-suggestion running all through Herr Wassermann's brilliant study of...

Page 41

A European Landscape Europe in Zigzags. By Sisley Huddleston. (Harrap.

The Spectator

2 la.) IN the course of these wanderings through post-War European history Mr. Huddleston goes from Spain to Italy, from Italy to Austria, and thence by way of Eastern and...

Page 42

Economic History

The Spectator

Women 'Workers and the Industrial Revolution. By Ivy ' Pinchbeck. (15s.) A History of the English Coin Laws from 1660 to 1846. By Donald Grove Barnes. (15s.) - THE rapid growth...

Page 45

The Aramaic Gospel

The Spectator

THE veteran scholar, Gustaf Delman, occupies a unique place among New Testament specialists. His wide erudition, his special knowledge of Rabbinical literature, and of...

The Story of a Vocation The Army. By Lt.-Gen. Sir

The Spectator

George MacMunn. The Stage By Lena Ashwell. The Architect. By C. Williams-Ellis. (Geoffrey 13Ies. 5s. each.) To judge from these first three volumes, Mr. Geoffrey Bles's new Life...

Page 46

THE WHISTLER'S ROOM. By Paul Alverdes. (Seeker. 5s.)—There is a.

The Spectator

quality of mingled cruelty and tenderness in this short and moving story. The scene is laid in a Gentian 4rillitary hospital during the War. In a special ward, kept apart from...

Some Grave, Some Gay

The Spectator

Tins is a second selection of pocket literature provided by the Times for the men in the trenches during the War. They were intended to be " a numerous and varied selection of...

Fiction

The Spectator

Past, Present, and Gerhardi ! Pending Heaven. By William Gerhardi. (Duckworth. 7s. 6d.) WE have certainly no quarrel with the Book Society's latest choice. Kristin...

REGENCY WINDOWS. By Mr. David Emerson. (Samp- son Low. 7s.

The Spectator

6d.)—Taking as his epigraph Lord. Chesterfield's opinion that " modes and customs vary often, but that human nature is always the same," Mr. David Emerson has given in Regency...

Page 49

HALF MAST MURDER, by Milward Kennedy. (Gollancz. 7s. &L)—The remarkable

The Spectator

thing about this Story is That the characters in it appear to be human beings : that is, they are neither wholly good, wholly bad, nor- wholly consistent in either. This virtue...

The Council on Foreign Relations, whose Survey of American Foreign

The Spectator

Relations in 1929 we recently reviewed, have issued a new volume of their Political Handbook of the World (1930), edited_ by Walter II. Mallory. This publication affords a most...

MURDER YET TO COME, by Isabel Briggs Myers. (Gollancz. 7s.

The Spectator

6d.)—One has come to look for Messrs. Gollancz's yellow wrappers as an efficient guide in the search for a good detective story. This one has already been acclaimed winner of a...

In his introduction to The Bookworm's Turn, a pamphlet which

The Spectator

outlines the intentions of the Book Guild (50 Farringdon Street, E.C. 4), Mr. Thomas Burke defines the public for which this new society caters as " that large intermediate...

Much enthusiasm and industry have gone to the making of

The Spectator

the two substantial volumes on Flemish Influence in Britain, by the well-known Scottish potter, Mr. J. Arnold Fleming (Glasgow : Jackson, Wylie, 80s.). The first volume is a...

General Knowledge Questions

The Spectator

oun weekly prize of one guinea for the best thirteen Questions submitted is awarded this week to Mr. E. W. Brittain, 93 Woodroyd Road, West Bowling, Bradford, for the following...

* * * *

The Spectator

A publication which will be written down as dull by most of us, but which is nevertheless important, is the International Survey of Legal Decisions on Labour Law (1928)...

Readers who are making any study of social and sociological

The Spectator

questions to-day will find the monthly International Labour Review indispensable. It may be obtained from Messrs. George Allen and Unwin, price 2s. (id. The January number...

More Books of the Week

The Spectator

(Continued from page 335.) How often do we hear people complaining impatiently about the tons and guns, protocols and optional clauses, &c., which the diligence of journalists...

Page 50

Travel

The Spectator

Dangerous Tyres A GREAT deal has recently been said on the subject of road deaths. Now, as everything seems to have been said- many times-the subject shows ' signs of dying a...

Firiance-PubliCr . & - Private

The Spectator

Bankers' Profits IN our Banking Supplement, which will be found in an earlier part of this issue, an analysis is made of _ the main items in bankers' _balance-sheets at the end...

[ We printed at the loot of: the article in

The Spectator

the SPECTATOR dated February 22nd on " -The .White _ Beaches -of Mallorca," some par- liculari as to travel .fatlilities and the address of the Spanish Travel Hurea ti eig 87 -...

Page 53

A New Government Loan - Although Mr. Snowden has only

The Spectator

been in office for a little more than six months,, we have now seen two Government Loans issued under his Chancellorship. The first was in November of last year, when, it will...

Financial Notes

The Spectator

INVESTMENT STOCKS FIRM. ALTHOUGH the Stock Markets as a whole have been quiet and rather dull during the past week, an outstanding feature has been the firmness of British...

STEADY PROFIT EXPANSION.

The Spectator

At the recent meeting of Selfridge & Company, the Chairman, Mr. Gordon Selfridge, had an inspiring statement of profits to put before the shareholders. After setting out the...

Seorrisn WIDOWS' RESULTS.

The Spectator

The Report for the past year of the Scottish Widows' Fund and Life Assurance Society is a good one, though the net new sums assured of £2,899,759 compare with £8,178,220 a year...

THE "OFFICIAL INTELLIGENCE."

The Spectator

The 1980 edition- of The Stock Exchange Official Intelligence will be published on March 25th. The Official InteUi4ence, I am asked to state. is the only work of its kind that...

A PEARL BONUS.

The Spectator

The splendid surplus shown in the latest valuation in the Industrial branch of the Pearl Assurance Company may be regarded as the outcome of a sound policy pursued over a number...